What reactions? The soulshifter is alone. He has no additional information. Consequently the only difference between him and a town player is that he knows that there is no correct answer. On the other hand, we have an unknown number of people who know that 1 person is innocent. Why keep that information secret?Xylthixlm wrote:This is an absolutely horrible idea. The masons can claim if they're going to be lynched. There's no reason to claim them early; it messes up reactions and gives the scum info on who to kill.qwints wrote:I'd argue the masons should mass claim.
In order to avoid the danger of a paired power role being snuffed out, we could simply have masons not claim their partner. The soulshifter couldn't claim mason because that would give us an odd number and lead to an inst-death.
My feeling is that narrowing the pool of targets is more useful than preserving town power roles given the fact that there is only one scum. I'll do the math on this and try to explain why this is in a bit.