No; obviously not, unless it is a 1-1 for scum. I would be fine with losing a cop if it means nailing another scum. I cannot imagine there are more than two left. Also, that is a total misrep.
VOTE: GiF
Lynch pool: {GiF, vezok, PV}. May increase; very ambivalent about LeMidget and MS.
Also, vezok is probably scum if we think there is a scum Herder.
i seem to be out of sync with my alp vote, granted its mostly because he lurks but i mean he comes in here and gets active only when pressured. So my question to both of you are how you can dismiss him?
Posted: Mon Mar 17, 2014 7:45 pm
by Aegor
I would be fine with annihilating Alp as well. Consider him added to the lynch pool.
Posted: Mon Mar 17, 2014 7:45 pm
by Svenskt Stål
All,
I now understand the amnesiac cop abit more, but the prevailing idea that the target AND the result reciever are both scum does not make sense. The cop trusted molla twice, what would be the reason for switching result reciever?
Posted: Mon Mar 17, 2014 7:48 pm
by Aegor
Fear that he would be NKed?
Posted: Mon Mar 17, 2014 7:54 pm
by Svenskt Stål
ohhh, okay
hmm, i think the cop should leave hints as to who recieved unouted information, but hold of on it obviously until the end of the day
Posted: Mon Mar 17, 2014 10:47 pm
by GuyInFreezer
In post 2598, vezokpiraka wrote:Just lynch scum Gif.
Asks aegor if he wanta the cop dead when aegor said that the cop shoul claim if he was xshot and out of shots. That is fearmongering.
cop has absolutely no reason to out now unless he's on L-1 and forced to claim.
He can always clsim when the massclaim time comes.
No; obviously not, unless it is a 1-1 for scum. I would be fine with losing a cop if it means nailing another scum. I cannot imagine there are more than two left. Also, that is a total misrep.
VOTE: GiF
Lynch pool: {GiF, vezok, PV}. May increase; very ambivalent about LeMidget and MS.
Also, vezok is probably scum if we think there is a scum Herder.
In post 2496, Zdenek wrote:Possible Mastin buddy - complains that Mastin is reading him as scum for a shitty reason, votes Bulba, on page 5.
I kidna agree with this one
Yep. And his play has been kinda weird today.
In post 2511, Alpazard wrote:I have a theory that scum got the results on another scum and now don't want to reveal it and lose another buddy
Unless Molla got extremely fucking lucky, I think Molla gets all the results.
It just doesn't make sense that he would get them twice in a row in a game this large unless that were the case.
In post 2512, Aegor wrote:Holding off is fine, but if no one claims cop results, I would recommend that the cop pick a different results target but the same investigation target.
I don't think that's how an amn cop works. Besides, if the cop could pick the results target, and the situation was scum got scum results, we'd have two scum more or less confirmed now.
In post 2553, BBmolla wrote:As far as I understand, Amnesiac selects a person to be investigated and selects someone to recieve the report. I was that person for night 1 and night 2. I don't know who for night 3.
Why would they pick a new target instead of you? It makes no sense.
Also it was my understanding of the role that the recipient of the reports was not a choice.
In post 2599, Aegor wrote:Also, vezok is probably scum if we think there is a scum Herder.
Yeah if we could get back to lynching this that would be great.
Targets were Pidgey AD and Sekai.
Posted: Tue Mar 18, 2014 7:37 am
by Svenskt Stål
vezok,
now that you have a substantial set of data I expect you to do soething pro town with it, looking forward to it
sekai, looking at data and making sense of it is right up your alley, since you offered no objection i would like you to make a go at it aswell
sure. I'll probably take the rest of the day phase. Thor flipping town was not expected.
Also I think there's a scum herder as per last game. Possibly it's Toog's slot, something he said D1 pinged my gut
If you're the amn cop just fucking check him and send me it because nobody is listening to me about the slot
If you tell me a reason why you think he's scum, I'll listen.
In post 2602, Svenskt Stål wrote:i seem to be out of sync with my alp vote, granted its mostly because he lurks but i mean he comes in here and gets active only when pressured. So my question to both of you are how you can dismiss him?
I'm not dismissing him, but like toogeloo there are some reasons to think that the slot is town, so if you want me to vote him, I'm going to need some sort of reason why you think they're scum.
So far metal sonic is posting in way that makes me want him dead.
In post 2614, Majiffy wrote:Wasn't to Thor, it was to you. Apparently you didn't get it, which means I also don't get the post you made that it was about.
You make my life so hard.
Unvote
Vote: Metal Sonic
Posted: Tue Mar 18, 2014 1:03 pm
by BBmolla
UNVOTE: VOTE: Metal Sonic
Posted: Tue Mar 18, 2014 1:38 pm
by Aegor
VOTE: Metal Sonic
Posted: Tue Mar 18, 2014 2:06 pm
by Majiffy
VOTE: MS
Posted: Tue Mar 18, 2014 3:30 pm
by pidgey
Sven- yah id be willing to vote alp.
Why the fuck do you keep asking that? I dont feel like voting him at the moment accomplishes anything..
BTW Majiffy is prob town as much as I hate to admit that.
Posted: Tue Mar 18, 2014 5:48 pm
by Majiffy
No shit.
Posted: Wed Mar 19, 2014 3:17 am
by Metal Sonic
did a cop get a guilty on me? no? then take your vote and put it on someone that actually drew a scum role pm