Mini 1566: Lunar Silver Star Story Complete (Game Over)

[borkjerfkin]

Votecount 5.4

[2] Aegor (Mac, beastcharizard)
[2] Mac (Aegor, mastin2)

[2] Not Voting (BROseidon, penguin_alien)

With 6 alive, it is 4 to lynch.

Let me know if you see any problems.

Deadline is in (expired on 2014-06-29 01:00:00)

[beastcharizard]

BC is just a massive disappointment because he has yet to provide a single actual reason that I am maf and has not even attempted to reconcile my play with scum intent.

I will do the work tomorrow. I have already ISO'd you so it shouldn't be that much work but as of right now I am falling asleep so the work would consist of: "Aegor is scum because of his ISO."

[penguin_alien]

Kind of like mastin's points. Thinking Mac shouldn't live to LyLo. Not thinking further at this hour. I know soon deadline is soon.

[BROseidon]

VOTE: Mac

[penguin_alien]

I want to hear beast's Aegor case before I vote. But I won't miss deadline.

[Aegor]

I will do the work

tomorrow

. I have already ISO'd you so it shouldn't be that much work but as of right now I am falling asleep so the work would consist of: "Aegor is scum because of his ISO."

Penguin, please end this.

[penguin_alien]

End this? Hm. Sounds convincing. Would want Mac dead anyways. Too many weird things with the claim. Sorry if you're town.

VOTE: Mac

[Aegor]

Hopefully the game is over.

[borkjerfkin]

Votecount 5.5 (Final)

[4] Mac (Aegor, mastin2, BROseidon, penguin_alien)

[2] Aegor (Mac, beastcharizard)

With 6 alive, it is 4 to lynch.

Let me know if you see any problems.

A lynch has been reached! Flip incoming.

[borkjerfkin]

Mac

Phacia
Vile Tribe Aligned
Vile Priestess (Mafia 2-Shot Doctor Neighbor)

was lynched day 5.

Aegor

Lemia Ausa
Magic Guild Aligned
Guild Headmistress (Vanilla Townie)

survives.

beastcharizard

Jessica D'Alkirk
Magic Guild Aligned
Shrine Acolyte (Town 2-Shot Nurse Neighbor)

survives.

BROseidon

Luna Noa
Magic Guild Aligned
Mysterious Songstress (Vanilla Townie)

survives.

penguin_alien

Dyne
Magic Guild Aligned
Retired Adventurer (Town Self-Watcher)

survives.

mastin2

Nash Rumack
Magic Guild Aligned
Arrogant Sorcerer Neophyte (Vanilla Townie)

survives.

>>>The Magic Guild Has Won The Game!<<<

[borkjerfkin]

Will open in a sec. Few things to say.

[borkjerfkin]

I had an unprecedented number of personnel problems this game and would like to deeply apologize to anyone caught in the crossfire.

In dealing with this I sought two things:
1) To avoid taking moderator action when possible.
2) To take the fairest moderator action when I had to.

Unfortinately, 1) was not attainable in some situations, and when this happened I conferred very closely with the listmods in how to proceed.

That said, I request two things:
1) If you have ongoing issues with your fellow players, please be respectful in the postgame thread. I will not hesitate to lock it if it gets out of hand.
2) If you have ongoing issues with how I handled a thing, please take it to me in private or to a listmod if you feel uncomfortable doing that.

Thanks, congrats to the town, gg to all, and a special thanks to repeat players of my games.

[borkjerfkin]

All PTs sans Mafia PT have been opened, which will be at their discretion.

[Jake from State Farm]

Wel at least I was responsible for catching 2 scum. Thanks for pulling the game out in the end

[Jake from State Farm]

Like, seriously, starting the game playing like a protective PR to bait an NK as a VT is a valid strategy.

Playing post-inno weakly to bait scum into shooting elsewhere to remove scum hunting pressure from the rest of town is a valid strategy.

The fact that you're playing dumb on this and trying to antagonize me about it is either:

A) Incredibly stupid or

B) Scummy, because you're trying to calibrate whether I'm a worthwhile NK target.

Now that this game is over I can finally address this.

No this is not a viable strategy. Please in the future don't do this and instead be a productive member of the game.

[fferyllt]

gj to the replacements working their way through this game.

It was an interesting game design. I was a little surprised that the players in the nurse-neighbor slot weren't more uncomfortable about the apparent game balance a Mac-town implied.

Thanks for running the game, Bork!

[pieguyn]

/was following

gj to the replacements working their way through this game.

It was an interesting game design. I was a little surprised that the players in the nurse-neighbor slot weren't more uncomfortable about the apparent game balance a Mac-town implied.

Thanks for running the game, Bork!

this. tbh I thought it was zmuffin-slot and then I realized mac's role didn't fit with the rest of the setup. oh well ._.

[beastcharizard]

Well it looks like it was a good thing my internet went out last night.

My theory was that Mac being lynched would allow me to get my protect. With that protect I would be able to protect PA while the mafia tried to kill them thus catching them red handed. There are a lot of holes in it of course.

What ever though, as long as we won. I didn't really do anything though.

[Antihero]

awesome we won







yay?

[ActionDan]

I did want to mention that putting in the nurse in when a scum doctor has no functionality throws off balance when the scum doc dies.

[borkjerfkin]

I did want to mention that putting in the nurse in when a scum doctor has no functionality throws off balance when the scum doc dies.

Agree. the scum doc with no use was fine, the town nurse wasn't.

[Aegor]

Congrats team. I am glad mastin saw the light by the end.

[ActionDan]

Well if Beast claimed nurse at some point, Mastin would have changed her mind and town would probably lose.

[Squirrel Girl]

That does explain to me why I had no good scum cases left at the point I replaced out - an error in thinking Mac's role was town despite his play.

[mastin2]

I did it?

...I did it!

I did it!

You have no clue how much small victories like this one help me.