Mafiascum.net

In post 2498, Ravenpaw wrote:

In post 2484, Mutleyddmc wrote:

In post 2479, ferretlover wrote:Whatever you say, Raven

VOTE: Darthe

null

Was this meant to be a response to my question? If so, why is he null?

Cos I havent really taken much notice of him tbf

MonkeyMan576 (1)- Mac
ArcAngel9 (1)- PeregrineV
Desperado (2)- ArcAngel9, MonkeyMan576
penguin_alien (2)- mastin2, Pidgey
xMALCOLMx (1)- Syryana

Not voting (2)- Darthe, Rubicon



then tell all these clowns to vote one of the two leading wagons so we can get a lynch done.

All you clowns get on ferret please

Mut, why don't you do an iso of Darthe and try to get a better read of him then a null?
Also what do you think of him saying that his reads list is affected by what his predecessor said before?

In post 2502, Mutleyddmc wrote:All you clowns get on ferret please

No, don't listen to this guy^.
All you clowns vote for Darthe please.

Its quite scummy and I will support his lynch but I want ferret first please. I could probably make a good case against ferret tomorrow actually

Just for the sake of a lynch.

Mutley why does it have to be tomorrow that you make a case? You can make it now and have us evaluate and analyze it.

because I don't care for now

In post 2495, Nero Cain wrote:I don't get why Despo is voting Darthe if he just said he doesn't think scum told.

I said I didn't see the Amished tell, but that I agreed that what he did was not town motivated.

Please read everything I say before making some kind of judgement, this isn't the first time you've clearly misread me.

In post 2505, MonkeyMan576 wrote:

Unvote:
Vote: Darthe

Just for the sake of a lynch.

Hey Monkey remember when you said this:

In post 2337, MonkeyMan576 wrote:Also, anyone willing to join a wagon with Arcangel, Mutley, and Ravenpaw on it needs to rethink their strategy. Lynching someone just to lynch someone is horrible, especially with a scum driven wagon.

In post 2480, pidgey wrote:So you are saying that the way ferret responded to monkey is making you more sure about monkey being town and ferret being scum... in fucking MULTIBALL of all things... you'd at least think you would found both of them scummy since you WERE voting monkey...
Oh but wait, after you called monkey town on your other post when you voted that one other guy, you are now calling him an "actor scum".
Yeah this is scum cleaning his hands sorry.

I never called MonkeyMan576 town--other people have. I said that I thought he was less scummy than ferretlover. I specifically noted that we're in multiball and so one of them being scum doesn't preclude the other from being scum:

In post 2395, penguin_alien wrote:

In post 2389, ferretlover wrote:Wow how did nexus pull it through and get the subs :O

I see despo as town again and would love to see a monkey lynch. A monkey lynch wood give us a LOT of info.

I just got grounded from the computer so yeeeeaaaaahhhhh.

...what information do you expect to get from such a lynch? Sounds like you're more looking to hop on and conveniently not have a real reason the next day. Which makes me skeptical of the wagon, as I don't see MonkeyMan576 reacting quite like he has as scum in the past.

Multiball may change that, and I wouldn't rule out their being opposite scum factions.

mastin2 looks good (although my context for that is that he didn't come in and insist on one person as scum [cough, Mini 1413 bussing]), and in conjunction with him not thinking MonkeyMan576 is scum,

UNVOTE: MonkeyMan576
VOTE: ferretlover

I don't like his faux-confused reaction to the Skullduggery daykill, but I think I'd rather see ferretlover hang today.

And I'm not liking the ArcAngel9-ferretlover pile-up on Desperado.

ArcAngel9, my sense is that in games where you're town, you tend to appeal to other people who you think are town to try to get them to agree with you. Yet here you have no town reads at all (yourself doesn't count) and have a huge pile of players in neutral and null, whatever the difference is there for you? What gives?

Emphasis added.

Dammit.

Ferret's town. Seriously.

I still don't think Darthe's scum. I can him as maybe being scum, now, but I really, have a strong gut feeling he's town.

If I've really got no other choice, I guess I'd vote him to avoid no-lynch, but I really, REALLY have a bad feeling that he's going to flip town and that this lynch is a mistake.

Seriously--can't we get anyone else? Not ferret, either. Heck, I'd be more satisfied with a Desperado-Darthe setup than that, but even then, that's not ideal.

Seriously. There has to be a name that we can agree on outside of them. Can you give me a gameday (well, gamenight ) to read Darthe so that I can get a better opinion on him? I don't like that lynch right now. Can't we instead lynch, say, penguin_alien? Mac? pidgey? (Okay, maybe not pidgey. Benefit of the doubt is being given right now.) The Goat?

Seriously, there to be a better option than Darthe.

Goat seems like a good option.

He barely squeezed through earlier.

Why are you changing considering you said it has to be you or darthe?

I was open to new options.

I just want today.

So going to goat isnt really going to do that. If what yo ureally want is just a lynch and you dont care who, surely you stay on darthe or go onto yourself

Everybody just completely fucked the trains we had built info and cases on to solve this. But that is fine, at least I can finally confirm myself by catching...

In post 2495, Nero Cain wrote:I don't get why Despo is voting Darthe if he just said he doesn't think scum told.

Likewise Mac continues to push me. At least Nero and Malcolm put me where they treat me.

In post 2511, mastin2 wrote:Dammit.

Ferret's town. Seriously.

I still don't think Darthe's scum. I can

see

him as maybe being scum, now, but I really,

really

have a strong gut feeling he's town.

If I've really got no other choice, I guess I'd vote him to avoid no-lynch, but I really, REALLY have a bad feeling that he's going to flip town and that this lynch is a mistake.

Seriously--can't we get anyone else? Not ferret, either. Heck, I'd be more satisfied with a Desperado-Darthe setup than that, but even then, that's not ideal.

Seriously. There has to be a name that we can agree on outside of them. Can you give me a gameday (well, gamenight ) to read Darthe so that I can get a better opinion on him? I don't like that lynch right now. Can't we instead lynch, say, penguin_alien? Mac? pidgey? (Okay, maybe not pidgey. Benefit of the doubt is being given right now.) The Goat?

Seriously, there

has

to be a better option than Darthe.

If you decide to take the extra time to do this then please please note how quickly arc wagons have risen and fallen through this game.

darthe do u mean confirm yourself as scum? because im town...

if the time comes that we need to do this then i will vote for myself.

In post 2517, Darthe wrote:

In post 2495, Nero Cain wrote:I don't get why Despo is voting Darthe if he just said he doesn't think scum told.

Likewise Mac continues to push me. At least Nero and Malcolm put me where they treat me.

Not likewise. I said I didn't see you pull an Amished tell, while simultaneously agreeing with Nero's interpretation of what you did.

You're far from my main scumread. I tried my best to get an Arc wagon started but basically no one bit (or even commented on my case), and given the choice between Monkey, you, or myself, you were the lynch for me.

Ravenpaw is scum for trying to make someone accountable for not wanting a no lynch.

In post 2519, ferretlover wrote:darthe do u mean confirm yourself as scum? because im town...

if the time comes that we need to do this then i will vote for myself.

VOTE: Darthe

It's like you watched what Mutley did yesterday, and are following that to the letter.

*sigh*

You know that feeling? It's a cliched trope, even. Of being the new guy in town. The new guy who should be shown the ropes? The new guy who the townies all ignore? The new guy who is apparently ignorant to the state of the game? And yet, in truth, this new guy brings a perspective which proves absolutely vital to the town's survival? That his outside perspective actually makes him more competent than those who have been there the whole time?

...Yeah, that one. (Let's just call it Jack Carter syndrome, since we're dealing with a metaphor that involves a town. ) That's going through me right now. It's not a feeling I get very often. Heck, I think the last time I had it was Underground Mafia, replacing in as triple-confirmed-town and reversing what would have been a perfect scum victory into a neck-and-neck race. (Had the town followed my plan, we actually would have won! But since my mason partner failed to convey the final part of the plan after I died, and then they died, the town mislynched in 3p lylo despite my having correctly nailed the entire scumteam pretty much in my opening post. )

Seriously, guys. Stop lynching Darthe. Don't lynch ferret. Don't fall into the false dichotomy that we only have those two (or Desperado as a popular third choice) available. Contrary to popular belief, yes, we CAN get a darkhorse lynch to go through with the time we have, and--contrary to popular belief--it CAN be on scum. But we have to work together, and channel our votes carefully. We canNOT divide them. Not with trivial pursuits, not with the wagons we don't want (Darthe/ferret/Desperado), and not by dividing our attention.

Let's narrow it down. I've got strong scum candidates in penguin_alien, Mac, and The Goat. We CAN get a lynch on one of them, but we can't get a lynch on all three of them, so we need to focus our efforts. Seriously. Help me. Choose, right here, right now, between those three. Most to least. You can help lynch scum, but to do it, you need to WORK WITH ME, HERE. And keep an open mind!

(Btw, the other scumreads are pidgey and Ravenpaw for me currently, but I'll be investigating those later, when I have more time available. For now, we need to focus on getting the lynch.)

My preference from strongest to least is listed above, for the record--I would most prefer a penguin_alien lynch, I would also like a Mac lynch, and I'm willing to compromise on a TheGoat lynch.

Now, your turn.