Mafiascum.net

↑ Sotty7 wrote:I'm gonna have to replace out guys. From three to ten pages in less than 24 hours.

No way I can handle this pace.

Peace out and enjoy.

(SD replaces Sotty7)

↑ orcinus_theoriginal wrote:

↑ pitoli wrote:Personally I’m liking Buldermar for scum, only because he keeps going on about how valuable Ffery’s going to be. It feels like he’s defending her experience/ability rather than her posts right now.

Pitoli's wagon is shit.

Not sure you've said that enough times...

Do you think I would have gotten this many votes if you hadn't voted me as a reaction test?


@SafetyDance: Welcome!

In the wagon's defense you have some truly terrible questions.

↑ orcinus_theoriginal wrote:

↑ fferyllt wrote:

↑ orcinus_theoriginal wrote:

↑ pitoli wrote:Personally I’m liking Buldermar for scum, only because he keeps going on about how valuable Ffery’s going to be. It feels like he’s defending her experience/ability rather than her posts right now.

Pitoli's wagon is shit.

Who do you want to lynch?

Well you sort of

Failing that I want to policy one of Nero and lurker

Do you think that one or both are scum? Because we can't policy lynch everyone who deserves it and win.

↑ pitoli wrote:Personally I’m liking Buldermar for scum, only because he keeps going on about how valuable Ffery’s going to be. It feels like he’s defending her experience/ability rather than her posts right now.

Indeed I am, but why does it make me scum?

↑ fferyllt wrote:I guess that means that right now I cautiously have you as town.

↑ fferyllt wrote:so yeah, not feeling so towny about buldermar at the moment.

What changed?

↑ fferyllt wrote:VOTE: buldermar

You're going to have to show me how this sudden change in opinion could possible come from town.

VOTE: ff

What happened? Reread happened. Even as it was unfolding in real time, I was uncomfortable with your extreme white-knighting.. Rereading, I kept asking myself how you'd come into the thread so certain that I'm town. And then I realized that your argument wasn't that I was town. As soon as orcinus gathered his case up into one post, you immediately backed down about my townishness. But you handn't ever argued that you thought I was town, just that I'm a strong town player (was it "strongest town player"?) on my home forum as though that should be enough.

Two mislynches are all we get. And I think you're setting up the opportunity to accomplish that: big me up as a bloodhound, let me help push a mislynch today, and then tomorrow lynch me for not finding scum on day 1. Then it's likely lylo depending on how the nights go.

I have a better idea. Lynch me today and then town can decide tomorrow if I might be right about you.

I've never been "so certain" that you're town. In fact, I've at no point in this game thought you're more-than-average likely of being town. I've defended you because you were being attacked for reasons that I found silly, and I've advocated at least postponing lynching you because you're a valueable asset as town.

I didn't "back down" about your townishness, I looked into the points orc raised and some of them were new and not fallacious. I hadn't ever argued that I thought you were town because You in my opinion the strongest town player by far in this game and you in fact the strongest town player I know of. You succesfully nail four scum players on day 1 based on very few posts before you were night killed on night 1. I must say that, at the very least, the idea of using objective facts that I've pointed out as an incentive to consider me scum is quite creative.

I've been speculating for the past hour about one thing that was bothering me about your line as scum. I couldn't figure out exactly why you chose now to supposedly having reread the thread and suddently change your read on me for apparently no reason. I just now found out.

↑ pitoli wrote:Personally I’m liking Buldermar for scum, only because he keeps going on about how valuable Ffery’s going to be. It feels like he’s defending her experience/ability rather than her posts right now.

I bet you saw this and thought that now would be a good time to push my lynch. Then you conveniently made first one post 235 and 236 to set things up and then later - still without me posting anything in the meantime - fired the bullet that is post 254 (which logically should have been fired right away at post 235, but you thought that would look too suspicious).

We can lynch ff now. I'm sorry that I've perhaps been too reluctant to go for it previously. Also lol@ you trying to gambit for a second time.

Also: reread<-- the most overused excuse as scum to suddently conveniently change ones read to fit how the game evolves.

On a sidenote: ff-Nero team currently looks to be the most likely ff-scum team permutation.

↑ fferyllt wrote:VOTE: buldermar

↑ buldermar wrote:

↑ fferyllt wrote:VOTE: buldermar

You're going to have to show me how this sudden change in opinion could possible come from town.

VOTE: ff

I'm so

What?

Whatever. FF is a good lynch.

I'm at a spa everyone waiting for the summarized case can suck it for another 7 hours

↑ buldermar wrote:I've never been "so certain" that you're town. In fact, I've at no point in this game thought you're more-than-average likely of being town. I've defended you because you were being attacked for reasons that I found silly, and I've advocated at least postponing lynching you because you're a valueable asset as town.

I didn't "back down" about your townishness, I looked into the points orc raised and some of them were new and not fallacious. I hadn't ever argued that I thought you were town because

I never had a town read on you in the first place.

You

are

in my opinion the strongest town player by far in this game and you

are

in fact the strongest town player I know of. You

did

succesfully nail four scum players on day 1 based on very few posts before you were night killed on night 1. I must say that, at the very least, the idea of using objective facts that I've pointed out as an incentive to consider me scum is quite creative.

I've been speculating for the past hour about one thing that was bothering me about your line as scum. I couldn't figure out exactly why you chose now to supposedly having reread the thread and suddently change your read on me for apparently no reason. I just now found out.

↑ pitoli wrote:Personally I’m liking Buldermar for scum, only because he keeps going on about how valuable Ffery’s going to be. It feels like he’s defending her experience/ability rather than her posts right now.

I bet you saw this and thought that now would be a good time to push my lynch. Then you conveniently made first one post 235 and 236 to set things up and then later - still without me posting anything in the meantime - fired the bullet that is post 254 (which logically should have been fired right away at post 235, but you thought that would look too suspicious).

We can lynch ff now. I'm sorry that I've perhaps been too reluctant to go for it previously. Also lol@ you trying to

raise-white-flag

gambit for a second time.

I had originally intended to sleep on it. But, sleeping on it wasn't going to change my mind. Also, thought that the time zone difference would give you time to fulminate over it a bit, and maybe even get my wagon to L-1 before dawn my time.

Multi-week game days are unnatural.

Are you insinuating that you expected to get voted by me?

It's hardly an insinuation.

This lack of paranoia is also not FF-esque

You are an expert on all things FF-esque.

↑ fferyllt wrote:You are an expert on all things FF-esque.

Self vote it'll save some time

Find another vote first and I'm quite likely to.

↑ fferyllt wrote:Find another vote first and I'm quite likely to.

Guys guys who wants town cred

*raises arm*

Did Nero post something that looks protown? Now could get my paranoia into high gear. Well, to the extent that buldermar hadn't already kickstarted it.

Interesting how quiet the thread has gotten.

buldermar, me why you were willing to pass on my lynch today on spec earlier while having a scum read on me per post 157.