Mafiascum.net

In post 2310, Isis wrote:

@Frederick A Campbell: Who designed the setup?

Check out the "Setup Designer:" section in the post below.

In post 0, Fredrick A Campbell wrote:

Mini Normal 2153

Backup Moderator:

Micc

Setup Designer:

Fredrick A Campbell

Primary Setup Reviewer:

mastina

Secondary Setup Reviewer:

northsidegal

Playerlist:

1. bob3141
   
2. notscience
   
3. geraintm
   
4. UnaBombaH
   
5. Replacement for Sujimichi
   Sujimichi
   
   
6. Porkens
   Klick
   
   
7. Bellaphant
   ●
   
   
8. Not_Mafia
   Emperor flippyNips
   
   
9. Galron
   
10. Hoopla
    
11. popopopopopopo
    ●
    
    
12. Isis
    
13. Dunnstral

●

denotes the first prod.

●

denotes the second prod.

●

denotes the third prod.

Spoiler: Alive

• geraintm
  
• UnaBombaH
  
• Replacement for Sujimichi
  
• Not_Mafia
  
• Isis

Spoiler: Dead

1. popopopopopopo, a Vanilla Townie, was executed on Day 1.
   
2. Dunnstral, a Town Psychologist, was found dead by the Moderator at the end of Night 1.
   
3. Galron, a Town Follower, was executed on Day 2.
   
4. notscience, a Town Neapolitan, was found dead by the Moderator at the end of Night 2.
   
5. Hoopla, a Mafia Indecisive Motion Detector, was executed on Day 3.
   
6. Porkens, a Vanilla Townie, was found dead by the Moderator at the end of Night 3.
   
7. Bellaphant, a Vanilla Townie, was executed on Day 4.
   
8. bob3141, a Vanilla Townie, was found dead by the Moderator at the end of Night 4.

Votecount summary, replacements and responses to questions addressed to the moderator

I'm an ungated VT with a vanilla modifier.

Haven't read through anything properly since day start, will do so later tonight.

I am a plain vt. I think i was fairly explicit all the way through the vame saying I would never have any extra info

Cool so time to lynch RfS then?

Yea, I'm still thinking RfS today.
I'm just wondering whether that's what I'm "supposed" to think, or what I'm actually thinking.
If that makes any sense.

Why didn't we get the necessary fuel to a RfS-wagon yesterday btw?
Was it all because I did that poke towards N_M to fish for reactions? That was enough to make me an interesting enough lynch to keep RfS from being a realistic option?

I mean, I still think Bella was acting like scum, but RfS got off relatively easy yesterday now that I think about it.

Wow what a revelation

In post 2339, Isis wrote:Gera, say you execute N_M, he flips scum, the mafia no kill, and you go to the next day phase and Frederick says no No Executing

Who are you voting?

Well....not sure being honest. I want to vote not mafia, suspect it is like 70/30 to be right. Tonorrow is a day away. I hate the push towards replacement. Fear my interagency is going to cost us now, but feel as town has pretty much had no successful hits on any day on any jnfo the roughly 25% chance we have left seems fair

What're your track results, Isis?

Think it's Not_Mafia with either Isis or Una. I townread Gera.

What changed your trajectory from Una to Replacement, N_M?

In post 2357, geraintm wrote:

In post 2339, Isis wrote:Gera, say you execute N_M, he flips scum, the mafia no kill, and you go to the next day phase and Frederick says no No Executing

Who are you voting?

Well....not sure being honest. I want to vote not mafia, suspect it is like 70/30 to be right. Tonorrow is a day away. I hate the push towards replacement. Fear my interagency is going to cost us now, but feel as town has pretty much had no successful hits on any day on any jnfo the roughly 25% chance we have left seems fair

Yeah, I don't really get what the push on me is, even now. I don't know why Bob and I had to be SvS. Isis's push on me feels in bad faith, and Una saying "wow, why didn't we have the fuel to push Replacement through" feels fake, especially since he never voted me towards the end.

I think Una-Isis is an unlikely team though, the way they've interacted this game doesn't seem faked, with the way Isis was pushing him a couple of days ago.

So, basically I just want to clown Not_Mafia.

I'm town though

Want isis to come back.

Confess that I am at the stage of the game where not much people can say will alter my thoughts.
People pointing out votes and quotes from the past might, but bleating now won't.

Night 1 I tracked notscience because he seemed PRish and finding the scum in your townreads is always nice. He visited Hoopla. WHYYYYY
When I told Una "don't pretend you're more of a clown than notscience" or something
It was a reference to this oof. I guess maybe he thought he was a vanilla cop, which would catch !goon Hoopla a phase sooner.

N2 I tracked RfS visiting notscience, who was the factional night kill. I crumbed that very clearly so you could exile him if I died. Some people claim their first guilty immediately but I don't get why you'd stop investigating like that.
N3 Not Mafia did not go anywhere.
N4 I did not receive a result, trying to target Una. This suggests that Not Mafia Is genuinely conftown, assuming the mafia are now at one goon one full roleblocker and that's why I couldn't act night four, then not-mafia would have been busy roleblocking people n3 as scum. It could randomly be an even night roleblocker or whatever but I'd like to just risk it.

I'm not sure which of Una or gera is scum

All my results are pretty clearly crumbed in the first post of each day phase, you can go look.

Right, so it's Isis and Not_Mafia then. Perfectly calculated by me

I think Isis is trying to go for the win today, as opposed to having her buddy clowned, since both Gera and I were looking to vote him.

VOTE: Isis

We have a flipped psychologist, follower, and Neapolitan lol. The tracker claim was a scumclaim in the first place actually. Isis has claimed another investigative in a setup with 3 flipped ones already, 1 of them being strong, and the other 2 being moderate.

1 mafia roleblocker
1 mafia indecisive motion detector
1 mafia goon
1 psychologist
1 tracker
1 follower
1 Neapolitan
1 2-shot compulsive commuter
5 Vt

That really looked balanced to you, Isis?

No but I consistently view the creations of NRG as imba.

The last time I was a PR it was

2 Mafia Goon
1 1-shot mafia strongman
1 weak doctor
1 psychologist
1 motion detector
1 1-shot vig
6 vt

So the weak doctor was strong than the neap and the motion detector was weaker than the tracker and oh that setup just had an additional conftown due to the 1-shot vig

Mastina also reviewed that one

The setup here is more heavily stacked if your role was real.

Those townsided setups are anomalies anyway, if you look through the most recently completed games, there's far fewer investigative power than what you're claiming here.

These are all very flawed investigative roles
It is a lot though so arguing with you is awk cause I feel bad for your faction :/
I think the utility of the indecisive motion detector was probably overrated