Mafiascum.net

In post 2494, Comical wrote:Is it possible Luna and Penguin are scum together?

I would like you to explain iDany being town pretty please

In post 2497, northsidegal wrote:

In post 2479, OkaPoka wrote:nsg you should let comical gunsmith you

why? it'd be a waste

penguin, working on a response to you now

i can protect you tonight and no further and odds are with a setup like this we aren't going to be allowed to play follow the gunsmith for the entire game (aka im the only protective - and i am gated)

so if you want people to trust you for your limited window, then getting you smithed would be ideal

In post 2492, Something_Smart wrote:Guns & Roses II?

You got yourself lynched there.

I think thinking there's two town gunsmiths, no mafia doctors, and no mafia role interference roles is pretty asinine.

Did Boon ever explain why he targeted RCE?

Oh...you were serious about protective oka? Did I miss something?

In post 2500, Eddie Cane wrote:

In post 2494, Comical wrote:Is it possible Luna and Penguin are scum together?

I would like you to explain iDany being town pretty please

Zero reason for him to want RCE and I to let things settle themselves out.

Unless RCE and him are exactly the scum team.

Doc on me, I gunsmith NSG tonight, RCE slot gunsmiths Idany today.

In post 2504, PenguinPower wrote:Oh...you were serious about protective oka? Did I miss something?

who knows

In post 2503, Eddie Cane wrote:I think thinking there's two town gunsmiths, no mafia doctors, and no mafia role interference roles is pretty asinine.

Did Boon ever explain why he targeted RCE?

I wanted someone who could explain my thought process to me as lock town. RCE also is a top 3 knows FL Best player, so scumHim could have circumvented me, possibly. He’s better town than scum.

I was gonna gunsmith you, but you joke claimed cop, and i forgot about the no cop.

Also, whoever pushed you as traitor likely is possibly town.

Still need a fruit target

comical i kinda want you to eat the nightkill so ehh

If you kill them, probably Luna, but I think she’s looking to be our lynch target

In post 2501, OkaPoka wrote:

In post 2497, northsidegal wrote:

In post 2479, OkaPoka wrote:nsg you should let comical gunsmith you

why? it'd be a waste

penguin, working on a response to you now

i can protect you tonight and no further and odds are with a setup like this we aren't going to be allowed to play follow the gunsmith for the entire game (aka im the only protective - and i am gated)

so if you want people to trust you for your limited window, then getting you smithed would be ideal

i don't think i need the assistance of being cleared to get people to trust or townread me. in fact, i think it would make the game a lot harder to solve if this valuable limited resource were wasted on a slot who—according to other people—shouldn't be difficult to solve at all.

In post 2503, Eddie Cane wrote:I think thinking there's two town gunsmiths, no mafia doctors, and no mafia role interference roles is pretty asinine.

Did Boon ever explain why he targeted RCE?

i don't necessarily think that there's no mafia role interference. i do think that, given what i know of the setup so far and given what i know of schadd, mafia doctors are fairly unlikely. i think going straight to mafia doctors is both a failure of imagination when it comes to thinking of mafia interference roles for gunsmiths and a serious misunderstanding of schadd's philosophy. based on what i know (and i am fully prepared to eat my words post game if i turn out to be wrong), schadd considers interactions like tracker + ninja to be intensely unfun, and i think he would consider a simple gunsmith + doctor setup to be along the same vein.

In post 2508, PenguinPower wrote:Still need a fruit target

Well im unlikely to be killed over 2 claimed gunsmiths and a claimed doc so u can give it to me.

In post 2509, OkaPoka wrote:comical i kinda want you to eat the nightkill so ehh

I kinda do too so I can boast about what happens when I start posting.

Boon - what's your least favorite fruit?

In post 2512, Luna Fox wrote:

In post 2508, PenguinPower wrote:Still need a fruit target

Well im unlikely to be killed over 2 claimed gunsmiths and a claimed doc so u can give it to me.

No.

I think Mafia Doctor is a mixture of strong synergy if there’s a town killing role, wink wink

In post 2472, PenguinPower wrote:

In post 2463, northsidegal wrote:

In post 2458, PenguinPower wrote:

In post 2455, northsidegal wrote:i really don't think oka should get a mango, but it's up to you really

Who should get "the fruit"

what are your thoughts on alchemist?

why alchemist? I wanted your thoughts.

he's in my scumpool (maybe i'm not up to date on how good mangoes are for your health), but i guess i'll go a bit more into my thoughts

i've already talked a little bit about why i townread oka but i guess it was only one post, so if you want more elaboration on that let me know and i guess i'll try to go back and grab some quotes. fair warning though, outside of the one that i already talked about i think that compared to other players in the game my read on oka isn't really one i'd be able to go back and give you specific posts that lead to the townread there. if you still disagree i'll try, though.

early game i townread clidd and so far i don't think SS has given me any reason to doubt that. there was something of a consensus early game that clidd's early posting was town – that opinion came from multiple sources that i both know to be town now (dannflor, firebringer) and people whose reads i trust. that's not i have the read—I came to the read myself—but it certainly makes me feel better about it.

I know you disagree with me on this one, but I think Luna is town. I liked her very early interactions with Firebringer, I think that 371 is a unique combination of indignation and self-meta that comes from town more often than it comes from scum, and I think almost all of page 66 is town indicative for her. Yes, I know the irony of saying that I think self-meta is towny in a game with flavor leaf in it, but I guess I consider it on a person-by-person basis. She's probably the weakest of my townreads, but I still think she's town.

Comical and RCE are out of my lynchpool right now pretty much only because of their claims.


so that's something of how i arrived at the pool of {eddie, RCE, alchemist, auro}.

In post 2511, northsidegal wrote:schadd considers interactions like tracker + ninja to be intensely unfun, and i think he would consider a simple gunsmith + doctor setup to be along the same vein.

Huh, that's interesting, good to know.

Even if I’m vigged, still gonna boast about how I was too good that people got paranoid I was scum being too good, but i was actually just town being too good

Also, Clidd was scummy af

NSG is scum spouting a mixture of TMI and circumventing direct confrontations.

;

Oh wow...forgot SS was clidd!slot.

Her entire set of reads are perfectly constructed to push a scum agenda yet seeming incredibly genuine and townie.