I thought one of Huntress/Uct was scum. VCA is starting to point to Huntress being scum.
GM is probably scum as well. I think the last one is Nero. Dave is town due to Zeb posting his reads when he replaced out. Only a townie would do that I feel.
Good posting.
About WIFOM: Sometimes I just get thirsty and drink both glasses.
Well, I was wrong on most of my reads, in fact the only "good" read I had came at the very end of the game where I said to look at people who didn't replace. Huntress and gm had been in the entire game, and there's no reason for them to replace, they were winning by a landslide.
hephaestus, if he had stayed in, would have gotten himself killed too, so Nero did a good job.
I still think I did the right thing by killing myself because I would have taken out BBT or Shinobi before hephaestus, so I would have lost us the game anyway.
"Also the town owes uctriton an apology for throwing him under the bus." - RXK
"I hate whoever shot triton." - Bumi
@Mod, you did a fine job, but I agree 3 week timelines are way too long; the days become gluttonous pages (like 20-25+ pages each?) and catching up becomes a chore and apathy sets in. Other than that, no complaints, congrats on your first completed game!
What happened with the Wisdom force replace?
"Also the town owes uctriton an apology for throwing him under the bus." - RXK
"I hate whoever shot triton." - Bumi
↑uctriton00 wrote:This game was extremely hard to gauge, I would have driven us off a cliff
So my guts are huntress and GM, then idk for 3rd
I still think aegor is town because I don't see a scenario where a scum is force replaced
↑Shinobi wrote:Yeah, I was gonna say that I didn't find any of those reads to be particularly useful.
No offense.
heh
Yeah Shinobi my frustration with you that day was completely sincere, I thought you were making a case just for making a case. What seriously went through your head when you said "I found the bullshit, I am attacking it?". Like seriously, what was that?
"Also the town owes uctriton an apology for throwing him under the bus." - RXK
"I hate whoever shot triton." - Bumi
↑beastcharizard wrote:Wisdom was replaced for fear of having outside knowledge of the game given to them by another player.
Didn't see this mod.
I'll PM you; in my second moderated game I had a mistake where I had to force replace someone, so if we share experiences maybe we can learn from them?
"Also the town owes uctriton an apology for throwing him under the bus." - RXK
"I hate whoever shot triton." - Bumi
↑uctriton00 wrote:This game was extremely hard to gauge, I would have driven us off a cliff
So my guts are huntress and GM, then idk for 3rd
I still think aegor is town because I don't see a scenario where a scum is force replaced
↑Shinobi wrote:Yeah, I was gonna say that I didn't find any of those reads to be particularly useful.
No offense.
heh
Yeah Shinobi my frustration with you that day was completely sincere, I thought you were making a case just for making a case. What seriously went through your head when you said "I found the bullshit, I am attacking it?". Like seriously, what was that?
Nothing, really. I'm a big fan of pointless rhetoric.
I probably wouldn't have voted you at all if I was actually paying attention the whole time. I just kind of hopped on and saw a thing I didn't like, so I went "let's see where this goes."
No matter how high the stakes, sooner or later you're just gonna have to go with your gut.
And maybe, just maybe, that'll take you right where you were supposed to be.
