Posted: Sun Jun 19, 2022 5:39 am
Event
Deadline
(expired on 2022-06-21 21:00:00)
Don't put words into my mouth. That is all for now.In post 246, Loki Dokie wrote:That’s a 180 degree switch up? Especially on Penguin.
Waffling tends to occur in different posts with usually a logical timegap betweeh those changed reads. Hedging can either occur in the same post or subsequent posts that progressionwise don’t make much sense.In post 243, Firebringer wrote:makes sense but ur going to have to point out why and how ur certain on someone isn't a waffler vs hedger
So for example, waffling: I have a strong town or sr on a player and then either new information or a new assessment makes me switch that read. The read changes but the logical progression behind it makes sense.
Hedging is more like you look like you’re making an actual read but failing to commit to it. It’s a way to make it easy to at some point out of nowhere flip your read on a player, since you’ve already laid the groundwork for having either kind of read on them. If you make a read where you outline points for where they can be either alignment, you don’t need to account for your read change.
It’s not black and white but it’s far easier to be outed as scum for illogical progression or fake waffling thznhedging because you’ve already laid the groundwork to be uncommitted to that read. So as long as there’s clear logical progression on a read, waffling is usually town indicative where as hedging makes it far easier for scum to hide.
????In post 251, NotAHecticAlt wrote:Don't put words into my mouth. That is all for now.In post 246, Loki Dokie wrote:That’s a 180 degree switch up? Especially on Penguin.
Waffling tends to occur in different posts with usually a logical timegap betweeh those changed reads. Hedging can either occur in the same post or subsequent posts that progressionwise don’t make much sense.In post 243, Firebringer wrote:makes sense but ur going to have to point out why and how ur certain on someone isn't a waffler vs hedger
So for example, waffling: I have a strong town or sr on a player and then either new information or a new assessment makes me switch that read. The read changes but the logical progression behind it makes sense.
Hedging is more like you look like you’re making an actual read but failing to commit to it. It’s a way to make it easy to at some point out of nowhere flip your read on a player, since you’ve already laid the groundwork for having either kind of read on them. If you make a read where you outline points for where they can be either alignment, you don’t need to account for your read change.
It’s not black and white but it’s far easier to be outed as scum for illogical progression or fake waffling thznhedging because you’ve already laid the groundwork to be uncommitted to that read. So as long as there’s clear logical progression on a read, waffling is usually town indicative where as hedging makes it far easier for scum to hide.
In post 253, NotAHecticAlt wrote:Where did I say I scumread penguin?
also
HEAL: ejj
HEAL: andante
My current top townreads are ejj, andante, and CSF - ranked from strongest to weakest.
I can’t wait for someone to suddenly accuse me of not hard tr Andante but between you and eijj misconstruing my posting, anything is possible.
In post 22, Radical Rat wrote:I think it's best we take this one leader at a time for now. Gives us time for more AI content to be generated from the first election that can be used to inform the second.In post 18, Gamma Emerald wrote:Are there events for every day phase?
HEAL: Roden
HEAL: Cat Scratch Fever
First one is just cuz, second one is because I feel like the question about what Leader does is a genuine town ask
Anyway, looks like this is the chance to put some demons to rest more directly.
Okay thanks.In post 256, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:you are allowed to heal 0 1 or 2 players in your most recent heal post
those heals will count for leader selection
if a player reaches 6 heals, that player will be locked in as a "leader"
if you do not elect 2 leaders this way, then whoever has the most heals at the end of the deadline will become "leaders" plurality ties broken by seniority
oh roflIn post 254, Loki Dokie wrote:In post 253, NotAHecticAlt wrote:Where did I say I scumread penguin?
also
HEAL: ejj
HEAL: andante
My current top townreads are ejj, andante, and CSF - ranked from strongest to weakest.I can’t wait for someone to suddenly accuse me of not hard tr Andante but between you and eijj misconstruing my posting, anything is possible.
Whoa, that is not what happened. I do townread Firebringer, I just don't think he'd make a good leader because of his playstyle, not because he might be scum.In post 236, NotAHecticAlt wrote:The point was they made a scumread by dressing it up as a maybe townread - I dont think this kind of "testing the waters" is towny and frankly, looks outing to me.In post 218, ejjinami wrote:forgive me for being blunt, accusing people for doubtful reasons at best won’t accomplish much at this pointIn post 191, NotAHecticAlt wrote:RR trying to hedge a read without appearing to do so
very creative strategy, I'll have to try it sometime
You wrote that read without thinking much, possibly a response to a scum-read on you.
Possibly as a way to maintain the leader-persona
please, quit it.
it just makes you appear unpredictable. It would be good to have some way to determine whether you seriously think of scum-reading someone or it’s just a reaction-testblehIn post 192, Firebringer wrote:dont we all hedge. i mean ur hedging on me.
I am hedging on a secret coin flip on a few players.
Hedging keeps the game turning
forced
Give me the result tho
I have the highest post count and i seem to be invisible to you - wanna talk about your read on meIn post 260, Aisa wrote:HEAL: ejjinami
Also quite liking ejji for leader at the moment. The volume and flow of their posting seems natural. For example, their reaction to some of my posts feels not overthought; I also like 220. I did a quick search and didn't find any past games as scum. Assuming they're not an alt this also raises my confidence in them being town slightly? I think that if they are fake town-spewing they are doing pretty competent town-spew, to the extent I'd expect it to be slightly out of reach for a newer scum player?
Admittedly am slightly susceptible to tring high volume posters and people who agree with me, so here's to hoping that's not the case x
If my count is correct, ejji has four heals at the moment. Would love to hear from anyone who has reservations about ejji.
Anyone kicking around rn and want a quick chat?
Sounds like yer attention span is better than mineIn post 201, Cat Scratch Fever wrote:What, the game only had 5 pages at this pointIn post 111, Aisa wrote: "Since I've started writing this I see this has been discussed and people mostly seem to agree with me" was shorthand for "I skimmed some of the discussion. On a more careful reread people have already made these points, and it's also been discussed more since I started writing this".
I realise this sort of posting is anti-town and it would make life better if my posting were accurate the first time around. What can I say, eh, digesting posts fully is hard and the thread is busy right now.
[...]
I found this a bit convoluted and it took me a couple rereads to understand, which makes me lean slightly town on CSFIn post 205, Cat Scratch Fever wrote:YeahIn post 204, Fidget wrote:Because I'm critiquing both Loki and Not Hectic, presumably, and the Loki read is about NotHectic.
I think bad reasoning knows no alignment. Even if I'm having questions towards someone's motives, I'm not going to turn a blind eye to arguments being presented against them.
Or, perhaps, I'm mistaken about what you're getting at
Or more specifically
NotHectic has a read that you don't understand
Loki also thinks NotHectic's reads are hard to understand
I haven't really talked about many players in this game, I guess you could say most of the playerlist is invisible to me. But would love to talk about my read on you. No clue how to read you so far. I feel like some of your comments are a bit speculative. This, for example:In post 261, NotAHecticAlt wrote:I have the highest post count and i seem to be invisible to you - wanna talk about your read on meIn post 260, Aisa wrote:[...]
for your theory to make sense we require Loki = scum, Andante = town, and I felt like that was a slightly strong assumption.In post 124, NotAHecticAlt wrote:Loki's interest in being on Andante's good side, knowing how Andante tends to play, comes off as a scum pocket in the sense that they're trying to look good by giving andante leader ? this is like strictly a preflip off seeing andante as town and noticing how loki is treating Andante, as matter of fact town who has good reads and not separate from that, if that makes sense.
ejj feels LAMISTy in like a subtle way too
so rn like preliminary scumpool is [FB/ejj/Loki] for independent reasons.
gamma/CSF had weird entrances too
I agree with you! It does feel like Radical Rat is a bit fence-sitty in the post your are referring to. Ultimately they are stating a lot of hedge-y views but not doing a ton to advance the game. The caveat is that it could just be playstyle, and I haven't really had time to look into what their playstyle is.In post 191, NotAHecticAlt wrote:RR trying to hedge a read without appearing to do so
very creative strategy, I'll have to try it sometime
Though if the "scumread dressed up as a maybe townread" you're referring to is Loki's read on you, I think you're misinterpreting what they're saying.In post 236, NotAHecticAlt wrote:The point was they made a scumread by dressing it up as a maybe townread - I dont think this kind of "testing the waters" is towny and frankly, looks outing to me.In post 218, ejjinami wrote:forgive me for being blunt, accusing people for doubtful reasons at best won’t accomplish much at this pointIn post 191, NotAHecticAlt wrote:RR trying to hedge a read without appearing to do so
very creative strategy, I'll have to try it sometime
You wrote that read without thinking much, possibly a response to a scum-read on you.
Possibly as a way to maintain the leader-persona
please, quit it.
it just makes you appear unpredictable. It would be good to have some way to determine whether you seriously think of scum-reading someone or it’s just a reaction-test
[...]
In post 230, Loki Dokie wrote:I don’t see why you view my asking Andante if she really doesn’t want to be leader, I would unneal her, “performative”?
Because I did that right after Roden made his post saying pretty much that or did you somehow miss that?
Like how do you have this take and completely ignore that?
Mmm
Probably your page 1-2 felt weird to me. But it got betterIn post 209, NotAHecticAlt wrote:which posts are lamisty
I'm trying to understand this post but I can'tIn post 236, NotAHecticAlt wrote: The point was they made a scumread by dressing it up as a maybe townread - I dont think this kind of "testing the waters" is towny and frankly, looks outing to me.
oooooohIn post 238, Andante wrote:oh yeah.. and that'd be why town would benefit, cause 2 town in a hood... can be pretty goodIn post 185, Gamma Emerald wrote:actually based on the event name "encrypted communications" they probably get a hood
pearing time hell yeah
Can you talk to me about rat?In post 238, Andante wrote: Meh that's good enough for now, I'm like getting sick IRL, it's great, but yeah I had a partner read I don't remember who, it was fidget and someone... ahhh should've just written it down. whelp yeah.
HEAL: Radical Rat
HEAL: ejjinami
I think those 2 are good to heal though
Why Gamma? Good impression of FB. My main impression thus far was him talking about what he would do as scum in this game.In post 211, Roden wrote:Aisa Eiji Loki Gamma all feel town so far
FB seems like he's kinda just posturing
I echo this. That is not a productive line of questioning.In post 214, ejjinami wrote:I’m really not impressed by the threat in the last lines. It feels like there’s enmity towards Hectic, yet the main message sent was “stop scum-reading me or I’ll scum-read you”In post 140, Loki Dokie wrote:Oh and what’s weird about Gamma’s and CFS’ entrances?In post 134, NotAHecticAlt wrote:we can use hurt tags to vote on that
HURT: ejj
HURT: loki
HURT: Firebringer
And still trying to decide if you’re town and your ability to read me hasn’t improved since Anything uPick or you’re scum tunneling me similarly to what you did in Witch Hunt.
intentional or not, it feels manipulative
What do you mean that you buy they are not "trying" to be townread?In post 216, ejjinami wrote:I… actually kinda buy thisIn post 162, NotAHecticAlt wrote:im not even trying to be townread ..? im trying to be leader, yes, but im overall trying to hardsolve the game d1 because im like always n1d as town nowadaysLmao why would you not want to get night-killedIn post 163, NotAHecticAlt wrote:ok ill spill why i want to be leader so bad - because i believe that leader gets nightkill immunity likely and id like that for myself.
Frankly, if I were to give it to someone, I’d choose someone whom I either trust 100% to protect them or whose decisions I trust… so that changes literally nothing :/
that post feels townie tho
btw, I doubt that. This is only a 13p game. Having 2 people with some sort of decisive power AND night-kill immunity for both of them seems like overkill
Could break the game in many scenarios
I think I know what you're referring to re: ejj feeling genuine and NotHectic not feeling as genuine. But I would say they have quite different posting styles. I think ejj's posting style may be more "introspective" or "stream of consciousness-like", which to some, maybe myself included, may inherently appear more towny.In post 265, Radical Rat wrote:Ejj feels like the Town version of The Alt (not) Formerly Known As Hectic.
Like, they're similarly hyperposting, both coming off as somewhat arrogant, and tinged with LAMIST.... But for reasons I can't quite articulate, Ejj's posting seems genuine, while citceH's doesn't.
Unexpected :/
I seriously don't understand this conversationIn post 258, NotAHecticAlt wrote:oh roflIn post 254, Loki Dokie wrote:I can’t wait for someone to suddenly accuse me of not hard tr Andante but between you and eijj misconstruing my posting, anything is possible.
i used hurt tags to remove my leader vote on penguin. so i was right that you put words in my mouth.
I'm not a newer playerIn post 260, Aisa wrote:to the extent I'd expect it to be slightly out of reach for a newer scum player?
Okay, come now.In post 166, NotAHecticAlt wrote:like im doing a pretty shit job of getting townread by putting myself out there in a way that gives me negative attention and all lmao
Hm.In post 220, ejjinami wrote:Fidget may consider FM an obligation. Till now they seemed to have been responding to posts mechanically- more out of a sense of duty (because they joined the game and consider it necessary to be serious), not because they consider anything they talked about interesting.
Frankly, that just instinctively makes me wary. It’s near impossible to determine whether the feeling of “hAvInG tO be productive” comes from personality or being scum (they question players because they hAvE tO act townie and actually don’t give a crap about anything they say).
Anyway, the feeling that they’re not personally attached to what they’re talking about makes me wary. I’m struggling to see fidget’s personality through their posts besides that.
that's what I'm getting from my observation. Hectic seems to be responding instinctively to most posts. Although the energy feels intentional, I feel no agenda behind it- they're just doing it on a whim- which matches what Hectic said about "trying to act like a leader, which is different from trying to act townie"In post 270, Fidget wrote:What do you mean that you buy they are not "trying" to be townread?In post 216, ejjinami wrote:I… actually kinda buy thisIn post 162, NotAHecticAlt wrote:im not even trying to be townread ..? im trying to be leader, yes, but im overall trying to hardsolve the game d1 because im like always n1d as town nowadays