Newbie 1756: Balloon (Game Over)

[Transcend]

Just the tone of them. Basically the cherry on top to my sundae of a case on you (even though those posts were made first).

WARNING: If Charloux claims PR then don't treat it as him being confirmed town. Scum can fish power roles and draw them out to kill them. We as a town have to decide as a collective if we trust his claim or not.

Btw: no one asked you to claim, so I'm not sure why you're in a rush home boy.

[Transcend]

And accountant asked you a very good question that you've neglected to answer.

[Charloux]

Yo Doug, shut up and allow me to skip the next 2/3 days of torture, i have had enough. I claim Town Doctor.

[Charloux]

And accountant asked you a very good question that you've neglected to answer.

I didn't see a reason to defend somebody who jumped into the fire for me.

[Transcend]

I don't buy it.

How about you guys.

[Transcend]

Also a little protip:

If you are a bulletproof or a jailkeeper, it is impossible for there to be a doctor and you already know that Charloux is a lying scumfuck. If you're a doctor, then there can't be two doctors obviously. If you're cop or tracker, his claim might hold some weight.

[Accountant]

Yo Doug, shut up and allow me to skip the next 2/3 days of torture, i have had enough. I claim Town Doctor.

I buy this. Don't lynch. I repeat, do not lynch this.

[Accountant]

Transcend, I looked into his ISO to check for softs, and I see some stuff that I think points to Charloux being a PR. I do not think it's the sort of thing Charloux would fake as scum, especially as they didn't draw any attention to it during the claim.

[Transcend]

And you have a right to secrecy if you have a contradicting role to Charloux's claim.

[Transcend]

UNVOTE:

Charloux can you point out any crumbs/softs you made to legitimatize your claim?

[Accountant]

UNVOTE:

[Charloux]

I didn't write anything that would pin me to being a PR knowingly.

[Transcend]

Transcend, I looked into his ISO to check for softs, and I see some stuff that I think points to Charloux being a PR. I do not think it's the sort of thing Charloux would fake as scum, especially as they didn't draw any attention to it during the claim.

Point this out then because i don't see it.

[Accountant]

During the fight with me, Charloux emanated giant waves of "get the fuck off my back, don't ask why". At the time I thought it was defensiveness at best, scum panicking after getting caught at worst. But it also makes sense if he's a PR.

[Transcend]

Eh

I can see both alignments doing it

Outside of that, i see genuinely nothing that points to him being town.

[Charloux]

You just don't want to consider the possibility because that would damage your pride and self confidence.

[Transcend]

I won't put my vote on him for now, because i respect your opinion and i respect Charloux and wouldn't want him to get lol hammered especially as doctor, while I'm at work. I just wanna see what others think about his claim as well because there's a possibility someone contradicts his claim. Too early to make a call, imo.

[Transcend]

You just don't want to consider the possibility because that would damage your pride and self confidence.

Is me unvoting not considering a possibility?

This is a really bad post, homes.

[Accountant]

I don't know. It's really hard to fake as scum. I mean, here's what I think we should do. Everyone after this post, if you are not a jailkeeper or 1-shot bulletproof, say "I am not a JK or BP". If anyone claims JK or BP, we kill Charloux immediately. If nobody claims it, I'm not willing to lynch Charloux.

For Charloux to be scum, they'd have to be bad enough to slip up early game, good enough to fake a very hard to fake PR tell, subtle enough to not draw attention to it when pressed about softs, clever enough to predict that I'd see the soft and say that he's town, and lucky enough to win the 50/50 coinflip in fakeclaims. I think that probability is low enough that I don't want to lynch him, especially given the consequences if we're wrong.

[Transcend]

Ok Acc my vote is off for now, but if I'm right, I'm sure someone will contradict his claim.

[Charloux]

@Transcend:I don't really care how my posts sound right now. I'm dead by D2 anyway. Well, i'm in this game due to a mod error anyway.

[Transcend]

Well, i'm in this game due to a mod error anyway.

Wha

[Manuel87]

Transcend how can you not believe that claim?
There is only one scenario in which he doesnt get counterclaimed by another PR.
That scenario has 2 goons -> 4 possible scenarios with 2 goons.
Would be a pretty big gamble to claim that.

Unless he is counterclaimed he is almost conf town. If you

[Transcend]

Hold on

[Transcend]

There's several ways it can be a fish?

I don't get your point.