Mafiascum.net

Interesting choice, but okay.

I feel like you're trying to find a place to vote that's not you/creature. I didn't think you'd be satisfied by my reasons, I normally hate using bad logic as a scumtell and you never really did either iirc. My reasons were surface level enough that I think you'd have noticed it without me having to explain it.

VOTE: gamma

i was debating whether poe meant that alch was an ok wagon even if i think the read is weak and i dont really like gamma's vote or if i should ignore the wagon or even push back on gamma. im glad to see im not the only one who thought gamma's vote was strange though. it felt opportunistic to say the least.

Not that I didn't get scumpings from alchemist from that post, but I don't think they were strong enough to really convince town!gamma (even with the meta argument)

It is defensive though. It looks like you were trying to undermine the other person’s read on the slot. I think “hatcheting” is the term Flavor Leaf uses for it. The tone of your post doesn’t seem like you were trying to get a read or a better understanding of Senshi, it seemed more like you were already a bit dismissive of their pun read.

In post 226, Infinity 324 wrote:I feel like you're trying to find a place to vote that's not you/creature. I didn't think you'd be satisfied by my reasons, I normally hate using bad logic as a scumtell and you never really did either iirc. My reasons were surface level enough that I think you'd have noticed it without me having to explain it.

yep this. like i feel that infinity voting alch would have been ok. but gamma hopped on without really contributing any analysis of his own.

In post 229, Alchemist21 wrote:It is defensive though. It looks like you were trying to undermine the other person’s read on the slot. I think “hatcheting” is the term Flavor Leaf uses for it. The tone of your post doesn’t seem like you were trying to get a read or a better understanding of Senshi, it seemed more like you were already a bit dismissive of their pun read.

thats not how i saw the post tbh. can you explain a bit more? what is hatcheting

In post 229, Alchemist21 wrote:It is defensive though. It looks like you were trying to undermine the other person’s read on the slot. I think “hatcheting” is the term Flavor Leaf uses for it. The tone of your post doesn’t seem like you were trying to get a read or a better understanding of Senshi, it seemed more like you were already a bit dismissive of their pun read.

This was a response to 221.

In post 231, Tayl0r Swift wrote:

In post 229, Alchemist21 wrote:It is defensive though. It looks like you were trying to undermine the other person’s read on the slot. I think “hatcheting” is the term Flavor Leaf uses for it. The tone of your post doesn’t seem like you were trying to get a read or a better understanding of Senshi, it seemed more like you were already a bit dismissive of their pun read.

thats not how i saw the post tbh. can you explain a bit more? what is hatcheting

I defined it in that post. Trying to undermine someone’s read on a slot. It’s like a more subtle version of chainsaw defending.

Opportunistic is a fair thing to call my vote, but I did contribute some real thoughts there

In post 233, Alchemist21 wrote: I defined it in that post. Trying to undermine someone’s read on a slot. It’s like a more subtle version of chainsaw defending.

I still don't see how you think that, but ok

The "or what" was giving SS an opportunity to explain what their take was

In post 223, Gamma Emerald wrote:That lines up with what I generally expect from scum Alchemist, he has a genuine solviness as town that he has to fake to varying degrees of success as scum
VOTE: Alchemist

you place your vote but theres no analysis of whether you think he's faking the solviness with success or just town. i guess you think hes not looking solvy? but theres no mention of why you think that. its a very surface level read

It's early so I don't have much data, but the things I've seen from Alchemist don't particularly inspire confidence in him yet
Mostly I just wanted to form a wagon, which is why I'm not too bothered by being voted rn, as the wagon just isn't on the person I'd originally planned

In post 237, Gamma Emerald wrote:It's early so I don't have much data, but the things I've seen from Alchemist don't particularly inspire confidence in him yet
Mostly I just wanted to form a wagon, which is why I'm not too bothered by being voted rn, as the wagon just isn't on the person I'd originally planned

this seems like a walkback from your earlier more confident sounding stance. i agree with the rest actually though.

Taylor what’s your read on me now?

strong town

ive seen what i want to see from a town!infinity

I’m suspicious but ok

we mindmelded over gamma.

I did say I was giving out free townpoints, I also see how you could really townread me for the past couple pages but it seemed a bit fast

PEdit: ok

i mean yeah its page 10, but i am sometimes able to identify townies pretty fast. especially given that we've played a bunch together recently and i feel good about knowing how to sort you.

am i wrong to townread you infinity?

Nvm keep it up <3

hehe ok

The fact you say you mindmelded makes me a bit uneasy about this but whatever