Newbie 1365 - Vantasmagoria of Flower View (Game Over)

[Sakura Hana]

Lets lynch MM? I dont like nice people.

lol what a reason.

About MM, i already said my thoughts on her, you just didn't read them, as usual.

[Shawn]

Trying to distract attention from you, eh? My god, have we revealed the scum? On D1?

Sycorax, I did I will repeat them again for good measure:

That was the word I'm looking for. My apologies for confusing your gender.

Nekoko could be setting herself up to look scummy and get lynched. The other Mafia would hop on the BW, blending in and exterminating Town one by one. Just an idea of mine.

Everyone's job is to find and lynch scum. You asserting this does not relief you of suspicion. Above is an explanation of my view of you again, so maybe check that. If not: it is not what you seek, it's about how you seek it. You are trying to revolt this whole thing onto itself. That's just mean. When new information surfaces, I will vote. I just don't want to risk lynching a power role.

My suspicions have risen again: Why do you defend Neko?

In my defense, I posted this before Commandodude appeared and Shawn defended his friends oh so joyfully, so I really have no suspicion on you

Or i dont want to mislynch people cause they are stupid not scum. There is a difference you know .

[TheIrishPope]

It is most likely you are defending him as your scum partner.
How would you know of his supposed stupidity?
I am voting to lynch Shawn D2 if i survive Night.

[Shawn]

It is most likely you are defending him as your scum partner.
How would you know of his supposed stupidity?
I am voting to lynch Shawn D2 if i survive Night.

Stop stop stop making association cases without flips. Stop.

Where are all the ICs

[Sakura Hana]

Tell me why wouldn't we lynch someone that's playing anti-town?

[MontyWhittaker]

Sorry, I feel so overwhelmed right now. I haven't posted because I either haven't had anything to add or it's already been posted by someone. For what it's worth, with so many votes in this game already, I feel like The Irish Pope has "suspicions" that he is leading people to vote toward, yet feels no conviction to vote for them himself. That is enough to warrant my vote:

VOTE: TheIrishPope

So you appear out of nowhere and suddenly join a BW.

FoS: MontyWhittaker

I stated why I made my vote. I did not place it on someone who I felt did not deserve it, nor was I untrue in what I said. The simple fact of the matter is, unless we, as a group, decided that we wanted to No Lynch on this first day, we do have to choose someone to eliminate. I have to base my decision on the fact that TheIrishPope is sowing seeds of dissension, yet does not want to validate those concerns with a vote. I believe that he does not want a recorded vote that would pin him as scum later, which is why I am doing it now.

[TheIrishPope]

Only one IC bro. Why should an IC help you? You gave yourself away as scum. Logos is out.
How would an IC help you? By telling everyone "Guys, I have played more games, I know more"? Ethos is out.
With what would an IC help you? By saying "Guys, he's compassionate, don't vote for him"? Pathos is out.
The only thing left is mythos. Good luck with that.

According to my count, Commandodude is at L-1. Should we quickhammer or not? I'm not sure how to advance with this.
MontyWhittaker, I JUST VOTED.

[Shawn]

Only one IC bro. Why should an IC help you? You gave yourself away as scum. Logos is out.
How would an IC help you? By telling everyone "Guys, I have played more games, I know more"? Ethos is out.
With what would an IC help you? By saying "Guys, he's compassionate, don't vote for him"? Pathos is out.
The only thing left is mythos. Good luck with that.

According to my count, Commandodude is at L-1. Should we quickhammer or not? I'm not sure how to advance with this.
MontyWhittaker, I JUST VOTED.

Because this is bad play(lynching commando/calling me scum cause I defended him) and you guys dont believe me and will probably believe more experienced players right?

[Tierce]

Votecount 1.8

(3)

TheIrishPope

- Nekoko,

(sycorax,)

MontyWhittaker, Shawn
(3)

Commandodude

-

(Shawn,)

TheIrishPope, sycorax, Sakura Hana
(1)

Shawn

- Thor665,

(Sakura Hana)

(1)

Sakura Hana

- Commandodude

(1)

Not voting

- Ms Marangal,

(TheIrishPope)

Ms Marangal is V/LA until April 24.

With 9 alive, it takes 5 votes to lynch.
The deadline is May 4 at 10:35 PM PDT. Countdown to deadline: (expired on 2013-05-04 22:35:00)

[TheIrishPope]

Ethos is credibility. So no.
Explain why it is bad play to lynch someone who gave himself away as scummy.
And explain why it is bad play to lynch YOU, who defended him with such haste.

[Shawn]

Ethos is credibility. So no.
Explain why it is bad play to lynch someone who gave himself away as scummy.
And explain why it is bad play to lynch YOU, who defended him with such haste.

Because thats the worse reason ever.
'DUDE HARD DEFENDED THE MOST OBVIOUS SCUM EVER. LETS LYNCH HIM' No. Nooooooo.

I have never seen scum go, 'Im not reading the thread LALALALA'

[Sakura Hana]

Only one IC bro. Why should an IC help you? You gave yourself away as scum. Logos is out.
How would an IC help you? By telling everyone "Guys, I have played more games, I know more"? Ethos is out.
With what would an IC help you? By saying "Guys, he's compassionate, don't vote for him"? Pathos is out.
The only thing left is mythos. Good luck with that.

According to my count, Commandodude is at L-1. Should we quickhammer or not? I'm not sure how to advance with this.
MontyWhittaker, I JUST VOTED.

As far as i've read on other threads while i was waiting to get into a game, normally one person says intent to hammer and asks for a claim then we proceed from there.
Quickhammering is pretty much when you drop the hammer without doing this (from what i understand)

[TheIrishPope]

I'm done with this guy's nonsense.
Anyone else want to add something?

Sakura, my bad, Commando is at L-2 with Mod's post. Any thoughts on this?

[Sakura Hana]

I never said he was on L-1 in any case, i dont really have any thoughts, these 2 are just playing the most obvious anti-town play i have ever seen, they are very likely scum. Right now my reads are like this, from most town, to least.

Syco. (Most likely Town)
MM (Town)
Thor (Leaning Town)
Neko (Null)
Irish (Null)
Monty (Leaning Scum)
Shawn (Scum)
Commando Dude (Obvious Scum)

did i miss someone?

[Shawn]

I never said he was on L-1 in any case, i dont really have any thoughts, these 2 are just playing the most obvious anti-town play i have ever seen, they are very likely scum. Right now my reads are like this, from most town, to least.

Syco. (Most likely Town)
MM (Town)
Thor (Leaning Town)
Neko (Null)
Irish (Null)
Monty (Leaning Scum)
Shawn (Scum)
Commando Dude (Obvious Scum)

did i miss someone?

Anti-town doesnt = scum.

[Sakura Hana]

Oh my god you're right, it's totally not scum, he's obviously helping scum hunt and hides in the darkness! that's totally pro-town! I mean, pro-towns are obviously supposed to not discuss and not contribute to the thread, while they watch the scum who knows who the scum and town is attack each other! I would have never guessed!

[Shawn]

Oh my god you're right, it's totally not scum, he's obviously helping scum hunt and hides in the darkness! that's totally pro-town! I mean, pro-towns are obviously supposed to not discuss and not contribute to the thread, while they watch the scum who knows who the scum and town is attack each other! I would have never guessed!

Oh man maybe we should hold hands and sing songs together
What a great idea !!

Yeah no.

[TheIrishPope]

D1 Lynch: Commandodude
D2 Lynch: Shawn

[TheIrishPope]

Sakura, I pretty much have that same list, substituting you for me. I suspected Sycorax but he's good for now.

[Commandodude]

Now people apparently think I'm scum because I said I don't read all the posts?
Whaaaat?

[Shawn]

k im absolutely serious now.
THE IRISH DUDE is trying to bandwagon on to a weak townie, COMMANDODUDE.

And we should lynch him because he is basically echoing town sentiment in ALL OF HIS POSTS.
Guys/Girls.

Eradicate scum.
Kill IRISH DUDE with fire.

[Sakura Hana]

And why do you trust him so much with such a few posts that he has made?

[Shawn]

And why do you trust him so much with such a few posts that he has made?

Because scum doesnt post like that? Think, if you were in your first game as scum, what would you post like?

[TheIrishPope]

If you could talk in full sentences, that'd be great. My name is not Irish Dude. I am also absolutely serious.
I am using logos to lynch the most apparent scum, Commandodude. I see nothing wrong in that.
So, if I am acting town, I should be lynched? According to you, I express this sentiment in all of my posts. Please, go ahead and quote them all. I'll wait.
My motive is the same. I want to eradicate scum.
Could you elaborate further on your trust in Commandodude and your apparent knowledge of him being "a weak townie"? You can't know how scum posts like. Not every scum posts alike. Every scum has its own mind.

[Sakura Hana]

Yes irish, he already expressed in an earlier post that being town = being scum.