In post 1251, northsidegal wrote:scum probably got the self watcher and knew they had to kill varsoon. might be able to catch another scum from spending histories
this is still a weird post; not sure why you went to self-watcher here and not 'varsoon basically claimed a rb guilty in his opening post that gammag suicided to prevent him to reveal'
or why you thought spending histories were a thing
i don't really consider roleblocker guilties "guilties" so that didn't really occur to me as a motivation. it seemed more likely to me that he tracked someone to a kill or something of that sort
i wasn't referring to "spending histories" as a specific thing, just moreso the idea tha tkeeping track of how people spent their money could potentially reveal scum if they had done the self watch
ormally, I'd be throwing down on Gammagoo for that hammer, but I'm actually pretty sure of scum that isn't him.
S
o right now, I'm gonna sit on that, though, 'cus I am interested in what everyone else has to think.
G
ooey, do you have anything you want to share?
uh maybe i'm overlooking things but look at the bolded, first letter of each sentence
porkens did you see this?
i'm laughing right now but i'm also really disappointed. this is the exatc same shit that happened to me in product placement mafia and i just don't have the same energy to get as mad as i got in that game, nor do i want to repeat any of that game. if you ever wanted to see perhaps the angriest i've ever been in a game of mafia, look no further. the summary is that i was roleblocked on the same night that a kill was stopped and thus people got it in their heads that i "had" to be lynched, while all the while i was screaming to actually lynch scum (and the rest of the game proceeded to ignore me, kill me anyways, and lose to the scum i was pointing out).
did varsoon rb me n2 or whatever? yeah, it probably looks that way. not really sure how common the "nsg" letters are but they seem pretty specific. that doesn't make me scum.
i really don't want to go through that whole same situation again.
you're making a lot of assumptions to get to me being scum from varsoon blocking me. none of those assumptions are reliable and they're not things you should be going off of over the actual evidence that points to me being town
Well here’s the thing:
In Product placement 3 reasons existed as to how a Killed could be stopped, all fairly valid.
Here I don’t see any BP or protective claims or flips
Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2018 5:25 am
by Gamma Emerald
And Product Placement was the previous game I thought of
u tried to compare this game where there are no flipped protectives to a game where there was a 3-shot doc
In post 2299, Nosferatu wrote:like ok my dude its a "lot of assumptions" to ignore the case of a n2 no-kill scum move
totally
See Nosferatu is on the level
Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2018 5:27 am
by Nosferatu
and inb4 "someone could have used extreme teen bible"
no because that would require them to have gotten 200 gold from d1 town lynch
only way that could have happened is if i used my role on someone and they blocked it, in which case they would have been town and claimed
on top of that i didnt even use my role until d3
pedit: yes gamma hop on the bus
Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2018 6:59 am
by skitter30
In post 2294, northsidegal wrote:i don't really consider roleblocker guilties "guilties" so that didn't really occur to me as a motivation. it seemed more likely to me that he tracked someone to a kill or something of that sort
i'm pretty sure he had already flipped at this point?
In post 2295, northsidegal wrote:the summary is that i was roleblocked on the same night that a kill was stopped and thus people got it in their heads that i "had" to be lynched, while all the while i was screaming to actually lynch scum (and the rest of the game proceeded to ignore me, kill me anyways, and lose to the scum i was pointing out).
a) not trying to make you angry, apologies if i did
b) i don't know if i'm saying you *have* to be lynched, so much as saying i think that this is fairly incriminating
c) i don't really feel like you're screaming to actually lynch scum?
i do think that he crumbed that he rb'd you (the odds of the first letter of each sentence otherwise spelling out 'nsg' is ... pretty low + this is like varsoon and i think it's more likely that he'd have crumbed than not, especially given how role/mechanics-oriented he is)
i'm not saying that this guarantees that you're scum (and i don't think i called you scum because of it), but i think it's fairly incriminating, especially coupled with the fact that i'm scumreading you already
can you link some of those scumgames? there's something in particular i want to check
In post 2295, northsidegal wrote:you're making a lot of assumptions to get to me being scum from varsoon blocking me. none of those assumptions are reliable and they're not things you should be going off of over the actual evidence that points to me being town
ok, what assumptions am i making?
what evidence points to you being town? (the last time i asked you basically said cuz rc was townreading you but you're currently pushing gamma so it's a little ???? to expect me to townread you on the word of a slot you're pushing)
In post 2296, northsidegal wrote:that was just something quick on my phone. do you think that i would ignore my modding responsibilities or something just to avoid posting here? i don't understand what kind of correlation you're meant to be pointing out here.
more in the context of:
it looked like she's flaked from more serious (ie modding and game-related ) posting and i'm not entirely sure i wanted to go through getting a replacement in mylo and i kinda wanted to just vote you out instead of waiting for a catchup and prolonging the game and spending days dragging reactions and responses out of people and making someone rep-in to a rb guilty
i couldn't talk about the modding obviously at that point but i was basically thinking that if you hadn't been modding you were prob not going to be posting here either
also i will admit that i'm lowkey weirded out that like everyone stopped posting for like half a week and it kinda makes me think that scum are ok with it? not entirely sure tbh. either that or scum didn't really react? i don't know how to tell which
no because that would require them to have gotten 200 gold from d1 town lynch
only way that could have happened is if i used my role on someone and they blocked it, in which case they would have been town and claimed
tbf i'm pretty sure someone flipped who could get that much gold off of one lynch (although tbf i think it had to be a scum lynch; i'd have to go and check all the flips tho to be sure)
Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2018 7:02 am
by skitter30
yeah ok, nm, all the flips can only get that much after being on a scum lynch
this is xyzzy, your moderator, your best friend, and your cold, dead hands.
Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2018 1:19 pm
by Porkens
I have so much gold
Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2018 2:14 pm
by Shoshin
How much gold?
Posted: Tue Oct 30, 2018 5:36 am
by Nosferatu
VOTE: nsg
Posted: Tue Oct 30, 2018 5:41 am
by Gamma Emerald
So by everyone’s silence I assume no one wishes to claim anything that could have stopped the n1 kill VOTE: nsg
Posted: Tue Oct 30, 2018 5:50 am
by skitter30
Shoshin not really posting anything is kinda sketching me out
Gamma just waiting for someone else to vote and hopping on immediately thereafter is also, especially since he's been doing that for like the last two dayphases
Im really not understanding why you're being so secretive about your reads
Posted: Tue Oct 30, 2018 5:53 am
by skitter30
And going through mylo without fully massclaiming seems incrediblu strange to me as well
Posted: Tue Oct 30, 2018 5:56 am
by Gamma Emerald
Well this time I had to determine that no one had info counter to the logic against my vote
Interesting that you’re backing out here btw
Posted: Tue Oct 30, 2018 6:01 am
by skitter30
I get incredibly skittish and paranoid in xylo
And my point is that you waited to vote till nos did
And technically we dont know that there's no counter since two people havent claimed, and theoretically scum could have no killed
I dont think that either of those scenarios are particularly likely tbf
Posted: Tue Oct 30, 2018 6:04 am
by Gamma Emerald
I get that, but neither came forward with relevant information. Therefore I find it reasonable to think that they don’t have any.
Posted: Tue Oct 30, 2018 7:45 am
by Nosferatu
In post 2316, skitter30 wrote:Gamma just waiting for someone else to vote and hopping on immediately thereafter is also, especially since he's been doing that for like the last two dayphases
well believe it or not scum will do that
Posted: Tue Oct 30, 2018 8:25 am
by Shoshin
VOTE: nsg
I don't get why we're voting nsg instead of no lynching but if this is what we're doing, I want to be on this for the gold.