Mafiascum.net

Okay I give up I’m just gonna sheep Blake and we’ll see where that gets us

VOTE: PP

In post 2295, Blake Belladonna wrote:I'd like to point out that PenguinPower has dropped off the face of the planet after that quoted set of posts.

Quite interesting, isn't it.

sorry, which posts are you referring to here?

In post 2298, skitter30 wrote:i'm townreading gobbles, i think

I lost all hope on you so don't worry

In post 2288, Menalque wrote:

In post 1107, MariaR wrote:Menaaaa I hope you get vigged thanks. Penguins reaction is the most interesting thing I got out of this though.

In post 1110, Pink Ball wrote:

In post 1107, MariaR wrote:Menaaaa I hope you get vigged thanks. Penguins reaction is the most interesting thing I got out of this though.

Interesting like "PP looks really townie out of it", right?

In post 1111, MariaR wrote:

In post 1110, Pink Ball wrote:

In post 1107, MariaR wrote:Menaaaa I hope you get vigged thanks. Penguins reaction is the most interesting thing I got out of this though.

Interesting like "PP looks really townie out of it", right?

Mhm.

P sure she means these

I just read through that exchange again and I'm not seeing what exactly about that response to Menalque's case is so town when you contrast it with the rest of his play.

i just feel like thinking about the games i've played with scum!him that reaction feels kinda unlikely to come from scum!him

I probably need to go back and check why I TR PB & lillith in the fist place (lillith I am not familiar with, so it must've been something generally townie).

HOWEVER, if BOTH are defending S_S (PB doing it indirectly though) they can't both be scum with S_S (OK.. they can, but it's extremely unlikely), and I'm more confused than when I was when I had just finished catching up.

@PB: It's a 50-50 that gobble is the SK. He did fake claim scum with lavender in a recent game (faked a slip) in order to get her lynched on D1, and he got lynched instead and flipped green. In short, silly gambits are NOT out of Town!Turkey's range.

Now let's consider the 50$ chance he is indeed the SK. Turkey -as outed 3P- has a history of siding by town. I witnessed it myself too, and I was frustrated because I was a member of the Mafia team in that game (he was culted), so EVEN IF gobble is a SK I would still be reluctant to lynch him on D1.

Summing the two points I think it is a bad move (lazy at best) to lynch him today.

@Blake/Menalque: If you two check this you would probably notice PP is indeed GREEN.

although now that i think about it, i really have no idea what he's thinking about this game
i'm actually not even sure who he's voting

In post 2307, skitter30 wrote:although now that i think about it, i really have no idea what he's thinking about this game
i'm actually not even sure who he's voting

This is precisely why I am scumreading him.

but i actually think i've felt this way about town!him before too?

Did he have an entrance into the game that he unceremoniously fizzled out of?

PP could easily have been sorted at night. NOBODY would expect a Gunsmith/Role Cop/Tracker or even Jailer to be on him over the majority of other players. UNLIKE Maria who KNOWS she would be targeted by the "opposing team" no matter what her alignment is.

Like, do I have to say everything out loud? This is a competent enough players list everyone should already know what they're supposed to do. Saying things out loud just helps SCUM more. *Sigh*

i'm not sure, i have to look

We should be focusing on the potential "scum masterminds" today, and leave the "unlikely to be the strongest player of the scum team" to night action.

oh he's not even voting ...

i guess i just feel like scum!pp doesn't react that way or get as emotional?

pp can you give me a summary of where you're at rn wrt reads?

Who are the potential scum masterminds?

Generally speaking (i.e. disregarding my own reads) I'd say skitter/Maria/Bingle/S_S are. (You may add me if you want to, but I don't want to look like I'm full of myself.. although it might as well be the case)

And that's not to say the rest are not good enough as scum, but if any of those 4 is scum they're likely to assume leadership of the team AND to have a plan already.

In post 2318, Almost50 wrote:I'd say skitter/Maria/Bingle/S_S are.

Don’t make Blake’s list of priority nightkills or the monkey’s list of scum masterminds, what do I even bother playing for

tbf i usually do try to outsource the mechanical bits if i can

Vaguely offended that the monkey thinks that I’d play second fiddle to anyone on a scumteam at this point

I’m not saying I’d fight with any of those names to be in control but it would at least be a collaborative project

God if I was scum with datisi right now I’d be like double offended and would start try harding the shit out of this game as scum

In post 2319, Menalque wrote:

In post 2318, Almost50 wrote:I'd say skitter/Maria/Bingle/S_S are.

Don’t make Blake’s list of priority nightkills or the monkey’s list of scum masterminds, what do I even bother playing for

As I said, it doesn't mean anyone else is of a lesser skill, but would you say you would assume leadership of the team if any of these 4 was on it? I mean, if it makes you feel better you are indeed the 5th name I thought of, but then I would have had named half the players list.

P-edit: Alright then. You're officially on the list.

I would not need help finding nightkills as scum.