Signs and Void (Game Over) [TM2015]

[Tammy]

oh

bane: shadoweh

[hitogoroshi]

VC 1 (Minor Day 1, VC 1)

Bane:

Target player's Sign is revealed.

(1)

Titus:

ChannelDelibird [L-10]
(1)

No Bane:

Titus

(Gammagooey)

[L-10]
(1)

ChannelDelibird:

Cheetory6 [L-10]
(1)

Zar:

Gammagooey [L-10]
(1)

Shadoweh:

Tammy [L-10]

(15)

No Bane Vote:

Actiondan, Antihero, Aronis, Bulbazak, Deasvail, Espeonage, fferyllt, GuyinFreezer, Marquis, Mastin2, Shadoweh, T S O, Untrod Tripod, Vezokpiraka, Zar

(ChannelDelibird, Gammagooey, Titus, Cheetory6, Tammy)

Choice:

Should protection stop

one

kill, but inform players when a kill on them was prevented; or

two

kills, without this information?

(4)

Two:

Gammagooey, Titus, Untrod Tripod, Cheetory6 [L-7]
(1)

One:

ChannelDelibird

(15)

No Choice Vote:

Actiondan, Antihero, Aronis, Bulbazak, Deasvail, Espeonage, fferyllt, GuyinFreezer, Marquis, Mastin2, Shadoweh, Tammy, T S O, Vezokpiraka, Zar

(Gammagooey, ChannelDelibird, Titus, Untrod Tripod, Cheetory6)

With 20 votes in play, it takes 11 to Bane or Choose. Deadline is Sunday, April 5th at 9 PM CST.

Minor Day One Deadline

(expired on 2015-04-05 21:00:00)

[Zar]

Gotta keep in character, I guess? ##

Vote: tammy

.

btw, my

circlejerk

team thinks espy is the most likely player to have waged scum tokens into this setup... regfan met him irl and apparently he couldn't stop talking about how much he loves being scum and all these evil mustache twirling plans he had in mind for future scum games, so...

[T S O]

Are we allowed vote to Boon ourselves? Because, I can tell you, I feel like a Boon.

[Titus]

Tammy. I'm going to assume you're fishing for townreads if you keep making posts giving the impression that you haven't read the rules. If you're town, go read the rules. Kthnx.

@Titus, how will scum know if we've baned Alquin unless they claim? We don't necessarily have to have anyone claim roles during minor day and we don't necessarily have to lynch the person we bane on MajD1.

Alquin's sign is in the first post. If we bane someone who has a candle sign, and they die then we basically did scum's job for them as Alquin cannot be protected.

We shiuld use bane as a verifier. If someone says they matched sign, the bane verifies.

[ActionDan]

Bane: Gamma

Choose: One

[hitogoroshi]

Are we allowed vote to Boon ourselves? Because, I can tell you, I feel like a Boon.

Sure, assuming there's a Boon being voted on.

Note that I will not be accepting Banes/Boons submitted by saying "Vote" during Minor Days so I can be sure you know exactly what you're voting

for

. Sorry, people who love the word vote! You get to use it in Major Days.

[T S O]

Tammy. I'm going to assume you're fishing for townreads if you keep making posts giving the impression that you haven't read the rules. If you're town, go read the rules. Kthnx.

@Titus, how will scum know if we've baned Alquin unless they claim? We don't necessarily have to have anyone claim roles during minor day and we don't necessarily have to lynch the person we bane on MajD1.

Alquin's sign is in the first post. If we bane someone who has a candle sign, and they die then we basically did scum's job for them as Alquin cannot be protected.

Presumably there are other Candle players in the game?

[ActionDan]

Gotta keep in character, I guess? ##

Vote: tammy

.

btw, my

circlejerk

team thinks espy is the most likely player to have waged scum tokens into this setup... regfan met him irl and apparently he couldn't stop talking about how much he loves being scum and all these evil mustache twirling plans he had in mind for future scum games, so...

The money is not in your mouth!

[Titus]

Tammy. I'm going to assume you're fishing for townreads if you keep making posts giving the impression that you haven't read the rules. If you're town, go read the rules. Kthnx.

@Titus, how will scum know if we've baned Alquin unless they claim? We don't necessarily have to have anyone claim roles during minor day and we don't necessarily have to lynch the person we bane on MajD1.

Alquin's sign is in the first post. If we bane someone who has a candle sign, and they die then we basically did scum's job for them as Alquin cannot be protected.

Presumably there are other Candle players in the game?

Yes but I am not one for taking chances. Mafia is a game of information as much as it is about reading people. We have a source of information the mafia want. Most of use have trace and detect. We use it on the people we want to learn more about. There's no need to take chances.

[Tammy]

Tammy. I'm going to assume you're fishing for townreads if you keep making posts giving the impression that you haven't read the rules. If you're town, go read the rules. Kthnx.

@Titus, how will scum know if we've baned Alquin unless they claim? We don't necessarily have to have anyone claim roles during minor day and we don't necessarily have to lynch the person we bane on MajD1.

Alquin's sign is in the first post. If we bane someone who has a candle sign, and they die then we basically did scum's job for them as Alquin cannot be protected.

We shiuld use bane as a verifier. If someone says they matched sign, the bane verifies.

If you're actually serious about ermigerds we should not out anyones sign because then scum will know who they can kill, then I'd suggest stopping with this line of discussion because I imagine any responses or discussion this will provoke will narrow down people's signs.

[T S O]

So how exactly are you proposing we utilise the Bane?

[Tammy]

Also the use bane as a verifier is dumb.

[T S O]

Choose: Two

[Tammy]

Also, I'm not going to cry if we bane someone suspicious, and scum kill them for us.

[T S O]

Choosing between One and Two seems to be kinda irrelevant to me, honestly, but I'd prefer Two to One.

[Untrod Tripod]

Choosing between One and Two seems to be kinda irrelevant to me, honestly

...this that a joke?

[T S O]

Not really.

[ActionDan]

He means the value we get. And he's right

[Titus]

Tammy. I'm going to assume you're fishing for townreads if you keep making posts giving the impression that you haven't read the rules. If you're town, go read the rules. Kthnx.

@Titus, how will scum know if we've baned Alquin unless they claim? We don't necessarily have to have anyone claim roles during minor day and we don't necessarily have to lynch the person we bane on MajD1.

Alquin's sign is in the first post. If we bane someone who has a candle sign, and they die then we basically did scum's job for them as Alquin cannot be protected.

We shiuld use bane as a verifier. If someone says they matched sign, the bane verifies.

If you're actually serious about ermigerds we should not out anyones sign because then scum will know who they can kill, then I'd suggest stopping with this line of discussion because I imagine any responses or discussion this will provoke will narrow down people's signs.

Not sure how talking about the pros and cons narrows down people's signs...

[Tammy]

Gotta keep in character, I guess? ##

Vote: tammy

.

btw, my

circlejerk

team thinks espy is the most likely player to have waged scum tokens into this setup... regfan met him irl and apparently he couldn't stop talking about how much he loves being scum and all these evil mustache twirling plans he had in mind for future scum games, so...

Hi zar!

I just realized your team name has a flaw. While empire is a member of westeros, he hasn't actually played a game there. That should be rectified before team mafia is done with, so at least you'll have some truth in advertising.

[ActionDan]

Although

@Mod: When you say "protection from 2 kills", is that protection spread over 2 or more people or the same person?

[Tammy]

Tammy. I'm going to assume you're fishing for townreads if you keep making posts giving the impression that you haven't read the rules. If you're town, go read the rules. Kthnx.

@Titus, how will scum know if we've baned Alquin unless they claim? We don't necessarily have to have anyone claim roles during minor day and we don't necessarily have to lynch the person we bane on MajD1.

Alquin's sign is in the first post. If we bane someone who has a candle sign, and they die then we basically did scum's job for them as Alquin cannot be protected.

We shiuld use bane as a verifier. If someone says they matched sign, the bane verifies.

If you're actually serious about ermigerds we should not out anyones sign because then scum will know who they can kill, then I'd suggest stopping with this line of discussion because I imagine any responses or discussion this will provoke will narrow down people's signs.

Not sure how talking about the pros and cons narrows down people's signs...

Talking about pros and cons does not. However, that is not only what you're doing. You've brought in the Alcuin and the candle discussion to the mix.

[Untrod Tripod]

Although

@Mod: When you say "protection from 2 kills", is that protection spread over 2 or more people or the same person?

how about you figure out the specifics of what the fuck you're talking about before you start talking down to people

see you in 30 pages

[T S O]

It's two pages in, and the first bitch has began to moan.