Micro 952 - The Coalition: ItGBSMoD [game over!]

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

YOINK PAGETOP!?!

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

I'm glad I got at least one of these before I bit the bullet

DonC just unvote and lets talk it out

aldus can log in at any moment

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

if you are unconvinced by the end of our convo you can just revote me no hard feelings

[DonCorleone]

there's no reason both wagons can't be town.

Sure, no reason they can’t be. Lots of reasons to think they probably are SvT when following this pattern

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

gimme 1 reason why they're SvT

[DonCorleone]

Because generally one wagon getting pushed by town that is strongly resisted means its scum doing the resisting

And I think it’s less likely that scum were consistently resisting one town wagon vs another than that scum were resisting because the alternative wagon was on scum

[DonCorleone]

If I’m wrong so be it, I tried my best and got fooled as hard as everyone else

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Because generally one wagon getting pushed by town that is strongly resisted means its scum doing the resisting

And I think it’s less likely that scum were consistently resisting one town wagon vs another than that scum were resisting because the alternative wagon was on scum

but you were the one doing the resisting!!

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

And I think it’s less likely that scum were consistently resisting one town wagon vs another than that scum were resisting because the alternative wagon was on scum

If both wagons are on town - the scum don't care one way or the other - they'd rather just split their votes up so both wagons are viable and there's a natural continuation target for the NEXT day when one of the wagons goes thru.

Setting up two wagons creates a natural rivalry between the 2 wagon targets and focusses all the action around them - this is something you want to happen if you're scum.

Look at Sleepersoul - Aldus on D1

Aldus is voting me
Sleepersoul is supporting me

Look at DnD - Aldus on D2

Aldus is voting me
DnD is supporting me without even reading the game as soon as he replaces in.

Why do you think they are always split up like that? My bet is Aldus told DnD in the scum PT that his job is to support Pooky - one scum on either side.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

If I’m wrong so be it, I tried my best and got fooled as hard as everyone else

if you're still wrong at the end of this convo you can just revote me - but give me a chance at least - if aldus logs in and hammers the game is over.


If I can't show you where you're wrong - I will take this loss knowing I did my best and you did too but at least give me the chance man.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

the ideal situation for any scum is not to get himself at L-1 every day and almost get lynched - that's just a retarded way to play.

What scum want to do is INDIRECT conflict - especially between town players - that's why they support both sides of TvT so that all of the energy/focus is on the 2 TvT players - that's why both day 1 and day 2 focused around a single 1v1 conflict that didn't really spread out to the rest of the game - the scum are quite happy having a TvT be the primary focus because they have no risk and they also have a natural target for the next day to go after.

[DonCorleone]

Because generally one wagon getting pushed by town that is strongly resisted means its scum doing the resisting

And I think it’s less likely that scum were consistently resisting one town wagon vs another than that scum were resisting because the alternative wagon was on scum

but you were the one doing the resisting!!

If it was me doing the resisting how come I was the fourth vote on clover and the third vote on klick?

Like yes I was probably the most vocally against you on D1/with wug and forced it, but I definitely wasn’t the one resisting on D2

[DonCorleone]

My bet is Aldus told DnD in the scum PT that his job is to support Pooky

I mean I recently rolled scum with aldus and sort of doubt that he’d be the one running things if the scumteam were him and DnD

[Dumb and Dumber]

VOTE: pooky

Let’s find out!

Awesome, I was right on you

- Dumber

[Dumb and Dumber]

DnD is supporting me without even reading the game as soon as he replaces in.

Why do you think they are always split up like that? My bet is Aldus told DnD in the scum PT that his job is to support Pooky - one scum on either side.

First line: factually untrue, which I addressed
Second line: To be quite honest, if I'm scum I'm running the scum strategy (sorry aldu)

Also, is Aldu/DnD your final answer?

- Dumber

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

you were the L-1 vote on me D1 , when you switched over on D1 you completely changed the momentum on that wagon - it was

4- Pooky
3- Clover

with Deimos signalling intent to hammer

you changed from Pooky to Clover making it 4-3 the other way and bent Deimos into hammering Clover - Was that scum driven? No - both you and deimos are TOWN


On Day 2 you were the first person to be convinced by DnD to switch from Pooky to Klick - after that Deimos also switched his position and that was the bandwagon - Pooky-DnD-DonC-Deimos

Was that scum driven? you know you're town - you know deimos is town. Who is the scum changing the wagon direction? DnD? Why don't you vote him instead of me then?

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

My bet is Aldus told DnD in the scum PT that his job is to support Pooky

I mean I recently rolled scum with aldus and sort of doubt that he’d be the one running things if the scumteam were him and DnD

DnD literally just replaced in on Day 2, you think he wouldn't ask aldus what's going on in the scum PT?

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Also, is Aldu/DnD your final answer?

I said Aldus was your scumbuddy like 2 or 3 days ago when DonC asked

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Cmon Donny

We've been thru so much - don't give up on me now

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

like I'm just saying let's talk it out

if you think I'm still scum at the end of the convo you can just revote me and it'll be game over

[Alduskkel]

hello i'm reading but it looks like pooky is at E-1 and is currently AtEing

[Alduskkel]

Just one thing that bothers me: if the scumteam is Pooky/D&D, and they NK'd Chemist because they expected Pooky to be eliminated Day 2, then why did D&D hard defend Pooky on Day 2?

DC do you have any theories? this is like the one thing that I wanna clear up before I hammer Pooky

[DonCorleone]

Nice so it’s confirmed not DnD/aldus which was my big paranoia worry, phew

[DonCorleone]

Unless this is a massive troll in which case

You’re tacky and I hate you

[Dumb and Dumber]

DC do you have any theories? this is like the one thing that I wanna clear up before I hammer Pooky

Cuz it's not the scumteam!

- Dumber