Wayward Son wrote: In post 50, Xlos wrote:Random is a lame reason to vote for someone IMO. It doesn't really encourage any discussion or have inspire any fear of being lynched. Even the first post of the thread had a reason to vote for someone! So that's my reason to
Even votes with a reason during RVS are random and searching, if your are town.
I'm struggling to make sense of
58. The connection is "not too convincing", making me think Zyla is town.
I explained the quoted post in
131 . I don't understand why the second one makes you think Zyla is town, though? Is a light scum lean equal to a town lean?
Wayward Son wrote:
He never, correct me if I'm wrong, never justifies the vote on bulge. He just goes after T3 from there on out.
Oh, I voted bulge cause I asked him a question. People are more likely to answer your question if you stick your vote on them.
In post 240, Wayward Son wrote: In post 173, Xlos wrote:It's gut reading man... given that I'm not a mason with T3, I can't imagine why the man doesn't want to say why he thinks anything. It's not like he'll be alive D2 to explain, or like we will gain any insight on what he meant by killing him if he does turns out to be town. Maybe he's just tired.
For me this seals it. He tries to paint T3 town in his posts. A lot.
VOTE: Xlos
Oh come on, you didn't quote the punchline of this post, I thought it was funny
Of course the post looks like I think T3 is super town without the punchline.
This post aside, it's true that I wasn't actively going after T3, so I can try to explain my reasoning in more detail. After I read the first two pages of the thread, T3 seemed somewhat suspicious, considering all the points lukewarm make against him and his lackluster responses. But people were digging into his case, and as I don't have that much time to post each day, I figured the others would do a better job of it than me and tried to go for breadth rather than depth, so I tried to look elsewhere for anything that looked fishy. Hence why I was digging into Zyla/Bulge. And as the day progressed, it became more and more obvious that we were just going to kill T3 without any resistance, which is sad. If everyone agrees to kill someone as soon as the thread starts, and then we kill them, it's not really helpful to look back on the next day. Hence why I tried to look at other people, after a certain point, I just considered T3 dead. He was my #1 suspect, too, there just wasn't any point in putting a vote on him. Later in the day, he was just very clearly going to die. If I were mafia, I don't think I would want to be defending someone who was about to flip mafia.
Let's also talk about the last post T3 made that Wayward pointed out:
In post 239, Wayward Son wrote: In post 157, T3 wrote:Xlos is town and I don't want to say why.
Mixlixwix saying there are more than 2 people I find scummy is towny.
This is also slightly condemning.
How condemning this is, of course, depends on how many levels deep you think T3 is at the time. I think that T3 suspected he was slated to die at this point, so giving positive reads to his scum buddy is a pretty daring move.
That said, I'm not positive if T3 thought he was going to die. Since
wasn't a claim that could draw town power out. Though, he did seem to think that he had already found town power
In post 186, T3 wrote:fwiw Xlos and Zyla slipped as masons. Don't trust any prs claims.
But I personally don't see the slip that me and Zyla supposedly made. And since we weren't killed, does mafia even believe the claim T3 made? One possible reason that Roden was killed was because his agreement with T3 about me and Zyla being masons were seems a pretty town-power move, maybe he was trying to redirect the nightkill to one of us cause he knows we aren't masons. But maybe not, at the bottom of this post I have another possible reason.
I've given a lot (too much) thought to the idea that T3 and Zyla are evil and T3 pinned her with me for some reason, but it just doesn't seem that reasonable. I won't subject you to too much analysis about this for now, though.
I think that Mix is looking very town due to the time he spent constructing a case against Roden. Why try so hard to build a case against a dead man? Unless mafia didn't know who they were going to kill at that time. But still, I really don't see why mafia Mix would kill Roden. I can see Egix killing Roden very easily, though, since Roden was going very hard against him at the end. And nobody else had that much suspicion on Egix besides Roden.
Consider the other choices: Lukewarm who is as close to confirmed town as it gets, and me/Zyla who are suspected to be town power. I think that, to kill someone else, mafia would need to have something big to gain. And the only person who gains from killing Roden (and gains a lot) is Egix.
VOTE: Egix