Mafiascum.net

S_S had 3 posts when Dunn made 147

but maybe that clears some stuff up

UNVOTE:

I'll think about it.

I believe that AJ legitimately missed S_S' posts up until then.

Not sure that makes him town, but we were definitely talking past each other.

So yeah none of that really makes a difference to me at least since 6/7 are just fluff/RVS and the 100 post thing is a prod dodge. Unless Dunn's going to claim there was something scummy there, there's really nothing more to it.

Like I guess that brings in disinterest (I was initially under the belief that he, like me, just didn't see the game thread open) but I'm not seeing anything there worth scumreading.

No, but it makes the discussion about whether or not it's a policy lynch something besides semantics, no?

Do we have to? Like now it brings up 'is lynching lurkers a policy lynch' if we're pursuing that but it's so far off the original point it's just not worth it.

I don't care to have a "what is a policy lynch" discussion, no.

I'm explaining what was going through my head when I condemned your dismissing of Dunn wanting to lynch S_S as not worth talking about at the time.

Like it makes a lot more sense if you thought he'd literally posted nothing instead of just posted things that were worthless in your opinion. The latter is worth talking about with Dunn or S_S, the former is not.

In post 181, Aj The Epic wrote:On the bright side, Dunn is town. This is like the first time I actually believe it too, but his actions around it show actual suspicion, something I don't see in scum games of his.

Since you did bring up why you think Dunn is "being stupid instead of scummy": talk to me about your town read here because I feel like you decided really definitively on this early with only the vaguest of explanations.

And since you brought up meta I need to see the counterexamples you used to get to this.

Votecount 1.8

Aj The Epic

(2) - Seiko x Naomi, The Oxford Bubbles

Syryana

(1) - Shadow_step

Not Voting

(6) - Dunnstral, Obvious Alt, Aj The Epic, Charloux, Syryana, borkjerfkin

With

9

players eligible to vote, it’s

5

to lynch!

Day 1 will end in

(expired on 2017-01-26 06:01:00).

Mod Notes:

Charloux is V/LA until the 19th of January.

Will search for a replacement for Obvious Alt in the morning (my time).

In post 283, borkjerfkin wrote:

In post 181, Aj The Epic wrote:On the bright side, Dunn is town. This is like the first time I actually believe it too, but his actions around it show actual suspicion, something I don't see in scum games of his.

Since you did bring up why you think Dunn is "being stupid instead of scummy": talk to me about your town read here because I feel like you decided really definitively on this early with only the vaguest of explanations.

And since you brought up meta I need to see the counterexamples you used to get to this.

So the main counterexample I have is Nhadia's Trial of the Evoker http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=23&t=69209 Dunn's ISO is a literal metric fluffton of posts that don't really have a suspicion behind it early on.

To note scum team in this game is Dunn/Pisskop/BATORU.

It's just a serious difference to see Dunn A.) More reserved and B.) much more questioning/prodding.



Like honestly if I had played with Dunn before Trials I think it would've been so painfully obvious. Bygones though, I wouldn't have caught pisskop ever.

In post 268, Aj The Epic wrote:Jesus. You'd think I've played this game enough to not buddy a partner in such a stupid way.

This might be a perspective slip. Town really has no reason to say this, I would just be wrong because he is town

Aj that meta you brought up - did you look at that to figure I was town early in this game? I think that's what you're saying

In post 287, Dunnstral wrote:Aj that meta you brought up - did you look at that to figure I was town early in this game? I think that's what you're saying

Did I use your posting Trials to help with my read here? Yes.

I'll be back tomorrow.

In post 290, Foxbird wrote:EDIT: Player has returned and may resume posting.

Youve gotta be kidding me

2 posts in goddamn however long even though theyve gone over double prod length without posting and they get to stay

In post 286, borkjerfkin wrote:

In post 268, Aj The Epic wrote:Jesus. You'd think I've played this game enough to not buddy a partner in such a stupid way.

This might be a perspective slip. Town really has no reason to say this, I would just be wrong because he is town

i thought about this overnight and dont feel as strongly about it

Did obvious alt pm the mod in order to avoid posting in thread?

Wait

he posted in scum pt lolololol

really though I think it's worth lynching obvious alt from that

In post 295, Dunnstral wrote:Wait

he posted in scum pt lolololol

Replied to prod pm? That is what i would have done

Actually id have just fucking posted in the thread

If the mod is counting "posting in any thread" as activity then you have a point

Dont know how to verify