Mafiascum.net

prod received will catch up

Ya I havent read that recent wall, but the "I have to decide correctly or else" mentality is not reassuring me of that slots off-chance-of-not-being-scum...ness

In post 2522, SeraphicMirth wrote:I don't...I think I was kind of saying that in my post.

You basically said you need to choose correctly and then later we're like 'well, maybe they're both town!' I don't see where that attitude is coming from. Either you have reads on them or you don't. I dont get the automatic inherent assumption that they are scum/town.

In post 2526, AngryPidgeon wrote:Ya I havent read that recent wall, but the "I have to decide correctly or else" mentality is not reassuring me of that slots off-chance-of-not-being-scum...ness

Except that it's pretty much true and the reality I am facing so...I dunno what else to say than that. I come into this situation as an easy lynch and there are only two mislynches left. So if I mess up, it's going to come down on me and then that's the game. I am nervous about that responsibility, clearly.

No, there is no assumption that they are scum..that is what I am saying. No one KNOWS who is scum or town except scum. So, no, I don't know. Just trying to decide as best I can...which I guess is what everyone does. As I said, there is the possibility they are all town..how likely? I don't know.
Maybe I am just making obvious statements and that is confusing. Sorry. I'm just talking myself through the facts of the situation I guess. I probably should post less and write out more for myself in my own notes. But I think you are looking way too much into some things I am saying and pulling weird conclusions out. Or maybe I don't get what you're saying either.


Thoughts on Elyse ISO (read as scum):
-1 page thank you mother of God
- Answers questions with question sometimes, or retorts, rather than answering.

Erm... well, actually...Elyse seems legit. Pretty consistent. Also, I agree with her early assessments of Grim that she had. She did not make big irrational/complex pushes against anyone with erroneous arguments...except Enomis/me. But I guess everyone thinks that this slot is scum so that's kind of null then. Doesn't postulate odd reasons why people are scum and is good at poking holes in those who do. Though I suppose that could be a scum tactic as well...except that her explanations/pointing-outs are so damn reasonable. Except for on me but I guess we can talk about that later.

In post 2522, SeraphicMirth wrote:Also - question for all: is there anyone who DOESN'T think enomis is scum (prior to my replacing)? Even just null? Just trying to see if there's a scum pattern/association around that as well. If it is truly "universal" then it doesn't help me see any sort of pattern that way but thought I'd ask.

I had a townread on the slot.

Are you guys just done discussing? It kind of seems like the few pages before I replaced in, that is the case and I probably didn't bring up anything that hasn't already been brought up either. So..guess that doesn't help. Maybe it's just vote time.

I'm away for most of the day today due to travel. Might be able to check in tonight.

Vote Elyse please thanks.

Why? I saw your argument which was a list of her posts that seem pretty solid to me. I don't think she was particularly "trying" to align herself with town. Just seemed like normal town play to me. It really seems that scummy to you?

Yes.

And also her reliance on "you can't tie me to a team nyah nyah!" as her entire defense for why she's not scum.

That's not my entire defense you just have problems with reading.

I'm kinda tempted to hammer Elyse just because I'm feeling scum are just waiting for Seraphic to hammer Grim.

If anyone takes Seraphic off the hook by hammering before she states an opinion, I'm challenging you tomorrow.

In post 2535, Wisdom wrote:I'm kinda tempted to hammer Elyse just because I'm feeling scum are just waiting for Seraphic to hammer Grim.

Wisdom - who are the scum waiting for her to hammer Elyse in this worldview of yours?

Errrr GG, not Elyse.

Wisdom, I don't understand that at all. Grim and I are both at L-1. Why is scum waiting for sera to hammer Grim and not me? Unless you think Venmar and Qwints are scum...which doesn't make much sense.

Don't see why it doesn't. Anyone could be scum in this clusterfuck of a game.

I don't even remember what my reads were this game tbh

can someone tl;dr seraph for me tia

what I hate, is that nobody can understand that I cannot <----- repeat cannot comprehend long wots unless there is an emotional appeal like on life channel. and I certainly cannot maintain an understanding of quote wars. I lose focus after 2 or 3 lines

I can't remember if site meta dictates that if a lynch lasts this long it is on scum or not.

WE NEED A LYNCH

We'll have one after Seraphic is ready.

In post 2536, qwints wrote:If anyone takes Seraphic off the hook by hammering before she states an opinion, I'm challenging you tomorrow.

My opinion has been stated as of now after ISO I think Grim is scum.

and also yeah idk this game really is a cluster so whatever. That's what I'm going with.