Mafiascum.net

my lavender towncase

an essay by prism

1. that wagon though
2. this person literally has not voted day 2 despite multiple wagons and being in danger of scum autoloss

Prism wrote:prism's final readlist

town: puppy/krazy/tanner in that order
super town day 2 but depending on who the other is: pooky
??? pretty town but haven't read in eons: morning
spectating the game: lavender
probably scum by default: chara
scum: taylor, hectic

Prism wrote:tanner belongs in between morning/pooky actually but i have read him more recently

I can accept that readslist. I have Chara at the top though

2 is worth elaboration, which is that they might be chara hammersitting, but do any of us think lavender is hovering over the game just waiting for their chance here? or have they literally just been AFK for 100 pages?

In post 2675, Prism wrote:my lavender towncase

an essay by prism

1. that wagon though
2. this person literally has not voted day 2 despite multiple wagons and being in danger of scum autoloss

my counterargument

that wagon did not exonerate Lav. it exonerated krazy
If Lavender suddenly started caring under pressure we would have eliminated her 45 pages ago. Also I don't think she minds as either alignment

THAT BEING SAID

i will vote tayl0r with you if that is the move

In post 2668, CantHateAPuppy wrote:

In post 2663, Tanner wrote:

In post 2662, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:Why doesn't Hectic make sense as the Chara?

chara-hectic doesn't lolbus elements?

like that's genuinely as profound as my reads go right now

dont want to start second guessing reads this late in the phase

but this post just doesn't sit right w/ me RN. tanner, could u elaborate on this even a little? if not, can u explain what u don't like about the game that's making it hard to make a better read here?

this game is confusing. i have "The Townblocc" and then i have the confusing mess that is 4 people i thought/think are viable votes or that i would maybe vote. i'm grasping at straws, i don't know how to read hectic, i never did. fear is telling me he's tried to shitpush me multiple times, gut is telling me he's a townie. i don't know what else to tell you.

chara absolutely does not deserve to be at the top, their progression on taylor is extremely questionable and their reads on me/hectic/tanner one notch below

beeboy revote+its followup was also sketchy given surrounding statements even if 95% of it lines up

chara's tone/reactions are insanely good but skimming scumgames will quickly tell you they excel at this and we should find another avenue to read them

In post 2682, Prism wrote:chara's tone/reactions are insanely good but skimming scumgames will quickly tell you they excel at this and we should find another avenue to read them

I see. It is unfortunate that I tend to read on tone and emotion

In post 2671, Krazy wrote:

In post 2597, CantHateAPuppy wrote:

In post 2595, Hectic wrote:My sus pool ftr is [Launchy, Pooky, Krazy] right now. I just don't feel confident about any one read to case or push it.

The tier above that is probably [Tanner, Lavender].

pooky? tanner? i just feel like we're playing two different games. if i could resolve this into a solid scumread or a solid townread, i would feel a lot better about you and the game in general

what did you think about Hectic's response to 2597 puppy? also do you have any feelings or thoughts about him having you and pooky as his bottom tier?

i didn't understand which order the tiers were in and am still waiting for this answer:

In post 2600, CantHateAPuppy wrote:

In post 2599, Hectic wrote:

In post 2597, CantHateAPuppy wrote:

In post 2595, Hectic wrote:My sus pool ftr is [Launchy, Pooky, Krazy] right now. I just don't feel confident about any one read to case or push it.

The tier above that is probably [Tanner, Lavender].

pooky? tanner? i just feel like we're playing two different games. if i could resolve this into a solid scumread or a solid townread, i would feel a lot better about you and the game in general

Probably be more accurate to say this:

Tanner, Lavender
Launchy, Pooky


Krazy

Krazy's slot was my only scumread and now he's not a thing. The rest aren't scumleans even and I see more town than scum there - this is the problem.

is this top bottom or bottom top

but if hectic has me and pook as most-want-to-launch tier... that's just weird. he needs to explain that even a little to convince me it's not an attempt to have weird reads from the rest of the game so he looks like he's not pretending to solve.

prism

pooky

tayl0r

Review: [tweet/chara/puppy/Heckboy/lavender]

tanner

right now processing what I think of tanner's soft defense of hecboy and some other things

but right now the hectic push is literally all my top town so that's... something

Pooky and Puppy below Lav? Just how confident is Hectic that Lav is town?!

I assume the bottom = scummier because Hectic wants Krazy the most i think

In post 2673, Prism wrote:scum: taylor, hectic

on this we're on the same page tbh. i would be fine with either of these unless hectic gives me a good reason otherwise. it's not even that he's the scummiest i've ever seen, he's just not making himself ease to sort

In post 2677, Prism wrote:2 is worth elaboration, which is that they might be chara hammersitting, but do any of us think lavender is hovering over the game just waiting for their chance here? or have they literally just been AFK for 100 pages?

if this is lavender's game im going to feel so stupid for not hammering when i had the chance

In post 2686, Krazy wrote:right now processing what I think of tanner's soft defense of hecboy and some other things

i've literally never voted for hectic this entire game and gut is telling me to nuke you for this

uuuuuughghghghhhhhh why is this game like this

what?

yesss towntisi finally hardtowntelling

<3

In post 2660, Tanner wrote:i'm reading prism's points on why hectic is scummy and like "this probably makes sense, prism knows what they're talking about"

hectic's push on me felt like scum knowing the pool is tight and they need to have some nice progressions so they're setting me up for a later day - the counterpoint to this is that i've thought this same thing about all of hectic/krazy/puppy/maybe ever taylor i don't remember

but hectic's points on why he doesn't hardbus there? i dunno? it vibes? at least not as not-chara?

i don't think i want to vote for hectic today?

it's unfair to call this a soft defense because why?

In post 2676, Morning Tweet wrote:

Prism wrote:prism's final readlist

town: puppy/krazy/tanner in that order
super town day 2 but depending on who the other is: pooky
??? pretty town but haven't read in eons: morning
spectating the game: lavender
probably scum by default: chara
scum: taylor, hectic

Prism wrote:tanner belongs in between morning/pooky actually but i have read him more recently

I can accept that readslist. I have Chara at the top though

oh, thanks, i missed that on the first read. prism, u should for sure have chara up higher than "default scum," that doesn't even make sense.

chara hasn't been around much the most recent part of the phase but this phase has gone on too long so that's understandable. but in the earlier past of the phase chara was v town and u are just self-wifom to death here

don't pretend u aren't doing a lot of wifom. u aren't shouting it out loud but i can see it in ur heart

In post 2692, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:yesss towntisi finally hardtowntelling

<3

ooh go on!

questionable progression by chara on tayl0r/beeboy is this btw

tl;dr of background posts is in reaction to tayl0r's catboi flop, chara goes: tayl0r +town-> actually this isn't good -> eh tayl0r +scum

882 says tayl0r is the closest thing they have to a scumread, ie. it either doesn't have any or it's tayl0r
906 activity votes beeboy (note: chara forgot but it was already voting beeboy)
948 justifies the vote with the readability line+not getting town feelings from ele/beeboy

i definitely asked them about this before, i'll see if i can fish up the answer from one of our ISOs

In post 2680, Tanner wrote:

In post 2668, CantHateAPuppy wrote:

In post 2663, Tanner wrote:

In post 2662, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:Why doesn't Hectic make sense as the Chara?

chara-hectic doesn't lolbus elements?

like that's genuinely as profound as my reads go right now

dont want to start second guessing reads this late in the phase

but this post just doesn't sit right w/ me RN. tanner, could u elaborate on this even a little? if not, can u explain what u don't like about the game that's making it hard to make a better read here?

this game is confusing. i have "The Townblocc" and then i have the confusing mess that is 4 people i thought/think are viable votes or that i would maybe vote. i'm grasping at straws, i don't know how to read hectic, i never did. fear is telling me he's tried to shitpush me multiple times, gut is telling me he's a townie. i don't know what else to tell you.

no, this is much better, thank u. glad i asked u for this.

Ok I'd be willing to go Hectic too. So Hectic/Lav/Tayl0r. I really don't think Hectic is Chara but he could very, very well be the other one.

I like Krazy and Tanner for small reasons but I guess I shouldn't completely dismiss the possibility one is scum. That's not what I'm leaning though

And everybody else I like lots

In post 2681, Prism wrote:chara absolutely does not deserve to be at the top,

their progression on taylor is extremely questionable

and their reads on me/hectic/tanner one notch below

beeboy revote+its followup was also sketchy given surrounding statements even if 95% of it lines up

i dont see how it's questionable and i dont' see how it's an important part of ur read on chara. aren't there more important points? chara hard bussed elements which u don't even seem to consider