So, if we lim correctly, we have to probably miselim because I don’t think it very likely that there two saboteurs on this team.
Posted: Fri Jun 24, 2022 11:22 am
by Loki Dokie
In post 29, Aisa wrote:Sorry for the absence - had a couple busy days.
Myself and Loki have argued that Gamma seems more inquisitive this game than some of his past scum games. What do you make of this, NotHectic?
@Aisa. who do you think the saboteur is because we know there’s at least one or else
I’d right now be in some gin soaked jazz club likely doing the Charleston otherwise
the game would be over.
Posted: Fri Jun 24, 2022 11:58 am
by NotAHecticAlt
In post 29, Aisa wrote:Sorry for the absence - had a couple busy days.
Myself and Loki have argued that Gamma seems more inquisitive this game than some of his past scum games. What do you make of this, NotHectic?
I don't see it, sorry.
Posted: Fri Jun 24, 2022 11:59 am
by NotAHecticAlt
Im at family tonight but this will be my full focus after work tomorow
Posted: Fri Jun 24, 2022 12:05 pm
by Fidget
Yeah, we'll cross the bridge of what to do after executing a terminator when we get there. Best not to think about it yet.
I don't immediately suspect Gamma for thinking something odd of my play, although, I mean it when I say it was vanilla ice cream reasoning. It's just bland. I can't be the only player who didn't really anticipate the game ending abruptly.
I don't see an obvious scum over town incentive for the vote. I just wanna talk more about it and see where you're coming from exactly
Posted: Fri Jun 24, 2022 12:18 pm
by Aisa
Oof.
I was hoping
hoping
that I'd reread main thread and come out of it like "yep Definitely Actually Not Hectic is scum here".
Actually I came out of it with more of a townread. Which is an issue. Is anyone else here worried about NAHA or should I just shelve it as a lim for this day phase
In post 29, Aisa wrote:Sorry for the absence - had a couple busy days.
Myself and Loki have argued that Gamma seems more inquisitive this game than some of his past scum games. What do you make of this, NotHectic?
@Aisa. who do you think the saboteur is because we know there’s at least one or else
I’d right now be in some gin soaked jazz club likely doing the Charleston otherwise
the game would be over.
No clue at the moment. Maybe I could be persuaded on Gamma? Maybe you could make an argument that all they had to get townread in this game is to engage more actively and ask more questions. I am underestimating their scum range then they could easily be scum here.
Then again if we're gonna play the "I am underestimating their range" game you could make that argument for nearly everyone, so :/
So, if we lim correctly, we have to probably miselim because I don’t think it very likely that there two saboteurs on this team.
Ok but like, who is the saboteur, what is your plan for finding them?
In post 17, Loki Dokie wrote:I have an extremely difficult time believing team 1 is pure especially since my most confident scumread voted team
So maybe we figure this out by having everyone give reads, not just on team 2 but on the rest of the playerlist.
I think there’s at least one scum off either team: toog
Penguin is town offwagon. Not really sure about anyone else but Fire could be town since he sr toog. Enchant no idea? Don’t remember who else didn’t get picked.
On team 1, I think Andante’s probably town. Have some possible worries about ejji depending on who’s scum in team 2 but think RR most likely.
On team 2, I know I’m town and think CSF and NAHA are as well and beyond that not sure. NAHA suspects Gamma and he suspects you and Aisa could be town but no idea. So that’s where I’m at.
Posted: Fri Jun 24, 2022 12:41 pm
by Aisa
Ok, so you think CSF and NAHA are probably town and you're not sure beyond that. That answers the first half of my question. Do you have a plan for how you're gonna develop a read on the others?
Posted: Fri Jun 24, 2022 1:06 pm
by Gamma Emerald
In post 36, Aisa wrote:Oof.
I was hoping
hoping
that I'd reread main thread and come out of it like "yep Definitely Actually Not Hectic is scum here".
Actually I came out of it with more of a townread. Which is an issue. Is anyone else here worried about NAHA or should I just shelve it as a lim for this day phase
mood
and yeah I'm pretty confident NAHA is town
Posted: Fri Jun 24, 2022 1:10 pm
by Aisa
Ah screw it here's a NAHA wallpost
Spoiler: wallll
blah why does no one feel towny
oh roden/fidget prob town i forgot lmao
i would probably leader the latter moreso tho
ok i have 5 town including myself im somewhat confident in im gaming now
These are all within 1 minute of each other. Do I believe this is genuine? Overall I think I do.
also i just thought of it but we should maybe plan on being potentially pulled into PTs and doing a minigame that requires some level of coordination that scum may have.
we should definitely think of planning ahead and guessing if such a minigame exists so we know what we will choose in the case of something like a secret vote or something like that
OTOH I do not believe for a second that scum NAHA wouldn't be capable of this.
oh lmao i just realized i kinda did overhype the penguin townread and internally made it stronger than it should be
regardless im fine with my heal there as i think the controversy around it spews penguin town :3
More showing awareness of their reads. Idk I think overall this is a good sign. There is some more of this sorta stuff in their ISO.
ok ill spill why i want to be leader so bad - because i believe that leader gets nightkill immunity likely and id like that for myself.
Yeah I buy that.
It is terrible play to assume a non poster is town. That is how you want me to play. I will not. I will sooner eliminate the 0 poster and expect it to flip scum over most of the rest of the playerlist
This is the type of post that I find hard to parse. On one hand this is a good post. But scum agenda?!?!
I'd go for loki fidget aisa
Thats it
Csf has a fairly polarized game and IMO she has shown her town game here- and there are takes i dont believe she makes as scum, i.e. they feel too bold for her - in that i dont think we mindmeld the way we have this game if she is mafia.
Sure you can call me scum and say that shes just scum with me but if you can see one of us as town the other should come naturally.
I don't really understand these two posts that came within like 5 minutes of one another.
gamma copied my idea of accusing someone of an unnatural townread bc i accused them of it first lmao
realizing that i am a threat this phase as ive caught scum gamma recently after misreading them SoDs
He knows i can find his alignment and thus has to resort to discrediting me.
other players who ive been more successful in reading have done the same - discred me before i gain the power to bury them
I kinda like this.
can people explain why they support the team they are voting by explaining it player by player btw?
It would be helpful in case we are wrong (which i believe is going to happen regardless of the team bc i scumread a person from both)
If there is town between RR/Gamma i believe that it is important for them to towntell in a way that gets their team through so we just win - bc thats the only place i think there is scum atp
This also feels like town Not Hectic.
I don't see it, sorry.
Scum motivation panic aaa, but also rationally this could just as easily come from town.
Maybe this whole trying to read post-by-post trying to find a tone tell is not serving me well in this situation? Maybe I should look at their motivation instead?
I think they have overall good points on the rodent in the main thread and I quite like that?
In post 36, Aisa wrote:Oof.
I was hoping
hoping
that I'd reread main thread and come out of it like "yep Definitely Actually Not Hectic is scum here".
Actually I came out of it with more of a townread. Which is an issue. Is anyone else here worried about NAHA or should I just shelve it as a lim for this day phase
mood
and yeah I'm pretty confident NAHA is town
Can you explain why? It can be just one sentence if you want.
Posted: Fri Jun 24, 2022 1:18 pm
by Aisa
Last spam and then I promise I will go, I just thought of something. I really like NAHA's takes in this game. I think part of the problem might be that in one of my previous games I nearly got burned by this scum when I thought I mind-melded sooo well with him and now I'm just wary of mind-melding as a sorting tool. But maybe, just maybe, it is time for me to chalk that up to bad luck, let gooo of those reservations and embrace mind-melding once more
In post 10, Cat Scratch Fever wrote:I'm in this weird place where I had high hopes that we would pass but also am not that surprised the mission failed. In hindsight maybe the team was approved with too little resistance
Is there anything you wanna know? x
(Maybe if I throw in a cheeky x at the end of my sentences you'll start thinking that I'm friendly? x)
Who do you think is scum in this PT?
My impression of your posts in thread were that your posts were focused disproportionately on mech/event setup. Early game I feel like that's ok to do, but I think you were doing it as the game picked up a bit more too.
Posted: Fri Jun 24, 2022 1:47 pm
by Cat Scratch Fever
I will be
v/la this Saturday and Sunday
for a weekend trip :>, but I plan to reread some of the main thread tonight
In post 36, Aisa wrote:Oof.
I was hoping
hoping
that I'd reread main thread and come out of it like "yep Definitely Actually Not Hectic is scum here".
Actually I came out of it with more of a townread. Which is an issue. Is anyone else here worried about NAHA or should I just shelve it as a lim for this day phase
mood
and yeah I'm pretty confident NAHA is town
Can you explain why? It can be just one sentence if you want.
