Mafiascum.net

Orc perfromed the kill because he was going to die.

Prod dodge. Just a sec.

don't you prod me

Maraca's claim is one that could pretty easily is faked (and looks to be). Apart from most of the case that people have already posted, it's something that can easily be correlated with real PRs. By that I mean that if Orc did make the kill and someone like a tracker saw, then it's easy to seem genuine when you're mafia and know of kills. It's also easy to go and say 'oh, we have a protective PR'. Also, rather remarkable how she has survived this long, and how she got scum N1 (despite a few of the 'Orc doesn't seem like scum' posts) and a PR on N2. Nice way to look all towny by being 'oh so helpful' to the town. Possible indication of a rolecop in the mafia if they did somehow find a Doc.

More evidence supporting Orc making the kill is that perhaps the other mafia members are people highly suspected by us already. And they sent Orc to kill, in fear of being tracked. It could possibly be just because of all of the 'Orc'll be lynched soon anyway' but they did have a chance of Orc getting through with the claim an having an extra day or two of trying to lure the real cop (if we have one) out.

So yeah, there's my thought process at the moment.

Also, TIP, how about you share some of that nice stuff called logical reasoning instead of just saying 'so and so is scum', 'so and so is town'? Is it really that difficult to help contribute a bit more? Your play looks like calculated lurking, posting something that is pseudo-useful but very short.

So,
1. You call me out on posting
2. You don't call RC out on posting
3. You call one night being remarkable for how long a PR has survived
4. You fail to see the WIFOM scum can create by leaving it alive
5. Do you even logic bro

In post 2280, TheIrishPope wrote:So,
1. You call me out on posting
2. You don't call RC out on posting
3. You call one night being remarkable for how long a PR has survived
4. You fail to see the WIFOM scum can create by leaving it alive
5. Do you even logic bro

1. Indeed.
2. RC has posted way less useless/semi-useless crap.
3. Technically two.
4. I can see the WIFOM possibility but I don't think this is the case here.
5. Yes, I do 'logic'.

So, how about you tell me your opinion on Maraca. Town or scum? Any extra observations? Other scumreads?

@GM - That cat is so adorable. And this is coming from me, and I normally dislike cats. But that cat is really cute ^__^

AFB, maybe you should look at yourself in a mirror

a no action from Orc would not have been a gauranteed guilty and I don't even have to explain why

also you don't fucking lynch the stupid without valid reasons, you lynch the fucking scum

you already mislynched fucking a stupid when we could have lynched a scum, so shut up your face

In post 2281, goodmorning wrote: Guyett [L-6] - PeregrineV

have you read the thread yet?

In post 2275, JacobSavage wrote:Orc perfromed the kill because he was going to die.

WHAT THE HOLY MOTHER FUCKING FUCK

SUCH INSIGHTFUL DEDUCTION

Also, TIP you're fucking useless right now so Hermy is right about you in that regard

In post 2169, yessiree wrote:Cephir and sangres are obviously not engineering or mathematics grads for appreciating a graph that's missing axis labels and titles

I can appreciate the towniness of it; I don't give a shit about axis or titles or anything like that.

In post 2196, Cephrir wrote:Why do I not want 80% the players in this game anywhere near lylo?

It's a game where reaching LyLo is a very very bad thing.

In post 2205, Guyett wrote:Its appalling. Trademark easy mislynch wagon driven by scum

Got anything better for me, Guyett?

In post 2221, Angry Frat BROs wrote:(although the lack of sangres/MC Maraca is uncomfortable)

In what?

In post 2251, Guyett wrote:I think this one is my favourite... If you highly doubted he was scum why follow him?

What

This lynch excites me more than other lynches again. Although JacobSavage can die whenever he's meant to die.

Hermy is town.

AFB is not.

Questions?

Honestly I don't know how AFB survived the first day but he's not surviving this one.

In post 2291, RadiantCowbells wrote:Hermy is town.

AFB is not.

Questions?

You're insane. I'm telling you. AFB is Town.
Honestly I'm not even gonna bother answering Hermy.

I'm not taking an "i'm telling you" from the person who jumped off Orc as soon as it picked up steam.

That has nothing to do. AFB is Town.

In post 2295, TheIrishPope wrote:That has nothing to do. AFB is Town.

Don't worry tippy I undermean what you stand. I don't think those two would get it short of you beating it into them.

In post 2267, PeregrineV wrote:

In post 2256, yessiree wrote:

In post 2253, MC Maraca wrote:Holy shit I even claimed i'd be following him night one during day one. Like five fucking times.

There is one inconsistency with your claim on day 1, when you said

In post 2040, Cabd wrote:Attention people voting orcinus:

In post 2026, Cabd wrote:If shit is faked ill know tomorrow.

Thank you.

because

In post 2241, yessiree wrote:If Maraca is a follower, there is no way it ("it" for hydra) could be certain of orc's alignment if orc didn't perform the night kill

Ummmmm....

I think I get where you're going with this pere, and if it is what I think it is, you're following a false conclusion.

The protective role should claim.
1. If no protective role claims, we lynch Maraca.
2. If a protective role claims, we have two confirmed Town and scum have to decide who to kill.
a. If they try to kill Maraca, protective role has a chance to protect them, which WIFOMs the shit out of Mafia.
b. If they try to kill the protective role, Maraca gets another night.

Plus Maraca already knows who it is, so he can call out whoever fakeclaims.

In post 2298, TheIrishPope wrote:The protective role should claim.
1. If no protective role claims, we lynch Maraca.
2. If a protective role claims, we have two confirmed Town and scum have to decide who to kill.
a. If they try to kill Maraca, protective role has a chance to protect them, which WIFOMs the shit out of Mafia.
b. If they try to kill the protective role, Maraca gets another night.

Plus Maraca already knows who it is, so he can call out whoever fakeclaims.

That, however, is a bad idea and can wait until later. No fucking way I'm outing the protective today. You realize my role is incredibly weak, right? Like it's weaker than tracker. Even if I live, I've got at best a {playersalive-1} chance of hitting the killer should I survive the night.