Mafiascum.net

In post 101, imaginality wrote:All of which is to say the "if you flipped scum I could consider it" seems more likely to me to come from scum talking to town than from town. Scum talking to town know the first part of the statement ("if you flip scum" can't occur so are more likely to give a careless consequence "I could consider it", compared with town who believe it's a genuine possibility to consider.

In post 225, Wisdom wrote:Ali you wanna live?
Read my points about Imaginality and vote there

In post 152, Wisdom wrote:Yeah I know townies get fixated on "scumslips" and push them forever, I've done it myself a couple times

I don't know, I kind of disliked his tone in pushing it, for example his appeal to people to judge whether I am inno or guilty for my statement felt a little manipulative

In post 153, Wisdom wrote:But again Imaginality is the one person I haven't played with in this playerlist so I could be disliking playstyle

In post 155, Wisdom wrote:

In post 107, imaginality wrote:So it's up to the rest of you whether you think that's because Taly is so obvtown, or because Wisdom is scum and knows Taly is town.

Like this is suggestive, it's like he's saying "Taly is not obvtown so I don't believe Wisdom" but he's putting it more subtly so it immediately rings manipulation bells for me

In post 229, imaginality wrote:Even you admit your point is questionable.

In post 233, Wisdom wrote:Imaginality's tone still feels manipulative to me

In post 229, imaginality wrote:It's obvious I think Taly isn't obvtown (I do lean town in Taly but I don't see anyone as obvtown yet).

In post 229, imaginality wrote:It's obvious I think Taly isn't obvtown (I do lean town in Taly but I don't see anyone as obvtown yet).

In post 229, imaginality wrote:Whereas this push on me is a point against you, it fits the 'scum wanting to get players who are suspicious of them eliminated' motif.

Not how I'd have expected town to respond to what I said. My vote is staying on you.

In post 238, Wisdom wrote:Like this is trying to convince others that I am not town
He does not care to actually engage with me and figure if I am town

In post 209, Taly wrote:

In post 186, the worst wrote:

In post 183, Taly wrote:

In post 179, Bingle wrote:

In post 177, the worst wrote:

In post 146, Bingle wrote:

In post 144, Wisdom wrote:

In post 127, Taly wrote:The reason I point this out is because I read the bolded as though you knew I was 8ball. A potential slip. That's what I want clarified.

No, you misread. Imaginality was talking about the possibility of you being scum and 8ball, and that's what I was responding to

Just gonna cut this off at the knees: That was 100% not a scum slip. When discussing the hypothetical that you are the eightball, the presumption that you would flip 8 ball is natural.

Hopefully we don't have a week long argument about whether the obviously NAI post is a scumslip every game I'm scum in.

now

this

is a scumslip

But like, it reads like a potential slip to me too. Djdoxjsklsjshs

i'd be interested in you expanding, i've had growing concerns about bingle.

Just the

"every game I'm scum in"

sounds like an admission since it seemed

Bingle

presumed that the

Wisdom

post was a red herring. Why would the first part of that sentence be true but the next be false?

Like, I can't be misreading again can I?

And why hold off on those concerns ducky, you waiting for me to be your shield?

In post 210, imaginality wrote:

In post 199, the worst wrote:i think if i rolled scum with momrangal in this plist i'd encourage us to make mom the 8ball just for the 'venge'kill to counter swing
not because i think mom is bad. i just think mom is a slow burn player, and is unlikely to get a strong footing in d1 in this player list.

idrk how meaningful this is just sayin

In post 200, Alisae wrote:Well now ur more suspect because u knew that information and me/tw didn’t

In post 208, Bingle wrote:

In post 200, Alisae wrote:Well now ur more suspect because u knew that information and me/tw didn’t

Actually... unpack this for me?

The scum role PM is public, and it's me. Why would

me

knowing setup stuff be scum indicative at all? And haven't you played this setup before?

Wasn't Alisae replying to the worst, not you?
Although the point still applies, I don't see why #199 is suspicious.

In post 216, Taly wrote:

In post 146, Bingle wrote:Hopefully we don't have a week long argument about whether the obviously NAI post is a scumslip every game I play.

Omfg you're right. Apologies. Fucking duck.

IT'S LATE. I'M GOING TO BED.