A50 that post was made in a moment of frustration and not thinking properly. I didn't how to respond to the gamma accusations that I thought were dumb. So I wanted to prove them wrong by flipping gamma. At least then we can focus on other people.
Like marshy. Let's lynch marshy scum. There's obviously a lot of TvT going on so let's avoid lynching the active people (though in the event people change their mind about koki that is still one of my top scumreads but we can wait. Let's sort the lurkers and speed up congress voting for future day phases).
VOTE: marshy
Posted: Thu Mar 15, 2018 8:08 pm
by Jodaxq
I don't really think the runner up WC host should be a huge deal. I'd rather give it to town, of course, but I cannot think of a way where scum could manipulate things with Brass as host.
HEAL: Joey_ x2
Posted: Thu Mar 15, 2018 8:29 pm
by Jodaxq
The Gamma v Nero fight is a pretty big turn off, but I think they're both town. I buy the arguments for a town Gamma and definitely want to give him another night to provide results. I think Nero's push is bad, but I trust Joey's read on him as I've seen Joey correctly and instantly identify town Nero elsewhere.
Posted: Thu Mar 15, 2018 8:31 pm
by Jodaxq
A50 is making a ton of sense to me. His logic combined with his claim and verification by Brass makes him a strong town read for me.
Posted: Thu Mar 15, 2018 8:43 pm
by Jodaxq
I don't like any of Marshy's votes today. I could get behind a Marshy lynch
Posted: Thu Mar 15, 2018 8:53 pm
by Jodaxq
Ranmaru was super active yesterday, but today he's only poked around the Gamma lynch in the midst of my claim and made the easy vote of Brass for WC host. His posts toward the end of yesterday were mostly contentless as well. Does anyone town read Ran? Why?
Posted: Thu Mar 15, 2018 8:55 pm
by Jodaxq
VOTE: Ranmaru
Posted: Thu Mar 15, 2018 10:53 pm
by Nero Cain
Ran was never super active to begin with.
Posted: Thu Mar 15, 2018 11:13 pm
by Nero Cain
In post 2527, Jodaxq wrote:I buy the arguments for a town Gamma and definitely want to give him another night to provide results. I think Nero's push is bad
What arguments are those?
All I remember seeing is an argument that we shouldn't lynch a claimed JOAT today. I feel like the JOAT claim is a little sketch. Like dude got tracked so he had to claim something that was plausible and the "WAIT I'M NOT A WATCHER!" Kinda gives him a little wiggle room. I also feel like he totally should have waited to use his watch when Brass wasn't protected. I still feel like his content is confusing and potentially scum motivated.
Me being wrong isn't a foregone conclusion but the wagon on him feels mostly town so what: Am I just wrong and scum are sheeping me? Gamma hasn't really talked about this either and it's shortsighted at best.
There's also a potential guilty.
What made you track Gamma?
Posted: Thu Mar 15, 2018 11:29 pm
by Nero Cain
Like if we are not lynching Gamma today b/c lol pr claim. Then I'd like to lynch in
Shaziro
ActionDan
and maybe Klazam depending on a reread
Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2018 1:34 am
by brassherald
Hi, I'll make a post before I go back to being one of New York's leading producers in fever and mucus.
My lynchpool today is Kiana, ActionDan, and Klazam in that order.
Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2018 1:47 am
by Ranmaru
Morning. I recently was given a 2 week suspension at work, so I should have more time to focus on this game. Do note, that I'm also having problems with my left hand, so I won't be posting in depth, but will try to give some content as I catch up tonight.
Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2018 2:54 am
by Kiana Kaslana
In post 2529, Jodaxq wrote:I don't like any of Marshy's votes today. I could get behind a Marshy lynch
I could get behind a Marshy lynch as well.
Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2018 2:55 am
by Kiana Kaslana
In post 2535, brassherald wrote:Hi, I'll make a post before I go back to being one of New York's leading producers in fever and mucus.
My lynchpool today is Kiana, ActionDan, and Klazam in that order.
Why is Kiana at the front of that order? I don't think that's a correct order.
Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2018 4:55 am
by Chara
can you tell me about marshy scum for you, Kiana?
Almost: 95%? you must tell me what happened in between your last read on me and this one. :>
Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2018 5:00 am
by Kokichi Oma
We are lynching Gamma. He fake claims PR as scum all the time. He did it as scum in a game I just finished with him. Lynch him. This IS his scum defense.
In post 2527, Jodaxq wrote:I buy the arguments for a town Gamma and definitely want to give him another night to provide results. I think Nero's push is bad
What arguments are those?
All I remember seeing is an argument that we shouldn't lynch a claimed JOAT today. I feel like the JOAT claim is a little sketch. Like dude got tracked so he had to claim something that was plausible and the "WAIT I'M NOT A WATCHER!" Kinda gives him a little wiggle room. I also feel like he totally should have waited to use his watch when Brass wasn't protected. I still feel like his content is confusing and potentially scum motivated.
Me being wrong isn't a foregone conclusion but the wagon on him feels mostly town so what: Am I just wrong and scum are sheeping me? Gamma hasn't really talked about this either and it's shortsighted at best.
The argument for a town Gamma is that there isn't a scum role that fits with wanting to visit Brass. My original thought was that he was the orange religion spreader (or potentially third party/third team spreader) but the other religion spreader PM suggests that brass would have been notified of both religions visiting him. I also think that if he is scum, he now has to continue to fake results which would be pretty tough to continue to get verified results.
I also buy A50's argument that Elbirn was shot by scum. This is something that will become more apparent as the game continues and we can know for sure if there's a vig/SK/third team.
Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2018 5:50 am
by Chara
^^^^^that.
except for the PR thought. a Gamma who was "caught" would have to fakeclaim.
Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2018 6:05 am
by Venmar
Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2018 6:15 am
by pidgey
In post 2545, Jodaxq wrote:
but the other religion spreader PM suggests that brass would have been notified of both religions visiting him. I also think that if he is scum, he now has to continue to fake results which would be pretty tough to continue to get verified results.
Where did you got this part from? I dont really see anything about that in my role
In post 2545, Jodaxq wrote:
but the other religion spreader PM suggests that brass would have been notified of both religions visiting him. I also think that if he is scum, he now has to continue to fake results which would be pretty tough to continue to get verified results.
Where did you got this part from? I dont really see anything about that in my role
It says "no discernable or tangible night effects" so I don't think it would be blocked by another religion visiting.