Micro 831: Great Idea Mafia (Game Over)

[Micc]

I’m a psychiatrist and I targeted gamma emerald. Maruchan next.

[Micc]

Speaking of which, we haven't discussed this (possibly because people are taking strategy as something everyone knows) but

should

we actually lynch today? If we knew we were at 2 scum vs 4 townies it'd be obvious not to lynch, right? Or are we scared of the possibility of two kills?

Not lynch would be a high risk plan with very little payoff. I’m strongly against it unless a clear breaking strategy were to emerge from the mass claim.

[KittenLicks]

I’m a psychiatrist and I targeted gamma emerald. Maruchan next.

Why did you choose Gamma?

And good lord, if there's an SK out there, they must be sweating bullets right now.

[Micc]

He seemed as likely to be a serial killer as anyone one else with the added benefit of probably not being nightkilled. and then he got nightkilled...I feel your frustration.

[Rob14]

Vote Count #2.1:

Not Voting:

Maruchan, Micc, Bicephalous Bob, Simeon, KittenLicks, davesaz

With 6 players alive, it takes 4 to lynch.

V/LA:

None.

Deadline:

(expired on 2018-11-15 10:25:00)

[Simeon]

Perfect segue into what are your reads?

most towny to least towny would look like:

davesaz, Kitten
Micc, Bob
Maruchan

[Simeon]

Speaking of which, we haven't discussed this (possibly because people are taking strategy as something everyone knows) but

should

we actually lynch today? If we knew we were at 2 scum vs 4 townies it'd be obvious not to lynch, right? Or are we scared of the possibility of two kills?

Not lynch would be a high risk plan with very little payoff. I’m strongly against it unless a clear breaking strategy were to emerge from the mass claim.

Isn't Lylo better than Mylo?

[Maruchan]

I can’t help wonder how he thinks he’s going to find scum.

I've always been rather bad at this

[Maruchan]

Maruchan next.

seer, Micc isn't werewolf

[Maruchan]

can someone compile a list of the current claims? I'm unsure who all claimed

[KittenLicks]

can someone compile a list of the current claims? I'm unsure who all claimed

These are my claim notes, I don't think I'm missing anyone.

Maruchan -

Seer

Micc -

Psychiatrist

Simeon -

fruit vendor

davesaz -
Bicephalous Bob -

And I claimed

FBI Agent

.

Speaking of which, what was your plan, going into last night? Why Micc?

[Maruchan]

because day 1 was a bucket full of null, and I needed a name, and the only person I felt had done anything of note was Micc pushing a policy on a role, so i investigated him

[ceejayvinoya]

because day 1 was a bucket full of null, and I needed a name, and the only person I felt had done anything of note was Micc pushing a policy on a role, so i investigated him

wtf. Shouldn't you have checked the ones not on the Tazaro wagon? since Tazaro flipped wolf?

[Simeon]

because day 1 was a bucket full of null, and I needed a name, and the only person I felt had done anything of note was Micc pushing a policy on a role, so i investigated him

wtf. Shouldn't you have checked the ones not on the Tazaro wagon? since Tazaro flipped wolf?

Arghh I fucked up. This is mine

[Bicephalous Bob]

maru, do you want me or dave to claim next?

[Micc]

because day 1 was a bucket full of null, and I needed a name, and the only person I felt had done anything of note was Micc pushing a policy on a role, so i investigated him

No part of me pushing shortaru was policy on his role. Stop acting like it was. I went from RVS voting him to making an admittedly shitty page 1 push that helped bring us out of RVS to correctly town reading him.

[Micc]

can someone compile a list of the current claims? I'm unsure who all claimed

And how hard is it to actually read and follow the game? Maybe the reason you’re rather bad at finding scum is that you aren’t even trying?

[Micc]

Isn't Lylo better than Mylo?

Not realy? If the game is mod confirmed to have a single scum team a case can be made for lylo having better odds than mylo. My expierence is that the player who everyone agrees is Town dies and nothing really changes.

Now if you consider that this game could have multiple scum teams the no lynch looks real risky. Consider that a two person scum team wins tonight with two deaths that aren’t them. Wouldn’t you feel silly not taking your shot to lynch them today?

[Maruchan]

because day 1 was a bucket full of null, and I needed a name, and the only person I felt had done anything of note was Micc pushing a policy on a role, so i investigated him

wtf. Shouldn't you have checked the ones not on the Tazaro wagon? since Tazaro flipped wolf?

Multi ball. Wagon analysis is useless this game buddy

[Maruchan]

maru, do you want me or dave to claim next?

Let's go you

[Maruchan]

can someone compile a list of the current claims? I'm unsure who all claimed

And how hard is it to actually read and follow the game? Maybe the reason you’re rather bad at finding scum is that you aren’t even trying?

At 3 in the morning when you can barely see out your eyes it's quite difficult actually. I would have made a list today if someone else hadn't yet, but hey someone else had one ready and waiting

[Simeon]

Isn't Lylo better than Mylo?

Not realy? If the game is mod confirmed to have a single scum team a case can be made for lylo having better odds than mylo. My expierence is that the player who everyone agrees is Town dies and nothing really changes.

Now if you consider that this game could have multiple scum teams the no lynch looks real risky. Consider that a two person scum team wins tonight with two deaths that aren’t them. Wouldn’t you feel silly not taking your shot to lynch them today?

But only one person died last night

[Simeon]

because day 1 was a bucket full of null, and I needed a name, and the only person I felt had done anything of note was Micc pushing a policy on a role, so i investigated him

wtf. Shouldn't you have checked the ones not on the Tazaro wagon? since Tazaro flipped wolf?

Multi ball. Wagon analysis is useless this game buddy

Really? Multi ball doesn't mean you always wagon your partner, right?

[Maruchan]

because day 1 was a bucket full of null, and I needed a name, and the only person I felt had done anything of note was Micc pushing a policy on a role, so i investigated him

wtf. Shouldn't you have checked the ones not on the Tazaro wagon? since Tazaro flipped wolf?

Multi ball. Wagon analysis is useless this game buddy

Really? Multi ball doesn't mean you always wagon your partner, right?

multi ball means there might not BE any partners. We could have 3 1 man scum teams.

mafia/werewolf/replecant/alien/serial killer/cult.

How would knowing who lynched the werewolf matter if there is only one werewolf and there is also an alien and a mafia? by VCA reasoning the alien and the mafia could appear perfectly towny, and lynch the werewolf with the town, thinking he was town.

VCA is useless in great/er/est/grand idea

[Maruchan]

Isn't Lylo better than Mylo?

Not realy? If the game is mod confirmed to have a single scum team a case can be made for lylo having better odds than mylo. My expierence is that the player who everyone agrees is Town dies and nothing really changes.

Now if you consider that this game could have multiple scum teams the no lynch looks real risky. Consider that a two person scum team wins tonight with two deaths that aren’t them. Wouldn’t you feel silly not taking your shot to lynch them today?

But only one person died last night

mafia compulsive doctor can nulify his own kill, at first glance. I didn't dig into any of the other roles I didn't recognize