can you give me a sentence or so for each of the non-grapes-wagon townreads you have? (for reference, that's DrDoLittle, mcqueen, Xtoxm, Dannflor, and Karmelion)
xtox and ddl i think i went over in my big post.
mcqueen could be scum, not really sure. i'm townreading him because it's easy right now, but I could definitely see something like vedith/mcqueen - karmelion also is like this -i'd rather get shoshin lynched rn (she makes the most sense) and then come back to these two then argue about lurkerscum posters.
dannflor I went over. basically he's different from ND kinda - less aggressive. I also feel pretty comfortable in my ability to read him once he posts content. if I die tonight i revoke my townread
In post 2370, Extrapolated Eagle wrote:like i fear that if I bring mcqueen/karm up rn scum are gonna push the wrong direction => we end up divided because i got paranoid on a slot
okay
I think you're on the right general track, you just need to focus on getting confident reads in that general group
the highest scum equity part of the wagon is the Jingle/Alisae/Shoshin trichotomy and that makes the most sense with the third scum being off the wagon entirely
agreed
Shoshin is lynch today
through shoshin we can prove jingle/alisae are clean (or dirty if shoshin flips town for some reason)
then we look at mcqueen/vedith/karm etc. but worrying about them now might distract from lynch at hand
I'm alright with the Shoshin lynch if we don't take too long to hammer it.
Posted: Wed Mar 20, 2019 10:06 am
by Extrapolated Eagle
TBH I'm gonna call it shoshin/mcqueen
Posted: Wed Mar 20, 2019 10:07 am
by Vedith
I think it's a no \o/
Posted: Wed Mar 20, 2019 10:14 am
by Reiuji Utsuho
Posted: Wed Mar 20, 2019 10:22 am
by Fuscosco
I has some time, so let's do a thing or three.
Posted: Wed Mar 20, 2019 10:24 am
by Fuscosco
ffs, did fa place out already? I hope for the best.
Posted: Wed Mar 20, 2019 10:38 am
by Fuscosco
In post 16, Extrapolated Eagle wrote:Hm. The game thread hasn't gotten off to a particularly quick start, so I'll be a little more verbose with my opening post.
1. How comfortable do you feel playing town/scum?
2. What are you good at, what aren't you good at?
3. What part of playing mafia is most natural to you?
4. What is one thing about the current meta that you think should be changed?
5. How well do you know the other people in this game, and how excited are you to play?
hmmm, sure.
1: Town's easy, but I often get accused of being scum because I hold my cards and shitpost a lot. I'm quite paranoid though, and will often waiver on my reads several times a gameday, though I don't post that stuff. I usually run through most possible teams in my notes; when I bother taking notes.
Scum is . . . more fun, but it's good that you only roll it every fourth game or so. Too much would be a hassle.
2: I do not do any long and thick engagements. At all. I'm more of a one-liner kind of guy. This means I often sacrifice a professional appearance. I am good at hunting though, and when I don't overthink it I am more often than not right.
3: Night Actions and night wifom. I love me some scumside PT talk.
4: *shrugs* I dont know the current current meta. My last completed game was a while ago. But I guess I dislike how wishy-washy people can be.
- They drag out claims and wont lynch those claims, then repeat.
- They flip flop in their heads and in the thread.
- They won't commit to rereading yesterday today.
- They either never or always listen to the dead. Mostly never.
5: Its hit and miss here. Ive seen most of you, played at least once with many of you, and consider myself intimate enough with a couple to reliably meta.
In post 1924, Shoshin wrote:Vedith's town because he's defending me, period. There's no reason for scum to defend me here. And maybe Vedith isn't town, I don't know, but I'm not lynching him today because at least he's doing the pro-town thing of trying to keep me alive.
The irony of this post is that
In post 1904, Shoshin wrote:Not to mention how badly my town games have gone recently.
I have a winning game in geriatric get lost because I don't even know what happened.
And then I lose a town game where I didn't even get a chance to post once because a bunch of townies decided to quickhammer without letting me say anything.
This account is cursed.
VOTE: Shoshin
I'm moving on from this game and probably gonna stick to playing on my alts where I'm actually winning games.
She's not doing the pro-town thing of keeping herself alive
I was de-compiling everything about it
Does it matter? - Scum intent is to pocket, town intent is to bait
Should he need a reason? No, giving one is bad
Is any of this AI? Only if you ignore half of the variables like you did VOTE: Shoshin
This post is abrasive in a bad way, but again, scum and town reaction hunt. I want to dismiss it as reaction hunting.
In post 184, Frozen Angel wrote:I can't follow this discussion
I can't understand anyone talking xd not sure what shoshin is searching for and not sure what is lycan hitting shoshin with and the reasons.
nah, mate, its still kinda rvs here. I agree with the shos sentiment, but I dismiss alisae. Its too early, its kind of just shading people. But its too early to tell.
tr:dl:
- Kind of feel like rqs took too long to pull us out. Slightly concerned over eagle, shos does look like bullocks so far -skittish-, and vedi is a meta flag.