Mafiascum.net

What would having him 'on the hook' achieve?
Again, if you think he's scum, wait until he slips up properly.
Don't complain about his bad etiquette; ask him (or others) pointed and game-advancing questions, and don't just blindly insist he's scum.

Cyan, Adorable, cyrus, FL, connor, can you give us your perspective on this Robb vs. Temporal battle?

In post 251, Spangled wrote:Cyan, Adorable, cyrus, FL, connor, can you give us your perspective on this Robb vs. Temporal battle?

i agree with you sounds like tvt but i disagree with the sifting votes 3 times in a day .

In post 250, Spangled wrote:What would having him 'on the hook' achieve?
Again, if you think he's scum, wait until he slips up properly.
Don't complain about his bad etiquette; ask him (or others) pointed and game-advancing questions, and don't just blindly insist he's scum.

That’s the thing. He’s slipped up properly imo.

I guess I’m all alone in that regard. Not much else I can do

I'm not sure what Robb wants me to admit but I will at least say the post I thought was trying to get me lynched is probably NAI (and seems like an observation)

Either way it's best for the town for me to disengage from this pointless argument.

How about retract that I made that post trying to get you lynched. Cause that never happened.

Um I implied 160 probably isn't you trying to get me lynched regardless of alignment despite what I said earlier

Robb vs Temporal looked like it was town vs town.

Regardless, it's best for your vote to be on who you think is the scummiest right now, shifting might be waffling but being afraid to change votes is scummy as heck

My vote is on the scummiest. Literally nobody scummier than you.

But bear in mind this is D1. Keep in mind it's better to vote a meh read if you.have no scumreads than to be not voting at all. The D1 lynch provides valuable info.

In post 259, Robbnva wrote:My vote is on the scummiest. Literally nobody scummier than you.

I think the reason that there's no one scummier than Temporal at the moment is because everyone who's really putting effort in (cyrus, Adorable, Robb, Temporal, Cyan) is being fairly townie, with only a few scummy comments. This isn't really a townbloc yet; there are some people who I'm iffy on and/or waiting to see if they slip up, but we need all of the lurkers to get posting.

Because if we go for the scummiest talking people, we might be missing the not-talking, potentially scummy people. Everyone understand?

We still have 8 or so days left, right, y'all? Keep that in mind.


Pedit:
That is true. You're agreeing with Robb there, right?

Yeah connorcompton still only has one post, and phone should try more. I'm not willing to put pressure votes when there is a mild SR but if you have no reads consider a pressure vote.

Robb's vote I'm fairly sure is not a bad vote.

And FL is totally ignoring this game; he's playing his others but not this.
I wonder if he's lurking, or if he's just forgotten it exists.

Oh, wait, we don't have FL, we have RedFlavor.
I just read the Flavor bit it seems
Everything I've said to or about 'FL', please apply it to Red.

Ah, no, RF is an alt of FL. So.

In post 201, Adorable wrote:Everyone is scum reading Robb except for two players. I was hoping to hear from Connor but he never came back and this slot will probably get mod killed or subbed out.

Cyan looks like he is just following other players scum reading Robb which looks sus and normally scum follow other players.


VOTE: Cyan Talon

Fixed

Not entirely true; if you look at the chain of two posts I made earlier, you cn see that I noted that even though his tunnel-like behavior is suspicious, he has a fair point against TemporalLich.

In post 266, Cyan Talon wrote:

In post 201, Adorable wrote:Everyone is scum reading Robb except for two players. I was hoping to hear from Connor but he never came back and this slot will probably get mod killed or subbed out.

Cyan looks like he is just following other players scum reading Robb which looks sus and normally scum follow other players.


VOTE: Cyan Talon

Fixed

Not entirely true; if you look at the chain of two posts I made earlier, you cn see that I noted that even though his tunnel-like behavior is suspicious, he has a fair point against TemporalLich.

fair enough

In post 265, Spangled wrote:Ah, no, RF is an alt of FL. So.

If serious, lynch him even more.

In post 245, TemporalLich wrote:gonna shift my vote because I'm thinking TL/Robb is TvT and because of 243 maybe.

VOTE: Cyan Talon

Reading his ISO, 177's read on cyrus doesn't feel genuine and the rest feels lukewarm. Mulling between this and RedFlavor (entire ISO is lukewarm at best) tbh.

Not sure what you mean by 'lukewarm' so I'm making assumptions here:

If you think my behavior has been passive so far, I can't really argue with that. I'm not all that great at forming deductions or making reads when compared to other players with similar levels of experience. So far, it's only D1, and I generally do most of my thinking on later phases where I have more information to work with. That, plus ongoing medical issues, is hindering my play ability as of now.

I'm aware this post probably reeks of AtE, but this is the best explanation I can offer.

In post 269, Cyan Talon wrote:Not sure what you mean by 'lukewarm' so I'm making assumptions here:

If you think my behavior has been passive so far, I can't really argue with that. I'm not all that great at forming deductions or making reads when compared to other players with similar levels of experience. So far, it's only D1, and I generally do most of my thinking on later phases where I have more information to work with. That, plus ongoing medical issues, is hindering my play ability as of now.

I'm aware this post probably reeks of AtE, but this is the best explanation I can offer.

yeah I meant meh and not very spicy.

That being said I will switch my vote again again because you haven't warmed up yet.

VOTE: RedFlavor

In post 251, Spangled wrote:Cyan, Adorable, cyrus, FL, connor, can you give us your perspective on this Robb vs. Temporal battle?

Really not sure what to think here. As others have pointed out, Robbnva seems too aggressive to be scum at this point, and I can respect TemporalLich for admitting to the fact and not directly fighting back (which is frankly only mildly townie). However, the way Rob's pushing the 'slip' still irks me.

Maybe I'd call this a nullread, but I'm leaning on a TvT interaction here.

watching setting down trying to get a better read on things

In post 268, Robbnva wrote:

In post 265, Spangled wrote:Ah, no, RF is an alt of FL. So.

If serious, lynch him even more.

Is Flavor notorious for not playing if he's scum or something?

i have no idea they mormaly talk more i think ask cyan what he thinks i honestly think red doesnt comment much untill there like 3 or four days to go