Mafiascum.net

In post 1153, Varsoon wrote:Irrel, if you're still reading, sorry for being insistent on your wagon. When you straight up disappeared under pressure, I thought you were caught scum not trying to throw up associative tells.

it's okay, I forgot to announce my weekend v/la's
just win for town so I have a chance at that graphic novel and I'll be happy

Varsoon, you tipped your hand too hard without just coming right out and saying it! I mean, not that you could've predicted that, but

In post 5, schadd_ wrote:

nsg mafia

In post 8, Irrelephant11 wrote:wowow nsg's scum game has slightly improved from what I am familiar with
varsoon being town sort of annoys me, because shoshin will probably stay stuck in a tunnel
unfortunate that gamma's real claim looks so towny

Jesus fuck
I CAUGHT nsg
SINGLEHANDEDLY
but noooooo

Why the fuck does scum get a DAYVIG
like
damn

well
welcome

Mad at myself for not just coming out and playing it smart but it turns out the setup is dumb so playing smart is dumb.

The whole thing makes me really upset.

In post 19, xyzzy wrote:mafia kill is northsidegal killing Creature... wow, Varsoon is just, like, gonna catch scum night 1 with a roleblock, huh

Like holy shit it's so obvious NSG is scum with that play and that NSG, if scum, would be the one to commit the kill. That's why I blocked there with confidence despite my block being 1-shot.

I really really hope some gets my NSG crumb
Damn it

yeah that's a very sad way to go
on the other hand I think nsg will get caught eventually because of her d1 play that made you suspicious enough to choose her
As will gammagooey because of this play
Also I had a couple of great crumbs that I don't think scum will easily find so sircakez can conftown himself whenever
Overall our team is set up well to win and you were shoshin's fav lynch there for awhile so maybe this isn't the worst set of circumstances

I wonder if town will start to play in such a way as to keep scum off the EOD lynchwagons for gold reasons

ooh you had a crumb? I missed it, gonna go look now

Like if this town isn't awful at this game, they'll look at my flip, realize "Oh shit his ABILITY informed him of SCUM that's why there was no NK!"
And then they'll figure that my 1152 CLEARLY points to scum
And they'll either get the first letter of each line being NSG was the crumb or that because I single out Goo who immediately shot me, he's gotta be scum
But I don't put a lot of stock into the skill of players like Shoshin or Kokichi, so I'm pretty sure they'll screw this up.
Damn it.

Like we're in a solid position, 2 town down but 1 confirmable by claim isn't bad on D2 especially given the info we have but
hoooleee shit I'm upset

LIKE COMEON
THE FACT THAT GOOEY IS SITTING AROUND GLOATING FOR KILLING TOWN THAT OBVIOUSLY JUST CAUGHT SCUM
HOLY SHIT
AND THEN HE GHOSTS THE SECOND THAT SKITTER ASKS WHY
PUT THE PIECES TOGETHER
THERE IS NO WAY YOU ARE ALL SO DENSE THIS SLIPS PAST YOU

I think you super underestimate Shoshin
She doesn't play how you like but she does pretty well as town
She's never mislynched, and ~half her scumreads are spot on and she pushes them well (she pushes the wrong reads just as well which is her biggest game flaw but)
Also skitter is super thorough
I have confidence

Your NSG crumb is actually amazing but idk if they'll notice it. I wouldn't look for it, probably, but it's right there... We'll see. Gamma is defo going down though

THAT IS NOT TOWN PLAY
NO VIG SHOOTS TOWN WHO SOFTS A GUILTY WITHOUT AT LEAST ASKING THE NAME
LIKE GODDAMN

I definitely underestimate Shoshin for death-tunneling me all the way down to the very predictable "uses the gacha on me" part.

Sounds like you're just bitter about her misreading you
You were voting me with confidence for activity while I had the v/la banner up, so
:shrug:

Yeee
But I actually still kept my head stuck out and engaged other players and generated content across the board.
I'm fine with being scumread--I entered the game in a way to deliberately be scumread and not be NK'd since I had a role with a decent chance of catching scum.
It's mostly that Shoshin scumread me at the expense of looking anywhere else or engaging anywhere else, which leads to a whole 2 weeks of wasted time on Shoshin's part, as well as a complete bust of the Gacha ability.

oh I just caught the crumb, that's cute! I hope that gets caught simply because it'd be delightful for someone to organically pick up on it

in the original version of this setup, the mafia was pretty weak, and the Jess the Beheader role was situational to the point where it might not ever make sense to use it -- making her a day vigilante evolved out of trying to increase the mafia's power. the most expensive Fantasy Costco items are basically game-winning for town if they can get to them, and generally the Fantasy Gachapon abilities will represent at least a small swing in the town's favor. a mafia day vigilante is for sure a powerful role in just about any setup, and an argument could be made that it's a bad role to include regardless, but imo it doesn't make the setup scum-sided.

I'll definitely reconsider depending on how town plays this out but yeah

P-EDIT:
Yeah, I can definitely see the Gacha abilities being very 'win more' for a town that's already winning.

To be honest, if I was scum right now, I'd cover with a "My role starts with 150 gold and gains 50 on lynches, so I was on the wagon and doctored this player' to explain away the No Kill

Looks like they're coming around to Gooey scum, thankfully, with SirCakez preaching NSG needing a looking-at.
So at least my death wasn't totally in vain.

yeah, the mafia PT has pretty much treating a Gammagooey lynch as a sure thing that they shouldn't even try to evade ever since they decided on that daykill a couple hours ago.

Ooof.
Still worried town'll get caught up in false associatives. They're already pitching out literally half the townlist.