In post 2410, Keyser Söze wrote:We can talk about (or go through) Eragon’s ISO:
First chapter:
- his town read on Creature
- his initial scum lean/suspicion on DrJ
- his one vs one with Relly
In post 1815, LabRat01 wrote: In post 1559, Keyser Söze wrote: In post 1521, LabRat01 wrote:I’m not going to use that as an argument, but actually, the fact that you said “he should be getting TRs from TRing creat” already makes it a valid scum motivation.
But that’s more of a fun fact than anything
(
Thinking further on this today, when I looked at Eragon's D1 ISO - in my opinion, the nature of Eragon's town read of Creature and subsequent actions in D1 demonstrate he was not interested in town cred / winning town points
)
That’s not sth I’d personally like to rely on tbh.
The read felt ok to me, because it fit how I remembered Eragon get his reads normally, but I don’t think it should be indicative in either way. Even if he’s scum, I don’t think it would be that difficult for him to enter the game with making a honest read on a townie.
If he didn’t read the thread and he was asked to spontaneously read someone, the read would be 9/10 times a honest one regardless of alignment. I wouldn’t expect him to blatantly lie about that read even as scum, because without the knowledge of what happened on the thread, he’d have to base the read on his own “standard” scum-hunting ideas anyways.
That’s not a reason to push him imo, but I’m not gonna TR him for it either.
The SRs he got from that are a bit more interesting imo. I still kind of think that it would be weird for so many people to miss or misread eragon’s explanations at the same time (don’t remember who pushed him rn, but that might be a good way to start off later).
Tbh that’s the 0nIy thing that I reaIIy disagree with
I stiII think his read 0n DrJ is m0re IikeIy t0 c0me fr0m t0wn than scum.
Reas0ning same as bef0re
And the 0nIy thing I remember ab0ut the 1 vs 1 with irre was that it was started by Irre, then erag0n freaked 0ut, then irre freaked 0ut and in the end aII 0f it I00ked intense, but rather shaII0w/unimpressive fr0m b0th sides
Erag0n is fuIIy capabIe 0f hard-bussing, but tbh idk
If he reaIIy is scum here, his interacti0ns with his teammates w0uId be nearIy identicaI t0 his interacti0ns in the previ0us purgat0ry game [the scum-team hard-bussed each 0ther. They w0n, s0 I guess it paid 0ff,,,)
I think it’s rather safe t0 assume that scum!erag0n w0uId be reIying 0n his previ0us game experience in here
And again, if s0, I think his c0nfusi0n and Iack 0f presence in the 1-st heaven phase w0uId be weird c0ming f0rm scum
he:
1- Had experience
2- pIanned t0 pIay in the exact same way anyways
s0 being I0w-key after that enthusiastic start sh0uId be m0re t0wn-indicative f0r him im0 :/
But tbh I stiII want t0 re-read that
I’m g0ing 0ff my mem0ry here and it’s,,, ugh,,, n0t abs0IuteIy f00Ipr00f, s0 d0n’t take my w0rd f0r it
