Detective Penguin & City of Fogport [Game Over]

[chennisden]

Liek, it looks like Fish has been planning to A) lategame and B) look good off a pops scumflip/

[chennisden]

ofrhz [3] - popsofctown, Marquis, Judge Joseph Dredd
popsofctown [3] - Bingle x3
Judge Joseph Dredd [1] - ofrhz
Bingle [1] - PenguinPower
Day One Lynch [1] - Chandra Nalaar

These wagons can fuck off:

ofrhz
JJD
DOL

[chennisden]

No Marquis/Fish Monger can be S/S

I dunno if I think it strongly enough to not lynch pop

[chennisden]

This just hit me: WHAT IF the "unkillables" were really not? What if their PT effect does NOT stop a direct kill? I guess that would explain why they seem to TR each other today, under the false assumption that if scum knew that they would have certainly killed one of them.

^^That's not something I would think of. Blame the monkey man for planting the thought in my head.

you could be right. but this might not be an altogether productiev line of conversation.

[chennisden]

Hey guys talk to me. Who in this playerlist do you know generally prefers playing scum?

This feels fake

It's NAI. Some players nowadays try to ask this (or ask everyone to state what they prefer to play) to break the ice and try to decide if someone should be considered to be more likely scum based on the level of comfort they're showing. It doesn't work most of the time (in some cases it does, but usually only when you know the answer in advance).

On another note, if that Croag guy doesn't play the game properly for the next 72 hours I'm policy lynching him (and I almost never do PLs). All I see is him making excuses to not be present it's become overly and utterly ridiculous.

Id rather not do it now bc pops has way higher scum equity and pops scumgame is something I actually am looking out for.

If you've seen croag's last scumgame youll know croag is rly easy to kill as scum

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

IT'S OVER JJD I LOST AS SCUM OK

This gives me pause though. This is genuine frustration, I think. pops probably thought (wrongfully) that I was pushing her today.

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

IT'S OVER JJD I LOST AS SCUM OK

Btw, I still dunno what this refers to exactly. Did we have a recent game in which you were scum and I was killed and it just ended? Are you talking of some kind of a winning streak you had as scum that came to an end?? WHAT?

[Bingle]

Well, first thing's first: I'm the trillest.

UNVOTE:

This just hit me: WHAT IF the "unkillables" were really not? What if their PT effect does NOT stop a direct kill? I guess that would explain why they seem to TR each other today, under the false assumption that if scum knew that they would have certainly killed one of them.

This is provable, btw.

Vig who shot Fish shoots me tonight. This has the double effect of giving us a bullet proof conftown and proving our BP status.

Also, the conftown can then claim, be conftown and unkillable, and then survive to endgame thus neatly avoiding the issue of deepwolves. They don't even have to claim today. That this also means they get to see exactly why I've been acting the way I have is just gravy

The one way this is manipulable is if the CPR doc is scum and protected a buddy. Which would be fucking hilarious, and make a lot of sense.

[Bingle]

Btw, I still dunno what this refers to exactly. Did we have a recent game in which you were scum and I was killed and it just ended? Are you talking of some kind of a winning streak you had as scum that came to an end?? WHAT?

I read it as her mocking people thinking you're partners, either in an attempt to drag you with her or false spew you town, take your WIFOMy pick.

[Day One Wagon]

JJD, we all knew Kuribo was scum kill tonight, Bingle and co wasn't in any danger, scum has no real reason to be afraid of their multivotes either considering how cautious both of them were

Chen, I think Kagami is saying he knows why Fish died and it wasn't FL

JJD, that Pops message is about marathon i think

[Kagami]

I'm just using common sense.

Pine has claimed that Fish died by shooting kuribo when he "holstered," and FL had Fish as a strong townread all day yesterday.

[Bingle]

So there’s multiple all town neighborhoods?

4 scum. 5 neighborhoods. Either FG's garbage at setup and wants a :lolclears: thing going on or we can't assume cap of 1 scum per neighborhood. And yeah, for reasons that are even more clear with today's claims, I find it incredibly likely my neighborhood is all town.

[Bingle]

JJD's night action plan was 110% scum trying to get into our neighborhood and not get PL'd for it, btw.

[chennisden]

so why does he pretend to be convinced by the almighty chennis

[Bingle]

Pine, when you get a chance can you paraphrase what Fish said over night phase?

[Bingle]

so why does he pretend to be convinced by the almighty chennis

?

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

I'm just using common sense.

Pine has claimed that Fish died by shooting kuribo when he "holstered," and FL had Fish as a strong townread all day yesterday.

?? Where did Pine say that? I might have missed it, but what I recall Pine said kuribo was shot because he said he was acting on N1 (and hinting, but not explicitly stating that kuribo said he would be checking FM against a Miller claim to see if they appeared of the same alignment). It was the MOTIVE not the CAUSE. Did I misunderstand?

[Day One Wagon]

Speaking of which, JJD, can we lynch you now and follow your plan tonight? Even if scum kills one of us, we have Pine now. For people wondering - JJD offered his life after we join Bingle's hood

[chennisden]

so why does he pretend to be convinced by the almighty chennis

?

Why does he pretend that he changed his mind because of me then

[chennisden]

Speaking of which, JJD, can we lynch you now and follow your plan tonight? Even if scum kills one of us, we have Pine now. For people wondering - JJD offered his life after we join Bingle's hood

No how about we dont

[chennisden]

The lesson in fakegod setups is play conservatively and play mafia

The moment town stops playing mafia is the moment town loses

[Day One Wagon]

Speaking of which, JJD, can we lynch you now and follow your plan tonight? Even if scum kills one of us, we have Pine now. For people wondering - JJD offered his life after we join Bingle's hood

No how about we dont

Shhh, we'll just lynch him, but we won't follow with the plan. Keep that in secret and don't tell anybody

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

JJD's night action plan was 110% scum trying to get into our neighborhood and not get PL'd for it, btw.

So, lynch me today and find out for sure. How about we make this a gladiator-like thing between you and me?? I have no problem if I lose it because I know you will have to be lynched at some point after my flip.

[Vecna]

The fact Pops called out mine specifically when i feel it’s general consensus right now Bingle is likely scum is just surface level play on her part or scum orientated.

If she was trying to get you to shoot bingle it implies theyre not scum together since shed know bingle cannot be vigged.

[Bingle]

So, lynch me today and find out for sure. How about we make this a gladiator-like thing between you and me?? I have no problem if I lose it because I know you will have to be lynched at some point after my flip.

I have 0 problems with lynching you today.

As for your suggestion:

I'll take roles I've publicly mocked as being terrible for town to ever use, Alex.

Is the answer Gladiator? Nope? Well shit, it was doublevoter.