Mini 1624: Joss Whedon Mafia: The Musical (Game Over)

[eyestott]

Although I guess there isn't really a reason for boonskies to forget about his powers really? It just seems weird

This is a big red flag for me too.
If hes actually an inventor, he should be able to remember his inventions.
Hes lying, about either what inventions he has, or his role.
I cant see him as town. Even if he is town, we cant afford to have him if we ever get to lylo.

Medea: Does your kill have to be used today? Can you save it?

Actually, Medea, you might want to hold off on using it. When the death ray was used in Dr.Horrible, it backfired. It could possibly be faulty. Just a theory.

[Marquis]

I'm back. Sorry.

Replace yoncé with me, please.

VOTE: F-16

[Egg]

Medea should kill either me antihero or boon

[eyestott]

Medea should kill either me antihero or boon

Well, duh.
Who would you prefer?

[Egg]

Antihero

[Bulbazak]

Marquis replaces Yoncé. He also gets a warning. If he doesn't respond to a prod again, he will be replaced.

[Bulbazak]

Vote Count

Medea the Alien (0):
Jesusbuddhavrishnathebest (0):
Antihero (1): Egg
F-16_Fighting_Falcon (2): Murder of Crows, Marquis
Egg (2): Serrapaladin, Eyestott
Serrapaladin (0):
Boonskiies (0):
Eyestott (1): Medea the Alien
Murder of Crows (0):
Marquis (0):

Not Voting (4): Jesusbuddhavrishnathebest, Antihero, F-16_Fighting_Falcon, Boonskiies

It is day 3. With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch. Day ends on Wednesday, January 7 at 1:00am EST. Countdown: (expired on 2015-01-07 01:00:00).

[eyestott]

Mod, I am voting Boonskies.

No you're not. I checked.

[serrapaladin]

Prod dodge

[eyestott]

Huh.
VOTE: Boonskies. I've already made a case.

[Murder of Crows]

I mean, the 5 inventions he just mentioned were different to the ones he claimed at the start.
He had NO IDEA ABOUT SERRA
His answers didn't even really answer my questions, but we're just politician garble

Were they? I'll admit I haven't been reading Boonskies posts with attention to detail because its painful.
Having no idea about Serra makes him scum? If you think its so egregious that he must be faking it, then I can buy that logic, but I don't see how it makes him likely scum in any other scenario. Surely scum is LESS likely to miss that sort of thing since it would likely come up when discussing kills. But who knows, its clear Boon is phoning this in. And ya I did giggle at a couple points where Boon missed the point. Still doesnt make him scum exactly.

[Murder of Crows]

I'm reading through AP's readslist. A couple of questions:

1. Why were you slightly concerned about Nacho when I called them a townlean whereas otherwise they seemed to be "radiating towniness" all around when you have me as scum?

2. This one is for both heads: I'm still unclear as to how your position changed on Nacho from TownieMcTownfuck to paranoiaville.

1. You haven't influenced my Nacho read. I town read them for all the reasons ffery mentioned on D2.

2. Ffery still thinks they are town. I think they are town if Im being totally honest. I don't even think I can do justice to my paranoia there other than I'm wavering backandforth on all my reads too much. Their predecessor was extremely underwhelming and when I looked back at their posts, I realize that most of my town read on them came from all 3 heads being rather random and posting stream-of-thought style in the thread, often in tandem. I guess I have been convincing myself that its a little hollow for the most part and that I could see them tryharding as scum since they are all in a hydra. Their drop off in activity Today just left me wanting for more and made me concerned that they WERE going to just coast off the cred they built on D2. When I mentioned the "antics" I mean that their posts Yesterday are really sort of a carnival of lunacy to a light degree. I disliked their interaction with the Mikuru wagon annnnnd I think I had something else to say but I gotta move my car BRB.

[Antihero]

been v/la for the past few days and will be for the next couple days. sry to leave ya'll hangin'.

cabd, just use the damn vig shot.

[serrapaladin]

I'm afraid to say that boon is probably town.

Today should end with cabd using his shot on Egg, anti, or crow.

Unless he claims, it should really be egg.

[Murder of Crows]

Serra can you talk in more detail about your reads?

[serrapaladin]

Do you think scum cabd would have used his shot without claiming?

Boon and eye are town for their claims, as is yonce, I think. Grey was kinda town for his rage, and I think F16 is too. I sort of trust regfan's read on Jesus, and I'm sort of thinking I should trust his read on you, too.

[Murder of Crows]

Do you think scum cabd would have used his shot without claiming?

Boon and eye are town for their claims, as is yonce, I think. Grey was kinda town for his rage, and I think F16 is too. I sort of trust regfan's read on Jesus, and I'm sort of thinking I should trust his read on you, too.

You have played more games with me than Regfan has. This was our second, and our first where he was town.

I agree with you on boon and Eye. I lean town on Yonce/Marquis with a huge footnote about Marquis' propensity for fake claiming as scum. The main thing I don't like about F-16 is that he's really been hyperfocused on us - ignoring tons of interesting stuff that happened today for instance - to come in and ask us to clarify our Nacho read. Like the most important thing to happen all of day 2 is some mild dissonance in our reads after AP did his catch-up.

I am not confident about Egg flipping scum, given his intransigent attitude about claiming, but that could be projection. I tend to be a lot more stubborn and stick-to-my-guns as town about certain things (including whether I think it's the right time to claim) than as scum, though I've by necessity incorporated some of that into my scum game.

I like Medea's reaction to getting the vig kill, but if anyone could fake that sort of thing flawlessly, it's Cabd.

Which leaves Anti in PoE land.

[Murder of Crows]

day 3, not day 2.

[Murder of Crows]

Which leaves Anti in PoE land.

Ya sort of. Thats my holdup though. I agree about

Egg - refusal to claim looks town
Yonce - looks town for claim sequence and other things
Serra - town
Jesus - town for play on D2?
Eyestott - townish thoughts recently
Boon - To dumb to be scum?
Cabd - town for Mikuru reactions + vig reactions?

Which would mean its just F16 and AH. If one of those flips town after I resolve myself to this logic, Im going to flip out.

[Marquis]

Medea needs to shoot Anti.

If flavor makes it backfire, that's a plus. I think there's scum in that pair.

[Marquis]

Probably should have explained earlier but recent boon events switched him and anti in my reads and f-16 is one of the few to stay in my scum pile.

[eyestott]

Seriously guys. Boonskies inventions have changed. How is that not a scumslip? Or at the very least, a lieslip?

So what are the other roles you can invent? And do you get to choose which one you give to your target?

freeze ray/death ray/

shield

/deflector.

yes, I choose who I give my invention to.

Questions for you:

1: Are your abilities all actions that give an ability to a target, all one shot abilities, a mixture, or do you not know? If one of the first 3, were you told in your pm? If the third option, what is the flavour reason for having a mix?

Someone is killing people off...one by one. My job is to find out who it is! I pretty much built these tools to help. I only get to use each once. I don't know when they'll be activated either.

2a: If the first option, why didnt you mention this when you said you gave the lightning rod to anatole?

I thought I said it.

2b: If the second, why is medea not dead?

The ray I gave him worked with a different mechanic as the lightning rod did. I'm happy he didn't die now; I started to town read him.

2c: If the third, how have you factored not knowing into your choice of target, given that (If your town-reading Medea) you could have either given a kill to a townread or downright killed them?

He was null for me; if he died, he died. Oh well, a null read out of the way for me. If not, I felt like I would read him better, which I have.

2d: If the fourth, why havent you mentioned that you didnt know? Why base your night 1 action on the thinking that you had 1-shots, but for some reason, base your N2 action on the thinking you gave 1-shots?

I thought all inventors were 1 shot with their inventions. Didn't think I'd have to say it.

3: Why would you give a kill to Medea, given that your last D2 post about them was voting them?

Previous questions.

4: This is an extremely important question. Why the heck did you not give the kill to serrapaladin, a CONFIRMED TOWN?

I didn't know Serra was confirmed town. Explain to me what happened? I missed it.

5: If you believe your abilities are a mix of 1-shots and 1-shot givers, how do you think each of your inventions work? What you say here better make sense with your next actions.

not sure anymore. the deflector role probably takes place the next night, and given to someone.

don't know what mind link does.

and the second ray probably gives a 1 shot role block.

[Boonskiies]

Oh, I fucked up. I don't have a freeze ray. I thought I had two rays. So yeah , I gave Medea the death ray. I have both mind link and shield.

[Boonskiies]

Hadn't looked at role pm in a while.

[eyestott]

Nope. Nope. Nope.
Nope.
Can we lynch Boonskies now?