Mafiascum.net

In post 231, CheekyTeeky wrote:

In post 230, brassherald wrote:praising his solving when earlier you said no one had a case on you, but I doubt you are going to go into that.

I wasn't praising his solving lol. I was saying that's more likely to come from town - where all his reads fall into place once he thinks he's caught a scum slip.

Noone has a rational case on me. The meta thing was me meta skimming a few people and obviously not paying attention to how many games NL had listed. I looked at one game of hers and assumed that it was more. Oh well.

Anyway the point of this was to get you guys sorting each other - don't worry about sorting me, you can assume I'm scum. If I'm scum you'd want me to spew all my stances on others so there's no reason to shut me down early.

Brass do you agree/disagree with any of my other townreads and reasoning?

I disagree with Shoshin being town, I feel she has been scummy the entire game. And, in fact, after this you voted her, so seems you don't even agree with you.

I don't really believe your reasoning for any of them, and feel there's lots of 180s from you that seem not like I remember you, that being said, I really don't have too much to add since my last set of reads.

Oka is moving down, if anything, since my last time posting, and, Maestro is both an enigma and a mystery right now because he's not posting, and that may be scum indicative, but now I have a four man scum team guess, and I need to find the odd man out and probably, when I have the time (tomorrow night) reevaluate the people in my town leans to make sure I'm operating based on their posts and not just my memory of their posts.

I have to ISO everyone again and I will when I am able.

Brass, what are your concerns about me?

In post 252, Shoshin wrote:Brass, what are your concerns about me?

Town reads are too numerous, I don't remember loving the analysis.

But, I do promise when I do my read tomorrow night of everyone's ISO, I will be open to change, because I have been wrong in the past.

Like one time.

If one time actually means so many more times than one.

In post 253, brassherald wrote:Town reads are too numerous, I don't remember loving the analysis.

I'd like to refer you to my town meta, then. I especially urge you to take a look at American Presidents since you modded the game, but also take a look at any other recent town games (TAZ, Fifth Fortnight, Mini Normal 2042, or even A Story Revisited).

In terms of analysis, I tend to say less than I'm actually thinking so if there's anything you don't understand, please ask. I'd also appreciate if you could reread as objectively as possible so that you don't let confirmation bias cloud your judgment.

In post 223, theslimer3 wrote:Oi, I'm alive. I'll catch up later tonight ~

Oi, you didn't keep this promise

let's not forget that they are still lurking

If he maintains this level of activity as the game progresses, Lynch’em. It’s that simple. I don’t think he should be a candidate right now.

just keeping him in people's minds. I know brass, at least, has issues remembering people are still in the game.

My preferred lynches, from best lynch to least best lynch is cheeky, maestro, oka, slimer so you're not getting an argument from me

[unv][/unv]

Consider me voting Shoshin because I see no commitment to... anytihng basically
HURT: Shoshin

I'm not realy clear on Cheeky's wagon but he's only a null for me for and I'm honestly really fknig pissed somebody thinks I'm WKing them since that's something I don't trhink I do that as either alignment so I'm almost tempted to say "fuckit, have your lynch if you want"

REALLY UNVOTE TAG

UNVOTE:

In post 258, Maestro wrote:[unv][/unv]

Consider me voting Shoshin because I see no commitment to... anytihng basically
HURT: Shoshin

I'm not realy clear on Cheeky's wagon but he's only a null for me for

reasons

and I'm honestly really fknig pissed somebody thinks I'm WKing them since that's something I don't trhink I do that as either alignment so I'm almost tempted to say "fuckit, have your lynch if you want"

talk about keeping your options open

"I might lynch either of them but I won't vote either of them right now and I'm giving no reasons for a null read on one of the most dynamic players in the thread."

okiee

My gut is telling me to just lynch Oka.

VOTE: OkaPoka
No harm in trying.

.....

@NL
I really think we should flip cheeky. I think she's a wolf here, and I can't really envision what the path looks like to me town reading her after watching cheeky calling me 100% scum, then fabricating that meta claim, then such a huge turn around but still being cagey about giving a readlist (as town, why?)

I really don't want cheeky to make it to lylo, and there are no night actions

And aubrey's right, there is a great deal to be gleaned from her flipping in either direction

so I'd rather flip cheeky earlier so we can start digging into that info faster.

I'm with you on oka looking scummy, though. Can we look deeper there on d2?

Only because I like you.
VOTE: CheekyTeeky

Wow that was more effective than expected. <3

I wonder...

Aubrey, what do you say we flip cheeky today instead of shoshin.

I think she's town, and I'm hard pressed to see why she is the best lynch today. It seems to me that most of what people are scum reading shoshin for is just her way of kick starting the game?

In post 258, Maestro wrote:Consider me voting Shoshin because I see no commitment to... anytihng basically

What are you talking about? I've provided clearer reads than anyone else in the game. I've said unequivocally that Brass/NL are town, that U2 shouldn't be lynched unless it's 4 players with Brass/NL, and that we should be lynching within the group of Cheeky/Oka/Aubrey. How is this a lack of commitment relative to you or anyone else in the game?

I’m expecting Bass to rejoin.

VOTE: CT

@brass you indicated a willingness to vote cheeky earlier. What do you say we start getting ready to close the deal?

btw @all I do want to give slimer, maestro more time to speak before ending the day

P.edit im pretty sure that's l-1?

UNVOTE:

NL, U2, I'm doubting Maestro as town. Thoughts? I don't understand how town ever makes 258.

Think that's L-1... Not quite ready to end the day yet, still want to do my review tomorrow.

We have time for that.

Was.

What are your reads, Aubrey?

I’m not wasting time with that. You know what I plan to do if cheeky flips.