Mini 1482: Castle - A Mafia Murder So Vile (GAME OVER)

[Malakittens]

2.46

with eleven alive it will take six to lynch.

*macmollie -
*Huntress - Sweet Pertayter, macmollie, bert, Wisdom [4]
*Sweet Pertayter -
*FakeGod - Natirasha [1]
*Mantisdreamz -
*Wisdom -
*Serrapaladin - Desperado, FakeGod [2]
*Desperado - Mantisdreamz [1]
*Bert -
*Natirasha -
*penguin_alien - Huntress [1]

Not Voting [2]: Serrapaladin, penguin_alien

Chapter 2 Ends..

Day 2 ends in (expired on 2013-09-05 03:00:00)

(There are no hints/clues in this flavor or in any flavor of the vote counts or death scenes. It's for entertainment purposes.)

[Wisdom]

Well she did do the same in Temple - she was scum and she tried to justify a scumread on me based on Polygamy.

But I really don't want to get paranoid about mollie at this stage.

[Bert]

when you flip town i will break down with such sadness because your play has been terribad in this game

Really, now?

Hey Serra, I repeat COME BACK if you're not SCUMMZZ

I will LOVE YOU <333333333333

you have a special place in my heart, open arms <33333333

What have we done to deserve to be left hanging????????????????????

what I have gained is a town read on mantis (finally) cos she will misremember stuff, it is a personality trait for her.

we spent 2 hours looking for her car in niagara falls

Now she'll start forgetting things to make you think she/he is town... *shrug*

This is dubious because she can just forget her reads conveniently from now on, is this the first time you've said this about her/his meta

Moreso when I think ure scum

Any good reason except being you being mollie's second vote?

Because you think it's all fine and dandy to be here on Day 2 but not actually ""be here", if you know what I mean.

BEETLEJUICEING

coming back and promising stuff that DOESNT GET DONE (like WALLS, posts that might HELP US). Styuff other than telling people to punch themselves or shut up.

Need I go further???

I think slimer's slot should just be policy lynched because he replaced out

wtf is this shit? I have personally replaced town-slimer before.

And was there a reason slimer replaced out??? there was none specified in this game

does slimer enjoy playing scum or.............

[Wisdom]

He replaced out of his other game too and hasn't posted anywhere since, so I don't think his replacing out has anything to do with his alignment at all.

[Bert]

OK GUT READS FROM PAST 8 PAGES

I finally caught up thank you thank you

Wisdom TOWN TOWN TOWN

Mollie TOWN TOWN TOWN all that AtE goodness gracious mamma mia <3333333333

Mantis looks better than before, at least she/he is here engaging and lokoing like he/she is trying to figure us out

Desp don't like - that 3 people, 1 have to be scum stuff sticks out, plus he didn't pursue me and go after me, not having played with me before, he should be more curious about my alignment and all that crap. its like hes all defense and no hunt, and has this attitude that irks me.

Penguin - that timing of the claim is really weird, and the mass claim part just eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeks my scumdar, i wouldnt cry if she died

Serra - can punch himself in the face for not being useful - expect a lot more out of him than this. PUNCH YOURSELF IN THE FACE

Nat and Tater - town, believe their claim...

Huntress - gut scumread, also push on me felt weird

FG - I don't like you and you replaced into a scumslot

SOOOOOOO

Scumspect Pool <Huntress, Serra, Penguin, Desp, FakeGod>

Strong town: Mollie, Wisdom - paranoia can just go die in a hole, so get on the same dadgum page and I will support you. GUT DONT LIE MY ARSE

Town: Nat, Tater

Null/confused: Mantis

Also, it is weird that Peng and Desp have character names that are girlfriend/boyfriend whatever, does anyone else feel that way

At this point, I'm just sheeping my strongest townreads. If you expect more out of me, the exit is that way ---->>>>>>>>> don't even go there with me, ya hear

[Bert]

EBWOP: That is a lot of scumspects, but it's not my fault, it's your fault for being scummy. have the balls to man up for being scum

Oh, and those of you calling me out for fluff can just save it because my ears are closed LALALALALALALALA <333333333 screw that

[Wisdom]

That's not a lot of suspects, having 4-5 townreads out of 11 people is pretty good. There are games that town is so bad that you can't even get one solid townread.

I'm on the same page as you, except I think FakeGod is town and I am pretty certain about Mantis being town again.

[Wisdom]

So for me, it's penguin/Huntress/ {serra or Desp}.

[FakeGod]

Nothing personal, Bert.

I just can't tell whether GIFs = town or scum.

[Bert]

Well she did do the same in Temple - she was scum and she tried to justify a scumread on me based on Polygamy.

But I really don't want to get paranoid about mollie at this stage.

MOLLIE IS THIS TRUE

Don't you make me doubt you

don't make me come over there and have to have a nice long talk with you

I will use what I've learned from Nacho (very little but still useful) and figure you out if you are stringing me along

don't you dare

[serrapaladin]

Sup, serra, I just checked up on TVTropes for Castle a little.

What do you find more surprising: Meredith as cop or Beckett as VT(see: Lynx)?

Just caught up, btw. Serra, thanks for restoring some amount of faith in you. Desp, you're pretty fucking scummy.

To answer your earlier question, Wisdom, I'm reserving my judgment on FakeGod right now.

Huntress can die too.

Well, my character is a cop, too, and I'm a VT. Do you have any flavour justification for being a cop? Richard and Alexis being neighbours is flavoured correctly.

Characters we have so far:

fitz - Jerry Tyson (probably +fakeclaim)
Lynx - Kate Beckett
serra - Javier Esposito
FG - Jordan Shaw
Desp - Kevin Ryan
peng - Jenny Ryan
Wisdom - Alexis Castle
Mantis - Richard Castle

I'm not sure if it'll tell us anything, but I think it can't hurt.

@penguin: I find Serra scummy for attacking me when I started to attack nati. Serra is my second strongest scum read in this game. He derailed the fuck out of nati wagon near d1 deadline for one.

Do note: this read has strong basis in my nati scumread. If Nati flips town, Serra is town.

So you're voting me under the assumption Nati is fakeclaiming? Do you really think I would derail a wagon on my buddy like that? I don't like lynching people who softclaim a PR, particularly not if I have a townread on them.

1. In that post I quoted.

2. We don't know that for certain.

3. He had already claimed and was repeating it as requested

in the post immediately before his

.

Vote: Penguin

Her name claim matching Desp's seemed a bit too convenient and I didn't like the way she tried to get others to claim.

What?

[FakeGod]

I'm bit hesitant to follow Wisdom's plan, not because he's scum but because his plan relies on Nati actually being a cop.

But even fakecops have to generate real info eventually, so I guess his plan could work.

I don't know....

@Serra: Scum_serra derailing wagon for scum_nati makes perfect sense to me. Doesn't it to you?

[Bert]

Serra I saved a nice warm seat for you please stay

if you don't want me to be annoying, please keep talking <3

[FakeGod]

@Penguin: give me your latest scumreads in your next post plz

[serrapaladin]

are you suggesting that there is some kind of insane cop possibility here and Nat's results will be all wrong

No, I was thinking more of

Godfather or possibly Tailor

. Insane cop is unlikely.

Why are you actively trying to find the reasons people scumread you? That's like... scumclaiming.

I'm not. I'm looking for why someone would suddenly want to get me lynched and letting the rest of you know in case they succeed.

Oh dear... Mentioning a role like tailor out of nowhere makes me wildly uncomfortable.

@Serra: Scum_serra derailing wagon for scum_nati makes perfect sense to me. Doesn't it to you?

Surely if my only goal at the end of D1 was to avoid Nati/me getting lynched, I would have just let the mantis wagon go through? Unless you think mantis is scum, too, but that's just a bit silly.

Serra I saved a nice warm seat for you please stay

if you don't want me to be annoying, please keep talking <3

<3

[FakeGod]

dear lord bert don't tell me you're just scumreading people who are not nice to you

remember: evil is nice otherwise people wouldn't bother with it

[FakeGod]

@Serra: Scum_serra derailing wagon for scum_nati makes perfect sense to me. Doesn't it to you?

Surely if my only goal at the end of D1 was to avoid Nati/me getting lynched, I would have just let the mantis wagon go through? Unless you think mantis is scum, too, but that's just a bit silly.

Where did this happen? Link me plz.

[Bert]

I try not to scumread people just for not liking me and genuinely sit on my hands to avoid doing so, but yes I am working on that

Also, your thing about GIFs is understandable, but now I am GIFless for the duration of the game so there is no excuse for an absoluetly null read unless I am just too awesomely fluffy <3333333. If you haven't noticed, I hacven't posted any GIFs in the past couple of days.

What I do is if we keep hitting town and my strongest townread is a competent player (like Nacho), then I will become extremely paranoid and try to figure out what's going on., or at least stop sheeping and not throw caution to the wind

[FakeGod]

I hacven't posted any GIFs in the past couple of days.

Good. GIFs are fun but I like catching scum more

What I do is if we keep hitting town and my strongest townread is a competent player (like Nacho), then I will become extremely paranoid and try to figure out what's going on., or at least stop sheeping and not throw caution to the wind

sigh, sheeping strong players is an easy way for scum to coast through early game.

[serrapaladin]

fitz - Jerry Tyson (probably +fakeclaim)
Lynx - Kate Beckett
serra - Javier Esposito
FG - Jordan Shaw
Desp - Kevin Ryan
peng - Jenny Ryan
Wisdom - Alexis Castle
Mantis - Richard Castle

*and of course Nati - Meredith

rereading ~73-77 has me thinking fg is probably town with a poor read on Nati. Outing the cop like that is terribly reckless though. That'd be a pretty crazy move as scum.

@Serra: Scum_serra derailing wagon for scum_nati makes perfect sense to me. Doesn't it to you?

Surely if my only goal at the end of D1 was to avoid Nati/me getting lynched, I would have just let the mantis wagon go through? Unless you think mantis is scum, too, but that's just a bit silly.

Where did this happen? Link me plz.

Serrapaladin makes good points. Plus mollie generally reads Mantisdreamz well, and I trust her read here.

Mantisdreamz, intent to hammer. Claim, please.

Sweet Pertayter, if you're around, what changed between #513 and #597 on WRT Mantis?

If you're still around for a bit, don't hammer just yet.

I'm a bit busy for another 20 minutes or so, but I do still want to look through stuff.

Could we just have a role call of who's around at the moment, to see whether there is any use in discussing alternatives to mantis/me?

[Bert]

sigh, sheeping strong players is an easy way for scum to coast through early game.

It's also an easy way to win if you believe in your strongest townreads and they ARE without a doubt much stronger scumhunters and vastly more experienced

Mollie and Wisdom are on another level with regard to scumhunting and playing and picking out scum

It may not have worked in my previous game with them (514), but it failed in part because they both got NKed night 1.

[BeautyAndTheBeast]

@Mollie:

I don't remember Wisdom making Mara cry

I remember Nacho apologizing and Mara crying AFTER the game

What does that have to do with Wisdom?

Mara admitted crying AFTER the game, while we were in a post-game chat. No one was blaming Wisdom.

Wisdom just told Mutley that it was all in the context of the game and he/she didn't mean to offend

are you fucking kidding me? she didn't cry after the game she cried after she was lynched.

huntress if you are sus of wis then why is your vote not on him?

[Bert]

are you fucking kidding me? she didn't cry after the game she cried after she was lynched.

She didn't ADMIT to crying until after the game, though!!!!!

WTF??????

She cried WHEN she was lynched, but she didn't get to talk to us till after the game, if I recall correctly!!! Then, after the game, she told us how she had cried. I must not have explained that correctly.

WHY DOES THIS EVEN MATTER

[Bert]

EBWOP: I'm going to go look at Polygamy to see what you're talking about, so at least I know what I'm talking about and don't doubt my memory.

[BeautyAndTheBeast]

EBWOP:

Look Mollie I'm not gonna get in between you two talking about Polygamy because I haven't read that game since it ended a while back during the post-game chat.

But my point is Wisdom didn't do anything that should hurt anyone IMO. I was there and I dont'remember going "OH GOD, WISDOM MADE MARA CRY"

I did not get that feeling after the game or during the game. Mara melted down. Why are you blaming Wisdom for that?

Nacho got a townread on Wisdom. You were lovers with Nacho, mollie/mac.

You trusted NAcho's read, right?

And TAM got lynched because of some AtE spill he/she did. This has nothing to do with Wisdom.

not sure I believe this shit. you remember WHEN mara brought it up that she cried (in postgame) and she clearly said "I cried myself to sleep that night".

mara is in this game so why don't you ask her?

no cookies for you it is time for you to sit in the naughty scumspect chair.