Mafiascum.net

In post 2473, popsofctown wrote:

In post 2469, CheekyTeeky wrote:

In post 2467, popsofctown wrote:idk if you've made a single read I agree with all game

Is that why you scumread me?

It is a large component I feel like you couldn't possibly be that bad

I've never understood people who think like you do. Catching scum is a process, judge me at the end of the game.

Also just to be bitch, I wasn't the one of the mislynch wagon

Cheeky who is your scumpool rn?

In post 2474, popsofctown wrote:Please don't gladiate.

Creature you're not gonna be that easy to read if you're not having a fun time this game.

Great

Can we discuss the non-mechanical essences of each player's soul then?

LUV but nullscumreading you, momo, PK, pops and AP.

HH was there until their second good mechanical idea of the game.

Basically everybody that isn't Bingle, Apthet, Creature, Dunnstral, HH.

AP will be sorted as the game goes on.
LUV will be either lynched or stumped today.
Momo needs actions used on so I'll neighbour him (or get killed trying).
PK and Pops people could use actions on as they're probably like vecna - town that I'm scumreading.

idk that's what makes them deep

That's helpful.

In post 2479, CheekyTeeky wrote:LUV but nullscumreading you, momo, PK, pops and AP.

HH was there until their second good mechanical idea of the game.

Basically everybody that isn't Bingle, Apthet, Creature, Dunnstral, HH.

Okay
I think LUV is a decent gladiate target rn

DON'T USE AN ANTITOWN ROLE

BP - apthet
Captain - momo
Neighbor - Gamma
Day 3 Post restricted - Bingle
Psychologist - pops
Tracker - Vecna
Revisor -
Chronomage -
Doublevoter -
Treestump -
Lynch -
Thoughts from role list.

PEdit: No gladiating ever. The purpose of gladiator is to prove you have it to solve balance concerns. We know you have it.

Oh, pk's a neighbor now, he should swap with Vecna.

In post 2447, popsofctown wrote:What happened to using a key for the two different anime characters you two are roleplaying?

The 3 hour minimum on revisor means that town can coordinate around it in a LyLo situation. You would have to troll with it before LyLo and put yourself at serious risk for getting vengelynched over it to get some use out of it. I think it will be mostly weak.

On a reread it cannot affect King due to the 3 hour minimum. The king's proposal is voted on for 0 hours.

I'm p sure the only reason Maria hasn't replaced out is because I asked her really nicely not to leave me alone. For better or worse you're mostly getting me here. We both agree though that if we can get the mechanics right it literally doesn't matter how good or bad we are at this game, between five investigations so far we should be able to nail this. I don't have a problem with the lynches being discussed, I mostly want to ask her if Creature is playing to this magic auto-town or scum meta that I keep hearing about.

You can't guarentee town can coordinate around Revisor because by LYLO there's no way people will agree who "The Town" are. Either way do you see any harm in giving it to someone whose alignment is about to be confirmed?

Edit: uh Vecna is dead, lo... did you mean pisskop since he's the other neighbour now

Why do you people only post when its time to cut me

In post 2283, CheekyTeeky wrote:PK proposed the roles and is universal back up.

I proposed the roles, pk sheeped it.

In post 2275, Lil Uzi Vert wrote:Give Bingle tree stump if we all end up town reading him.

WTF?

In post 2299, pisskop wrote:Additionally. very odd that i was immediately fingered for the proposal, since it was literally Jingle's from a page or two before mine.

And you know, all the people who almost immediately supported it.


Its not a good look, Cheeks and momo, to fingerbang me when there's so many other places to look. it looks like faux-townrage.

^This.

In post 2489, Hidden Happiness wrote:Why do you people only post when its time to cut me

?

momo can't be a captain, his gimp includes day actions

In post 2316, Hidden Happiness wrote:

In post 2304, pisskop wrote:Maybe we should make cheeks use her gladiator today?

Other then making sure they get lynched this time idk why we'd do this, but considering that's the result I'd want anyways..

So without thinking about it too hard is there any reason not to do something like this?

Night 2 Bulletproof:
Captain:
Chronomage:
Doublevoter:
Neighbour #3:

Gamma Emerald

Day 3 Post Restricted:
Psychologist:

pisskop

Revisor:
Night 3 Compulsive Role Caller:
Even-Night Tracker:

popsofctown

Treestump:
Compulsive Quitter:

We could put all three of the investigative roles into the Neighbour PT for secret results sharing, which I guess isn't as useless when they're outted but there's still value to being able to hide results until someone accidentally contradicts them. Another useful possibility is putting one as the Night 3 Compulsive Role Caller so three people can discuss the next day's roles in advance

and get half the proposal arguing overwith.

- Shadoweh

+1

In post 2494, Hidden Happiness wrote:momo can't be a captain, his gimp includes day actions

That's the point. We give it to him and he can't use it, so no one is the captain and we don't have to worry about the clearly scum utility role that is dangerous as fuck.

In post 2488, Hidden Happiness wrote: You can't guarentee town can coordinate around Revisor because by LYLO there's no way people will agree who "The Town" are. Either way do you see any harm in giving it to someone whose alignment is about to be confirmed?

In 5p LyLo I think your concern is kinda valid, in the more likely 3p LyLo it doesn't matter whether people "agree" who "the town" is. In the cases where the two townies agree they should vote the scum together, they can wait until each of them logs in at the same time and hammer it together, even if that scum is a revisor. In cases where two townies do not agree they should vote the scum together, we lose 100% of those games anyway, scum do not selfvote.

But yeah I don't see much harm in Revisor going to Cheeky.

pedit:
Oh yeah, mom is hardlock captain good notice

chrono is also negative utility but momo can't be both

In post 2335, Creature wrote:tbh I would rather we just manually decide the kills and throw the rest of the names in random.org

I would be 100% down for deciding Compulsive Quitter and Treestump normally (maj vote) and then building proposals around that, actually.