Mafiascum.net

In post 263, Randomnamechange wrote:why mafia's push on you was solid. i havent played with him before.

Oh? Fair enough.
WhyMafia is going to be Scum. I can lynch there.

In post 265, GuyInFreezer wrote:Chikadee replaces kingmaker.
2 days added to deadline.

Oh, great...

Wait I know who you are

In post 277, RadiantCowbells wrote:Wait I know who you are

Prefer for you not to say.

rando starts feeling off.
I like 1SVT actually. Don't get why people are voting him. Please explain better.

I'd sheep RC but jj is actually able to be obvtown so I'm not going to.

I'd lynch Tarkus or rando right now.

In post 274, Nazeebo wrote:

In post 168, Randomnamechange wrote:

In post 159, WhyMafia wrote:Why are you interested in pushing a claimed vigilante?

In post 160, WhyMafia wrote:Gut scum reading randomidget

Interesting transition

In post 162, Nazeebo wrote:

In post 145, Randomnamechange wrote:

In post 143, Nazeebo wrote:

In post 37, Randomnamechange wrote:then i dont rly think anything can be read so far.
so far im townreading lucky and kingmaker and scumreading tucker.
VOTE: tucker

want to explain these? I got nothing up till now.

Edit: okay I got lucky and king from reading newer posts. Why did you originally scumread tucker though?

I didn't like his reaction to Lucky's vote. felt like they were worried pressure there would dissolve and wanted to keep it up. combined with a lucky townread this makes me think they were trying to avoid attention falling onto their team.

you mean Lucky voting RC? I'm confused

I meant joke not vote sorry

didn't lucky's joke happen after Tucker's vote?
Sorry this is really old but I do think it's an interesting fact.

yeah it did. tucker then continued to push lucky which is what i was talking about.

In post 279, Nazeebo wrote:I like 1SVT actually. Don't get why people are voting him. Please explain better.

I already did. Explain why you like 1SVT

I was getting scum vibes on read through from Tucker, but not really from WhyMafia. Could still be a scum slot though.

I'm not really understanding the SRs on Random. He's solidly in my town pile.

RC is in my town leans.

Scum Leaning beeboy.

I need to go back and look at the whole miller thing again.


I suppose I could go for a Why lynch today. Conflicted since one of my scum leans, and one of my town reads are currently voting there. I'm more confident in my town read on Random though. And I was scum reading the general slot.
VOTE: WhyMafia

In post 280, Randomnamechange wrote:

In post 274, Nazeebo wrote:

In post 168, Randomnamechange wrote:

In post 159, WhyMafia wrote:Why are you interested in pushing a claimed vigilante?

In post 160, WhyMafia wrote:Gut scum reading randomidget

Interesting transition

In post 162, Nazeebo wrote:

In post 145, Randomnamechange wrote:

In post 143, Nazeebo wrote:

In post 37, Randomnamechange wrote:then i dont rly think anything can be read so far.
so far im townreading lucky and kingmaker and scumreading tucker.
VOTE: tucker

want to explain these? I got nothing up till now.

Edit: okay I got lucky and king from reading newer posts. Why did you originally scumread tucker though?

I didn't like his reaction to Lucky's vote. felt like they were worried pressure there would dissolve and wanted to keep it up. combined with a lucky townread this makes me think they were trying to avoid attention falling onto their team.

you mean Lucky voting RC? I'm confused

I meant joke not vote sorry

didn't lucky's joke happen after Tucker's vote?
Sorry this is really old but I do think it's an interesting fact.

yeah it did. tucker then continued to push lucky which is what i was talking about.

this is probably the point where I think you made a mistake and tunnel you for the rest of the game because town never makes mistakes and you end up flipping town because town makes mistakes all the time and I feel terrible.
So I'm going to leave it at that.

Deadline: (expired on 2017-08-26 21:02:02)

VC 1.06

Nazeebo
beeboy, Chickadee
Lucky2u, esires, iDanyBoy
TwoInAMillion, 1 Shot Vanilla Town
randomidget
RadiantCowbells
WhyMafia

Not Voting: Tarkus, CookieDotJay

With votes, to lynch

In post 281, WhyMafia wrote:

In post 279, Nazeebo wrote:I like 1SVT actually. Don't get why people are voting him. Please explain better.

I already did. Explain why you like 1SVT

what's not to like? He's pushing what needs to be pushed.
Sorry I don't share your gutread. Unless I missed any of your reasoning?

In post 282, Chickadee wrote:I was getting scum vibes on read through from Tucker, but not really from WhyMafia. Could still be a scum slot though.

I'm not really understanding the SRs on Random. He's solidly in my town pile.

RC is in my town leans.

Scum Leaning beeboy.

I need to go back and look at the whole miller thing again.


I suppose I could go for a Why lynch today. Conflicted since one of my scum leans, and one of my town reads are currently voting there. I'm more confident in my town read on Random though. And I was scum reading the general slot.
VOTE: WhyMafia

If you're not getting Scum vibes from WhyMafia why could he still be Scum? That's like saying anyone could be Scum, it doesn't warrant a vote.
Voting there because a town lean is, isn't a valid reason.

In post 286, 1 Shot Vanilla Town wrote:

In post 282, Chickadee wrote:I was getting scum vibes on read through from Tucker, but not really from WhyMafia. Could still be a scum slot though.

I'm not really understanding the SRs on Random. He's solidly in my town pile.

RC is in my town leans.

Scum Leaning beeboy.

I need to go back and look at the whole miller thing again.


I suppose I could go for a Why lynch today. Conflicted since one of my scum leans, and one of my town reads are currently voting there. I'm more confident in my town read on Random though. And I was scum reading the general slot.
VOTE: WhyMafia

If you're not getting Scum vibes from WhyMafia why could he still be Scum? That's like saying anyone could be Scum, it doesn't warrant a vote.
Voting there because a town lean is, isn't a valid reason.

I was scum reading Tucker though. So I really don't think the vote is all that bad.

What was scummy about it?
WhyMafia isn't Tucker. If WhyMafia isn't looking scummy to You, why could it not be that Tucker is just a scummy looking player?

You need to review both the Miller claims.
We should not be going into day 2 with 2 Miller claims.

Yea, it's on my list of things to do.

But saying Tucker could just be a scummy player, why could the flip also not be true? WhyMafia could just be playing a good scum game. I'm looking at that slot as a whole. However I do agree that Why should hold more weight, since they're in that slot.

For now my vote is going to stay though.

, I don't like Tarkus either but for different reasons. First thing he does when TIAM claims miller is votes him but then in Post 94 he doesn't think TIAM's should be that confident in his vote.

, Can you explain what puts randomidget in the town pile. Would also appreciate if you could explain your scum read on tuckers and subsequent town read on WhyMafia. I agree with you on RC as a slight town lean for his Post 36.

, Why can't we go into day two with two miller claims?

In post 290, iDanyboy wrote:@1SVT, Why can't we go into day two with two miller claims?

If town ignore it day 1, they will ignore it day 2... Then we get that much closer to a situation of dealing with them late game.
Miller won't be a scum night kill.

The only other options I'll consider is Tarkus shoots the other.
But so many false reasons can be given against that.

Let's deal with it Day 2?

In post 292, iDanyboy wrote:Let's deal with it Day 2?

So you don't even think that 1 Miller claim should shoot the other if we ignore it today?

Can we Lynch the unholy fuck out of chickadee if we aren't doing jjh

VOTE: chickadee
feel like they are WKing me here and looking for a buddy on rc. expressing suspicion on tucker but then TRing WM is an easy way to look like you have scumreads without making enemies.

Ok but if there's a vig or even a fucking so they shoot jjh a

In post 293, 1 Shot Vanilla Town wrote:So you don't even think that 1 Miller claim should shoot the other if we ignore it today?

I think there's better people to shoot than TIAM.

In post 297, iDanyboy wrote:

In post 293, 1 Shot Vanilla Town wrote:So you don't even think that 1 Miller claim should shoot the other if we ignore it today?

I think there's better people to shoot than TIAM.

Given their claims, I think you're wrong here.
Killing the Miller takes out a potential fake claim and prevents potentially killing a PR.

In post 290, iDanyboy wrote:

@Chickadee

, Can you explain what puts randomidget in the town pile. Would also appreciate if you could explain your scum read on tuckers and subsequent town read on WhyMafia. I agree with you on RC as a slight town lean for his Post 36.

Reading through, I feel like Random gave good insights, and was looking at everything. I don't agree with everything they've said, but overall I'm reading them town. I really like:

I know some of that is RVS/NAI but I'm a gut player, and this are what are standing out to me. Also He had a good reaction earlier when someone voted him. Really read town.

And just to be clear, I don't have a town read on WhyMafia. I had one on Tuckers, I just don't have one. Absence of a scum read does not equal a town read. As for my scum read on Tucker, they just said a few things that were off to me. A lot of their posting sounded forced. It might have been the newsy gimmick (YES, I KNOW GIMMICKS ARE NAI), but it just didn't sit right with me.

In post 294, RadiantCowbells wrote:Can we Lynch the unholy fuck out of chickadee if we aren't doing jjh

RC it makes me sad you always scum read me. And that you haven't learned your lesson yet.