Mafiascum.net

VOTECOUNT 1.08

(0)

Aristophanes

—

(+4)

BROseidon

—

RadiantCowbells+Nahdia+Maestro, Aristophanes

(L-3)

(+2)

Clumsy

—

Errantparabola, Gammagooey

(0)

Errantparabola

—

(0)

Gammagooey

—

(0)

hiplop

—

(+1)

KuroiXHF

—

Spiffeh

(0)

Maestro

—

(0)

Nahdia

—

(+2)

Spiffeh

—

hiplop, BROseidon

(0)

RadiantCowbells

—

(0)

TheTrollie

—

(+3)

NOT VOTING

—

TheTrollie, Clumsy, KuroiXHF

With

12

alive

, it takes

7

to lynch

.

Deadline is in

(expired on 2016-04-18 00:30:00)

(Mon Apr 18 @ 12:30:00 AM EST)

.

NOTES

Awaiting prod response from TheTrollie.

catching up slowly

game started at a bad time for me I had just finished vla for work but now im actually limited access out of town but trying to stay in on my game(s)

in order for me to catch up im gonna just be reading like a few pages every time i can sit down with my phone in a waiting room/uber

as of Page 3

town: Clumsy (lets talk about this again later because a lot of you scumread clumsy for the same posts i am reading him/her (forgot to check) town) I don't think the posts come off as scum i think they come off as not really thiking)

Scum read on RC

null on Maestro and gamma though gamma leaning town.

will add to this next uber ride.

Everybody is null-reading me or doesn't know how to read me. My work here is done.

What more did you want, RC? Nothing and nobody's jumping out at me, and this is usually how I am until something or somebody jumps out at me.

Gonna post some short stuff here for now, probably get more into things tomorrow when I'm not falling asleep at my desk.

↑ Nahdia wrote:

↑ Clumsy wrote:

↑ RadiantCowbells wrote:Nahdia offered to claim but I asked her not to because we don't know who will end up in the thread.

Nothing from Maestro.

The way you say this implies that you trust the people that were currently in the thread at the time she offered to. Is this true?

it was literally just RC and i in the thread at the time lol.

Ah, okay, I didn't realize. Makes sense then.


Also, RC, what exactly is the case on me anyway? I'm just seeing a joke taken the wrong way early and then just riding that out.

↑ Gammagooey wrote:

Clumsy wrote:

↑ Gammagooey wrote:My only reads so far are a Clumsy scum read and gut town reads on Nahdia and Spiffeh. I'll maybe post a bit more after Clumsy responds, since pretty much everything else in the game seems more likely to be white noise than meaningfully readable imo.

Those three are the -only- reads you have so far? I'm not expecting everyone to be sorted, but that's it?

Yep!
I tend to think that most posts, espeeeeecially early game, are a lot more reflective of a player's personality than their alignment, and that trying to ascribe someone's alignment from posts that I can very, very easily see coming from that player as either alignment is more likely to introduce likely incorrect biases when trying to evaluate them later (when they've made plenty of additional posts and have said things that ARE more likely to be alignment relevant) than do anything useful.

Also, I do want you to answer my question to you in #115, though it's not a very kind one. Because to me it looks more likely to be a lazy effort to attack me for saying something that looks vaguely contradictory than a genuine desire to know why I did it, considering that even if we assume that you didn't leave it out intentionally to try to show that I was 'suspicious', it implies you weren't even paying enough attention to the post you're quoting to realize that the part you deleted was exactly what you asked for.

Eh, fair enough I suppose. Also, while I don't exactly appreciate the "stupid" comment, you are right. It was a reading comprehension fail. I thought it would be after the quote. And this is why I shouldn't be doing mafia when I'm tired. Like right now.

I'm currently getting a scum feeling from Spiffeh. And like an IC told me, gut feeling is usually unconsciously picking up on something in their posts. I'll look through and try to figure it out. Probably tomorrow. For now though, sleep.

↑ Maestro wrote:

↑ Aristophanes wrote:He knows damn well you can't quote PTs. I have never seen a game where you can. I dislike the posturing here.

It's not posturing, and I know normal site rules, dude. How many games of yours have I

modded

? not posturing at all, I'm asking to triple-duple-check

I know you know the rules, that's what's so damning. It's not like there's suddenly gonna be a ruleshift on that.

↑ RadiantCowbells wrote:147 is basically a scumclaim.

Could you elaborate, RC?

↑ hiplop wrote:I also think one of bro/spiff is scum

Leaning spiff? Idunno. Thinking on this big time

What makes Spiffy scummy Hippy?
I found his entry rather null.
You should vote Bro with me instead!

↑ RadiantCowbells wrote:I wouldn't townread Maestro if Broseidon weren't obvscum.

What makes these mutually exclusive?
I don't have a townread on either.

↑ KuroiXHF wrote:

↑ Spiffeh wrote:hm I kinda hate this mechanic

Look. I know you're unhappy with your oil change, but you should have known you'd be paying an arm and a leg if you're not going to do it yourself. (Happy to play with you again, Spiffeh! How are you!)

Hahaha!!!
As someone who deals with this on a daily basis, I found it hilarious! XD

↑ Gammagooey wrote:My only reads so far are a Clumsy scum read and gut town reads on Nahdia and Spiffeh. I'll maybe post a bit more after Clumsy responds, since pretty much everything else in the game seems more likely to be white noise than meaningfully readable imo.

So...why aren't you trying to sort anyone else then??
Like, I get only having a few solid reads at this point, but yours are mostly gut and it doesn't look like you'tr actually trying to sort anyone else. You haven't really asked anything or engaged anyone yet.
How do you expect to get reads without putting in any work!?

Kuribo's replacing out?? That sucks!
I really enjoyed his posts

↑ KuroiXHF wrote:

↑ RadiantCowbells wrote:VOTE: Pisskop

fucker can get out of this game.

That moment when three people voted someone who's not even playing this game.

That moment when Kuroi makes surface posts and doesn't engage the game...

↑ hiplop wrote:VOTE: gamma

@clums, spiffeh usually posts like that either way. yeh

Hippy, I don't think you've mentioned why Gamma is scummy yet.
It'd be nice if you would.

Shiiit! Modkills suck
Sorry to see you go man!
Also, this has to be the first time a Treestump hasn't made it to endgame...

↑ BROseidon wrote:hiplop y u vote gamma?

↑ Spiffeh wrote:

↑ Spiffeh wrote:hiplop I want to know why you are scum reading Maestro

↑ hiplop wrote:Gut read. Doesn't seem town honestly? Seems to be riding the tides

Answer received. And from the other posts I assume your Maestro read is gut..

And then you revote Spiff? What is making him scummy to you? Didn't you say his repsonses could be made as either alignment?

Caught up now.
Sorry about that mini-wall.

hippy likes to be wrong about me

nothing new really

I kinda think he's town now though

He doesn't push me as scum

I kind of liked you, Aristophanes, when you commented on my hilarious joke, but not when you accused me of not engaging the game. I've done that already.

BTW, Spiffeh. You're a businessman. I'm a businessman. How can we remove this vote on me? *pulls out checkbook*

Stop making me reconsider my position on you gdi

↑ Spiffeh wrote:hippy likes to be wrong about me

nothing new really

I kinda think he's town now though

He doesn't push me as scum

So him not being afraid to push you makes him town. Interesting.

What are your reads on Bro and Maestro?
They're my top two for scum atm.

Well it's more that he knows he can probably manipulate me as scum

↑ KuroiXHF wrote:I kind of liked you, Aristophanes, when you commented on my hilarious joke, but not when you accused me of not engaging the game. I've done that already.

BTW, Spiffeh. You're a businessman. I'm a businessman. How can we remove this vote on me? *pulls out checkbook*

I like you! You're funny!
But you have barely done anything engaging the game. That point stands.

↑ Spiffeh wrote:Well it's more that he knows he can probably manipulate me as scum

Gotcha!
I'm not gonna take this as rote, but it's a good jump-off point for reads for sure!
I know you two know each other's gameplay well, so the dichotomy is really odd.

Maestro's early aggression looked town to me

I'm scum reading BRO

↑ Spiffeh wrote:Well it's more that he knows he can probably manipulate me as scum

Oh come on. We're buddies. I got your back.

↑ Spiffeh wrote:Maestro's early aggression looked town to me

I'm scum reading BRO

What makes this town, not scum aggression?
And I really think his post asking if he could quote a PT is scummy.

We agree on Bro at least!

Alright, I am here.

clumsy continues to rub me the wrong way, looking at 40 but I think I'm more open to reconsidering?
I think Nahdia is town.
I also think that Maestro is town but that's a bit weaker.

↑ Clumsy wrote:Wait, did you guys actually think that was a serious proposition?

ehhhhh....

↑ RadiantCowbells wrote:Like the whole making a show of voting, unvoting because L-1, then jumping on this shiny new Nahdia vs Maestro fight just feels horrible and like scumbuddy-scumbuddy interaction.

Probabilities wise I don't think that Broseidon's L-1 unvote is town or scum, really.

I do want kuroi to explain maestro and hiplop reads. Actually, explain the broseidon read, too.
I think that gamma's reads are pretty legitimate. I also think that someone with just a few reads and being open about that fact is more likely to be town, but that really depends on how scum-gamma approaches the game, which I have no knowledge of.

spiffy asks for kuroi to explain reads, too. Kuroi doesn't respond. Just a thought. Spiffeh doesn't follow up? Am I missing something?
Okay I'm glad trollie is prbaobly town.
Aristo is very null.

what do you think of me ep

EP Kuroi did explain his reads eventually

I didn't really follow up on them because I kinda thought they were shitty

But I find him continuing to reach out to me pretty town

So I'm conflicted there

↑ Aristophanes wrote:I really think his post asking if he could quote a PT is scummy.

Except, actually, objectively, it's not

so try harder plz bitch

Ok but you can do things now

I'm kinda in this blah state with this game rn where I think people are scummy for one reason then they do something I think is really town later on and I'm just left there not knowing what to do

A lot of that's probably due to the lack of activity in general so hopefully I'll get some firmer reads soon

I am super confident that Nahdia and Ari are town though

↑ RadiantCowbells wrote:I don't want to centralize the discussion around my Broseidon read this early in the day.

This is really out of character for RC actually

I agree it's outside of my norm.

Don't you dare scumread me for it.