Warrior Cats Mafia [Day Three]

[NorwegianboyEE]

These are domestic policies and we are cutting the fat.

[Datisi]

i want us to remove the scum that is definitely in there

do you have mod-confirmed mechanical information that there is scum present in your hood?

[NorwegianboyEE]

You know i don’t.

[Datisi]

then stop acting like you do?

[NorwegianboyEE]

I’ve made up my mind and if you disagree then great, who is scum? I’m not gonna change my decision i’ve thought about it and i prefer T3 as the flip today.

[Charloux]

What was the point of the last 5-ish pages, it's just running in circles.
I'm waiting on Shiro to come back from V/LA, T3 to post some reads. If we need info we should flip Alisae, she is the eye of the storm of a lot of stuff that happened this game.
Kitty is still scummy, but his posting is consistent which i find harder to do as scum. He also never had a "moment of clarity" so can't call him faking it either.

Anything specific that needs commenting on?

[Datisi]

like jesus fucking christ why are both you and alisae distancing and pussyfooting around your t3 scumread under the excuse of "he's the scummiest in the hood" THAT DOESN'T MEAN ANYTHING

either own the scumread or admit it's not that strong, i don't want to be solving around the nonsense bullshit of "scummiest in hood" because it's so easy for scum to hide behind that

why does alisae scumread t3, norwee? from what am i supposed to understand their scumread there?

[NorwegianboyEE]

Like are you literally just scum?
I think it’s been pretty clear our reasoning, no pussyfooting there (heh, get it?), but you’re just being obstinate for the sake of it now.

[Alisae]

Datisi please read the following out loud…

I wouldn't even say my read on T3 is strong

[Charloux]

He is just annoyed people keep piling up easy ml's. Mastina D1, T3 D2, Kitty D3... When does it stop actually?

[Datisi]

Datisi please read the following out loud…

I wouldn't even say my read on T3 is strong

yes thank you that is exactly the fucking problem

y'all admit that your read on t3 is weak and still the only reason given is "scummiest in hood", but you're still preflipping half the game based on him being scum and you don't see the problem in that??

[Alisae]

U sound like ur mad

[Datisi]

ya i'm fucking mad

this was supposed to be a simple question that we both spend one post on, and then i wait for catboi to answer my post in hood, i draw conclusions on alisae/catboi/t3, and we move on with our lives

but it's turned into this nonsense and i'm taking a break from this game until my classes of the day are done

[Ydrasse]

Please remember to treat each other kindly.

[T3]

I had an entire wall on Misty and then I accidentally exited out of chrome ;-;

[T3]

Spoiler:

is the postcap what's making y'all jumpy because it feels like you keep going off on things that are more arbitrary than scummy

i think frozen angel is scummy for trying to over-explain her vote on charloux

What part is over-explanation? All of her explanation is in response to direct questions.

fan of this post

hi misty do you have any alignment related thoughts on anyone yet

not really

liked the way you dug into FA's vote post, liked SS's analysis, think those thoughts had more depth than any other pushes

kinda just chilling until i get something to lock in on as a way to get into the game

I don’t think I buy that Misty actually thought S_S’s analysis post was towny. The post is a surface level observation of a flaw in another player’s case that I also thought of immediately.

Aside from that, all of her early posts are calling posts good or bad without any actual analysis. While that isn’t inherently scummy, her justification for why she does so doesn’t track. She claims that everything town has been latching on to is arbitrary and not necessarily scummy. That just seems like a way to coast and avoid making content. By that point Charloux had already made his ‘slip,’ catboi and FA were pushing Charloux. Those pushes are hardly arbitrary, Charloux made a post that could be reasonably interpreted as a scumslip. There are definitely non-mech related things that one can latch on to based on other player’s analysis.

I ISO dived Misty a few days ago but never got around to typing everything up. More coming later.

[Something_Smart]

I'm good enough and have the game knowledge and experience to be able to look at another player and just tell who is experienced and who isn't and sucks and is just an idiot.

Is there anyone else in this game who has arbitrary stances?

[KittyTacky]

Where are your read explanations, my man. If it's gut then say it's gut. Don't dodge questions.

[Cephrir]

You genuinely believe our hood has 0 scum?

i don't think of scum with regards to hood memberships and i think it's extremely stupid to solve that way, which is why i didn't understand alisae's scumread there

i have been begging alisae to explain to me why they scumread t3 and they keep giving me non-answers, i'm not making anything out

based on their answers, why does alisae scumread t3, norwee?

Well i’ve stated in hood that i want us to remove the scum that is definitely in there and since every other player has felt very town and 1 slot has not even tried to engage in hood since their "hi" post, you do the math.
It’s an high-intensity zone in there and T3 couldn’t even keep up with main thread.
So it’s an selfish desire that drives me too. I want to have a scum free hood and idc what you say. It is from an game perspective almost impossible odds to just have a hood in this game that is scum free.
If T3 is town then i can only assume that i must be mistakenly townreading someone else, that’s just how it is.

At game start the odds of a hood being clean are (16/21)^5 = about 25%. There are 4 hoods. So chances of at least one of them being clean are actually quite good

[Mistyx]

UNVOTE:

[Mistyx]

busy today probably won’t be around around until the afternoon at best

[KittyTacky]

Good nyaight. I will do an ISO analysis of T3 tomorrow.

[Cephrir]

So chances of at least one of them being clean are actually quite good

it's about 72% without accounting for titus

also: i feel like maybe titus' role is scummy? the fact that the hoods don't list occupants means she could have pretended to just be alone and used it to spy

but idk maybe that is overly obvious game design

and i can think of a (deeply, deeply niche) town use for that ability too

[Bell]

When Titus joined your clan, did the mod make an announcement?

Seems like an easy answer.

[PenguinPower]

i mean - titus is just scummy so there's that too