Mafiascum.net

You get sent a PM saying your action was roleblocked right? (This is to everyone who has been roleblocked)

As of the last page, yes, we did get a message.

So, what, just because I'm not going to take the lead anymore, everyone stops scumhunting? Get going, guys. Those of you who are still town are going to need to take the lead here and find that recruiter.

Flameaxe wrote:As of the last page, yes, we did get a message.

Who's we?

Xvart, myself and Yos have all claimed to get a message when we we're blocked.

And this roleblocker is part of the cult?

Or any anti town party?

This is so reassuring. Of all the people I think might be town, they are lurking or apparently idiots.

So much for my theory on the roleblocker(s). Probably a good thing that I didn't read the last page until after Flay had PMed xvart.

gandalf5166 wrote:Yos knows fully well that he has to work with us. If we don't lynch the other cult's recruiter SOON, his cult automatically loses. His info should be taken with a grain of salt, but it's not worthless.

Apparently knows too much. Probably not the only one, but this is a good place to start.

Sorry about my lack of posting over the weekend. I haven't really had the motivation to go back and look at Andy, Robo, RCs, and Chrono's target claims, when they occurred, and parse out which of RC and Andy I think is the recruiter. My plan is to have a vote up by the end of the day tomorrow with supporting reasoning.

xvart.

@Xvart: Opinions on my speculation in 2278?

@Charlie, Andy: Could you reiterate the flavor the two of you got on the nights you got no result?

Erg0 (Andrius, Chronopie, Flameaxe, gandalf5166)
ooba (ReaperCharlie, singersigner)
Yosarian2 (Katsuki)
gandalf5166 (Erg0)
xvart (ooba)

Man, I have just over 10% of the posts in this game. 244 of 2312.

Flameaxe: http://mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.ph ... 2#p2519712 Here's what you want.

I think I like the way RC is heading with his ooba/ss theory - it reminds me of the point I was meandering my way towards yesterday. Am I reading right that nobody besides ooba and ss mentioned the double vote ability for loose cannons? Might also explain why TheLonging's apparent belief that he had a daykill seemed inconsistent with the kind of PM I'd expect a double-voter/night vig to get.

Bonus points: if Yosarian's telling the truth then ooba is almost certainly not recruiter.

You see, I was thinking about this game, and something hit me really fast. But I wanted to make sure I had everything right first. So I got a just a few more questions.

The cult gets the person ability upon recruiting right?

Erg0 is diverting wagon away from himself. It doesn't matter if ooba is his scum or not.
He's diverting away from him. HRM.

Moar votes.

Erg0 wrote:I think I like the way RC is heading with his ooba/ss theory - it reminds me of the point I was meandering my way towards yesterday. Am I reading right that nobody besides ooba and ss mentioned the double vote ability for loose cannons? Might also explain why TheLonging's apparent belief that he had a daykill seemed inconsistent with the kind of PM I'd expect a double-voter/night vig to get.

SS's double vote is an interesting one, possibly a gamble, however I doubt it (thinking about the lynching wagon). The reason Im not voting you just now is that I think its worth going through a few others (particularly BBM/ani) first. However you haven't painted yourself in a very glamorous light this game so far.

Andrius wrote:Erg0 is diverting wagon away from himself. It doesn't matter if ooba is his scum or not.

I said recruiter, not scum. And it kinda does, if Yosarian is to be believed.

Regardless, I just realised that the ooba double vote theory would require him to have made the assumption that there were no other loose cannons still alive when he claimed, which seems pretty risky. As such, he's probable town.

SS was online during the kill so chuck that theory ..

Erg0 wrote:I think I like the way RC is heading with his ooba/ss theory - it reminds me of the point I was meandering my way towards yesterday. Am I reading right that nobody besides ooba and ss mentioned the double vote ability for loose cannons? Might also explain why TheLonging's apparent belief that he had a daykill seemed inconsistent with the kind of PM I'd expect a double-voter/night vig to get.

- Nobody else mentioned it cause zwet is probably the only other LC role and he never had to claim fully
- Checked the PM - fairly easy to miss it if skimming ..

Read Me=Weird in ISO .. Gut read: Katsuki is probably Me=weird's cult leader ..

Assuming every person claiming right now is telling the truth, we can safely eliminate as recruiter
Andrius
Chronopie
Lord Gurgi
ooba
ReaperCharlie
vezokpiraka Robocopter87
TheLonging singersigner

Calling the two scum teams Red and Blue:
Yosarian2 -> Red Recruit
inHimshallibe Katsuki -> Red Leader (My read - feel free to disagree)

Which leaves possibilities for Blue Leader at:
xvart
Erg0
animorpherv1 Flameaxe
gandalf5166
Porochaz

I liked xvart sticking his head out for the roleblocker PM thing -> Not a recruiter.
Not sure about erg0 - maybe a slight recruited vibe .. Gandalf is my pick amongst the rest ..

ooba is scum with Erg0.
Moving on.

Andrius wrote:ooba is scum with Erg0.
Moving on.

Dammit, Andy, you couldn't have waited one minute to say that so I could say it first?

No.

LARGE Cult
Erg0
ooba
xvart

Small Cult
Yosarin2 (I have my doubts about his claim)

Town
Andy
Chrono
RC (Doubts here, but meh. not recruiter)

I think we should be aware that we have no idea about the size of either of the cults beyond yosarians word and actually when it comes to this, I would actually prefer to disbeliever his word.

Porochaz wrote:I think we should be aware that we have no idea about the size of either of the cults beyond yosarians word and actually when it comes to this, I would actually prefer to disbeliever his word.

(shrug) There's no reason you should take my word. However, the town does already know that there's 2 recruits a night, that there have been 4 nights so far, and that only one cult member is dead. No matter if you trust me or not, you should have already figured out most of what I told you, at least in broad outlines.