Mafiascum.net

In post 2374, Luca Blight wrote:

In post 2371, NorwegianboyEE wrote:I'm not really feeling hyped about any of the other options though. Lucy feels town to me, Farkran just seems really town, although i will admit Pooky's got a point in that their scum/town game is really similar. But how would you be so sure they are scum in this game then Pooky?

Wanna join on Chara?

I'm in the same boat tbh but Chara seems as good a wagon as any right now

What do you think about Farkran if we assume Skitter is town here?

I think Farkran is Town regardless of Skitter's alignment

In post 2371, NorwegianboyEE wrote:I'm not really feeling hyped about any of the other options though. Lucy feels town to me, Farkran just seems really town, although i will admit Pooky's got a point in that their scum/town game is really similar. But how would you be so sure they are scum in this game then Pooky?

1. his posts feel careful and artificial in a way - the vibe of them does not feel completely natural.

2. I think hes more interested in pushing an agend than figuring who is town/scum.

3. i think hes chainsaw defending here by attacking skitter and being selectively ignorant about her reasoning for voting lucy.

In post 2376, Luca Blight wrote:I think Farkran is Town regardless of Skitter's alignment

Could be, i just feel like there are too many town atm.

He spewed himself town in the argument just then imo

If anyone is scum from that argument then it's probably Pooky, but I think it was all TvTvT tbh

fwiw i also feel like farkran's push of me is agenda-driven in that i feel like he *should* be able to see and understand my pov here but resolutely is not

i also feel like he's imagining what he would do as scum in this circumstance and then calling me for not playing that way almost? idk unless i'm not understanding. but like he has some model in his head of what i'd be doing here but because i'm not playing that way i'm scum

Because Pooky seemed a little disingenuous in how he discredited what Farkran said, but maybe he is tunneling

fark calling me scum for me voting lucy when shes been buddying/hard townreading me all game is the most ludicrious take hes had in the last several pages and hes had several.

In post 2381, skitter30 wrote:fwiw i also feel like farkran's push of me is agenda-driven in that i feel like he *should* be able to see and understand my pov here but resolutely is not

i also feel like he's imagining what he would do as scum in this circumstance and then calling me for not playing that way almost? idk unless i'm not understanding. but like he has some model in his head of what i'd be doing here but because i'm not playing that way i'm scum

It was a heated argument, this shit happens. Egos take over and you just shout past each other

Farkran reflected my own thoughts in that argument. It took me a bit of time in a calm environment to see your PoV

In post 2383, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:fark calling me scum for me voting lucy when shes been buddying/hard townreading me all game is the most ludicrious take hes had in the last several pages and hes had several.

Just to entertain your arguments here.
Who do you think is likely scum with Farkran in a scum!Fark world?

And yeah, i checked their ISO. And i guess i can join you here Luca.
VOTE: Chara

Like being present in that argument just then I felt nothing but Townie vibes for the most part, like everyone was genuinely pissed off and really believed in what they were pushing

I need to read through it more thoroughly, but there's other stuff to catch-up on first which I'll get to now

Maybe. Like i said i'm cognizant of the fact that i may just be really annoyed, which is why i'm not actually voting

But, like, he looks scummy to me. Idk i'll try to calm down and think abt it some more

In post 1851, Day wrote:1542: Menalque has LegoLucy on his town list
1671: skitter22 suggests distaste at Lucy's vote
1678: Menalque ponders about Lucy but isn't sure
1679: skitter22 starts casing Lucy

So yeah, skitter22's right on Lucy's reasoning being flawed there.

I want so badly for Lucy to be town though.

I'm surprised Day doesn't see how this isn't actually scummy

In post 2385, NorwegianboyEE wrote:

In post 2383, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:fark calling me scum for me voting lucy when shes been buddying/hard townreading me all game is the most ludicrious take hes had in the last several pages and hes had several.

Just to entertain your arguments here.
Who do you think is likely scum with Farkran in a scum!Fark world?

fark/lucy

this is almost textbook chainsaw defense here.

In post 1864, Chara wrote:

In post 1862, skitter30 wrote:no but i have a guess for who she is

also day to compound the above: she's saying all of this right after she voted mena to e1. i.e. she's saying that i'm scummier than mena and that i'm trying to pocket him blah blah blah just after she placed the e1 vote on him (and thus indicating she scumreads him ...)

pedit yes can we vote lucy now? 1800 was awful

i mean yeah it's certainly not great, but i haven't liked what i've seen of Day's approach either.
i'm not sure about the unvote and then "i'll think on it". i first thought yeah, that's what Day should do given the timeline has apparently been cleared up, but maybe that's also what scum Day should do rather than doubling down, anyway.

This is a really bad justification for sticking on Day

In post 2254, NorwegianboyEE wrote:Skitter be having that Flavour Leaf effect where they can be scum and people will even admit they might be scum, but nobody will eliminate them because they are too charismatic to die early.

No it's because if she's town she might solve the goddamn game if given a few days.

In post 1917, skitter30 wrote:i also want to say (again) that i think that posting in an intentionally opaque fashion after other people have said it's hard to parse is scummy, even if it's a gimmick
(especially if it's a gimmick)

Ah, clearly you have not met Macabre

fwiw I do appreciate Lucy dropping the gimmick as I suck at reading players who use gimmicks

In post 2325, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:farkran isnt even playing in the same reality as us.

Perhaps, but he has been known to do this as town.

skitter my heart isn't really in the Lucy vote

maybe I'm biased but knowing that Lucy is isis inclines me more towards just bad than scum

possibly
i'm probably not voting nor rn tho

In post 1955, LegoLucy wrote:I didn't really pay close enough attention to Menalque's progression. So that theory is a dud. The main point is the standard town explanation of what you're doing making little sense. If seems like it pushes some scum objective, it seems good to make my best guess at it.

Ah, and Lucy even acknowledged the mistake here so I don't know why that continued to be an issue