Mafiascum.net

I kind of just want a flip now tbh >.>

i'm giving a bit above 12 hours for everyone to check in and say their peace or whatever before i hammer

it's likely gonna be a bit more since very likely i'm not awake at 7:30 am tomorrow, but yeah

I mean that's fair I'm not demanding you hammer now

I'm just bloodthirsty and tired of thinking

In post 785, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 757, JohnnyFarrar wrote:

In post 755, marcistar wrote:this is a recent towngame if u care

@gamma do you remember anything of this game? I skipped around the ISO but ain't no way I'm reading a 500 post ISO

Yes
I feel like Marci might be a little similar across that game and this one
More notably, her position feels like the one I was in that game. So I’m fairly certain she’s town here.

This might be my most clear indication of how I was translating the events of Eurybia’s Curse into my marci read this game, but I definitely explained it so “no explanation” is a blatant untruth by Datisi. And I feel like Datisi has to have seen me use this sort of “extrapolate events from game A to read game B, even if there’s no meta thru-line of any particular player”. As a result calling my reasoning “nonsense” and saying it was scummy feels off-color, a personal disagreement on the relevance of my anecdotal meta does not make it immediately nonsense.
Actually he DEFINITELY saw me use the anecdotal meta thing recently, unless he doesn’t actually read the games he mods.

i'm not saying it was scummy, i'm saying it has partner equity with marcistar (along your other acts towards her), that's not the same thing

your explanations were nonsense and unexplained to me because i have zero idea what happened in that game and i don't do second-hand meta

i wasn't reading pyp closely since it was p boring (assuming that's what you're referring to here) but i never claimed that using anecdotal meta is scummy from you either way so moot point

In post 2604, Datisi wrote:i wasn't reading pyp closely since it was p boring

townstomps are extremely boring

It feels kinda shite to go “I don’t do second-hand meta” to write off my read and then say my defense has partner equity, when you haven’t rlly put in the actual effort to parse my defense
I can’t actually recall Datisi ever directly engaging my marci TR in fact

In post 2553, marcistar wrote:me/gamma was one he brought up a bit

read this datisi
"WAS"

In post 2607, Gamma Emerald wrote:It feels kinda shite to go “I don’t do second-hand meta” to write off my read and then say my defense has partner equity, when you haven’t rlly put in the actual effort to parse my defense
I can’t actually recall Datisi ever directly engaging my marci TR in fact

think i asked people why they townread marci at points

if you go "vibes and also vaguely similar to this game" that's a dead end to me immediately

like i'm sorry i'm discarding your read there but i am physically incapable of using meta from games i did not play through with an uninformed mindset without confbiasing myself to shit

and whatever defense you would've put up of marci there would've been +partner equity if it makes you feel any better

I wasn’t rlly saying she felt similar to another game
I was more trying to highlight the anecdotal meta portion. If you had asked “why do you feel like marci’s situation matches yours from that game?” I would have actually responded “it feels like an unrealistic initial expectation was put in place for her gamestart behavior and she’s in an unrecoverable hole as a result of it” which would have been an assessment of and more parsable. So maybe try to actually tell when I’m presenting anecdotal meta, because that (almost) always has some tangible bearing in the current game, so even if the meta element is uninviting you could at least determine if the presented scenario in question makes sense on its own

I think Freedom's the winning vote here

yeet

Freedom[4]:

JohnnyFarrar, Ausuka, Gamma Emerald, Alexcellent

Datisi[1]:

marcistar

marcistar[1]:

Datisi

not voting [2]:

Freedom, Scamper

In post 2576, Ausuka wrote:

In post 2521, Freedom wrote:

In post 2470, Ausuka wrote:I will say I think Freedom's behaviour is fairly clear cut the scummiest of anyone and the role claim is also probably the worst. Shoshin is the only thing that makes me doubt that push.

Why is my claim bad?

I missed this - I think
1) Town needs significant power and also needs plenty of VTs. Both of our roles are effectively useless and therefore fairly unlikely to coexist, although I wouldn't rule it out because loltrollgame and I don't fully understand what balances a normal game.
2) It's somewhat odd you're the only neighbour who's vanilla. I could see you possibly being some form of scummy mafia PR who didn't want to either trueclaim or make up a claim so just claimed vanilla neighbour.

I agree with 1) and the first sentence of 2) but I disagree on the second one. If I was an actual PR, why would I fakeclaim after receiving your Mailman message?
You literally gave me a headsup on what claims I could make and you wouldn't find it bad.
Why ignore you?

In post 2611, JohnnyFarrar wrote:I think Freedom's the winning vote here

Why?

ugh sorry for being so indecisive >.>

gve me a minute to collect my thoughts here

In post 2611, JohnnyFarrar wrote:I think Freedom's the winning vote here

You want me to hammer?

In post 2616, Freedom wrote:

In post 2611, JohnnyFarrar wrote:I think Freedom's the winning vote here

You want me to hammer?

I'm not self-hammering, you know?

In post 2613, Freedom wrote:

In post 2576, Ausuka wrote:

In post 2521, Freedom wrote:

In post 2470, Ausuka wrote:I will say I think Freedom's behaviour is fairly clear cut the scummiest of anyone and the role claim is also probably the worst. Shoshin is the only thing that makes me doubt that push.

Why is my claim bad?

I missed this - I think
1) Town needs significant power and also needs plenty of VTs. Both of our roles are effectively useless and therefore fairly unlikely to coexist, although I wouldn't rule it out because loltrollgame and I don't fully understand what balances a normal game.
2) It's somewhat odd you're the only neighbour who's vanilla. I could see you possibly being some form of scummy mafia PR who didn't want to either trueclaim or make up a claim so just claimed vanilla neighbour.

I agree with 1) and the first sentence of 2) but I disagree on the second one. If I was an actual PR, why would I fakeclaim after receiving your Mailman message?
You literally gave me a headsup on what claims I could make and you wouldn't find it bad.
Why ignore you?

I don't think I did?? I said you were probably a PR but that didn't mean you would know what exactly to claim

In post 2618, Ausuka wrote:

In post 2613, Freedom wrote:

In post 2576, Ausuka wrote:

In post 2521, Freedom wrote:

In post 2470, Ausuka wrote:I will say I think Freedom's behaviour is fairly clear cut the scummiest of anyone and the role claim is also probably the worst. Shoshin is the only thing that makes me doubt that push.

Why is my claim bad?

I missed this - I think
1) Town needs significant power and also needs plenty of VTs. Both of our roles are effectively useless and therefore fairly unlikely to coexist, although I wouldn't rule it out because loltrollgame and I don't fully understand what balances a normal game.
2) It's somewhat odd you're the only neighbour who's vanilla. I could see you possibly being some form of scummy mafia PR who didn't want to either trueclaim or make up a claim so just claimed vanilla neighbour.

I agree with 1) and the first sentence of 2) but I disagree on the second one. If I was an actual PR, why would I fakeclaim after receiving your Mailman message?
You literally gave me a headsup on what claims I could make and you wouldn't find it bad.
Why ignore you?

I don't think I did?? I said you were probably a PR but that didn't mean you would know what exactly to claim

But I would know that claiming a PR would impress you more than claiming Vanilla.

good morning scumfucks, i am awake

is it hammer time?

In post 2619, Freedom wrote:

In post 2618, Ausuka wrote:

In post 2613, Freedom wrote:

In post 2576, Ausuka wrote:

In post 2521, Freedom wrote:

In post 2470, Ausuka wrote:I will say I think Freedom's behaviour is fairly clear cut the scummiest of anyone and the role claim is also probably the worst. Shoshin is the only thing that makes me doubt that push.

Why is my claim bad?

I missed this - I think
1) Town needs significant power and also needs plenty of VTs. Both of our roles are effectively useless and therefore fairly unlikely to coexist, although I wouldn't rule it out because loltrollgame and I don't fully understand what balances a normal game.
2) It's somewhat odd you're the only neighbour who's vanilla. I could see you possibly being some form of scummy mafia PR who didn't want to either trueclaim or make up a claim so just claimed vanilla neighbour.

I agree with 1) and the first sentence of 2) but I disagree on the second one. If I was an actual PR, why would I fakeclaim after receiving your Mailman message?
You literally gave me a headsup on what claims I could make and you wouldn't find it bad.
Why ignore you?

I don't think I did?? I said you were probably a PR but that didn't mean you would know what exactly to claim

But I would know that claiming a PR would impress you more than claiming Vanilla.

I think this is has some legitimacy but claiming PR also carries risks - you're more likely to get caught in a lie, and you're more likely to have to explain why you weren't nightkilled, for example

In post 2620, Datisi wrote:is it hammer time?

this is a serious question btw

i see scamper asked for a minute but it's been 5 hours so

I would wait a bit for scamper I think since you're like... very active onsite I don't think there's a risk of missing the deadline

yeah ok, worst case scenario i'll hammer after work

back to lurking then, see ya