Posted: Fri Jun 08, 2018 5:03 pm
It feels good to know that I was right about 123 being scum lol
Um...errr.... for why?
What do you think a no lynch will accomplish, Smart?
It seems pretty straight forward to me. Penguin told 123 that he should use his vig shot on Firebringer or something smart because 123 wasn't sure about them. 123 knew that he wasn't actually the vig and couldn't carry out the shot. He also knew that the real big would probably kill him. So he died and tried to take out the IC at the same time. The Mafia got lucky because they ended out taking out the real big. Or maybe they suspected Firebringer was the real vig. Since 123 was pushing something smart and 123 flipped scum, the natural conclusion is that something_smart is probably town. But I think he should still be in the lynch pool because there's the possibility that 123 was bussing him and knew his suicide bombing would erase any suspicion we had for SS. These are all the reasons I can come up with for itIn post 281, TheRampage wrote:Yeah, I can go with Vulcan. I thought I had a scum read on him earlier but backed off. Before we lynch though,I think we need to discuss why the suicide bombing this early in the game.It seems to be a premature move, especially since no one suspected 123 enough to lynch him. I know if I was bomber, I would have held out til I was L1. So there has to be some reason as to why the mafia decided to do it early. I feel we need to discuss this in the case we are wrong about Vulcan.
VOTE: Vulcan
Okay, that makes pretty good sense. Alright, so if we are wrong, which a few of us are feeling we won't be, we will be 3 to 1 tomorrow day phase. Where does everyone think we need to look in the case that we are wrong about this lynch? Because we can't be wrong again if we are wrong right now. Actually guys, looking at this now, I think I see the benefit behind SS wanting to no lynch. If we force the mafia to make their kill tonight, we get 2 more days of trying to investigate and hunt down the scum. if we are wrong right now, we only get one more day. Cause we mislynch at 3 to 1, then mafia NKs and we lose at 1 to 1BlackStar wrote:It seems pretty straight forward to me. Penguin told 123 that he should use his vig shot on Firebringer or something smart because 123 wasn't sure about them. 123 knew that he wasn't actually the vig and couldn't carry out the shot. He also knew that the real big would probably kill him. So he died and tried to take out the IC at the same time. The Mafia got lucky because they ended out taking out the real big. Or maybe they suspected Firebringer was the real vig. Since 123 was pushing something smart and 123 flipped scum, the natural conclusion is that something_smart is probably town. But I think he should still be in the lynch pool because there's the possibility that 123 was bussing him and knew his suicide bombing would erase any suspicion we had for SS. These are all the reasons I can come up with for itIn post 281, TheRampage wrote:Yeah, I can go with Vulcan. I thought I had a scum read on him earlier but backed off. Before we lynch though,I think we need to discuss why the suicide bombing this early in the game.It seems to be a premature move, especially since no one suspected 123 enough to lynch him. I know if I was bomber, I would have held out til I was L1. So there has to be some reason as to why the mafia decided to do it early. I feel we need to discuss this in the case we are wrong about Vulcan.
VOTE: Vulcan
VOTE: Something Smart
If we want to get to 3p LYLO, which has the fewest scum possibilities, we need to NL at some point. Better to do it now so that scum have the least information about who the IC is (and about people's reads) when they make their free kill.
I agree with with Smart's assessment here. Look at the gamestate. There is no clear obv-town at the moment. WeIn post 293, Something_Smart wrote:If we want to get to 3p LYLO, which has the fewest scum possibilities, we need to NL at some point. Better to do it now so that scum have the least information about who the IC is (and about people's reads) when they make their free kill.
But you townread him all day. Awfully convenient that you change your tune right before boom-boom time. Plus, this post raises an eyebrow. For real. It's awkward. Whether it's awkward town or awkward scum, I can't really say right now.In post 275, BlackStar wrote:It feels good to know that I was right about 123 being scum lol
Could you do me a couple favors?In post 281, TheRampage wrote:Yeah, I can go with Vulcan. I thought I had a scum read on him earlier but backed off. Before we lynch though, I think we need to discuss why the suicide bombing this early in the game. It seems to be a premature move, especially since no one suspected 123 enough to lynch him. I know if I was bomber, I would have held out til I was L1. So there has to be some reason as to why the mafia decided to do it early. I feel we need to discuss this in the case we are wrong about Vulcan.
VOTE: Vulcan
So, I was wrong about Firebringer. So the fuck what! Dude, Firebringer was scum in a game that I recently played with him. He fakeclaimed cop. Me and another player bought it hook, line, and sinker, but due to some unlucky PoE flips, it was revealed that his claim was bogus. It took some cajones to do what Firebringer did that game, and if it weren't for the flip, none of us would have known. It was a brilliant scum move that was so ballsy it almost put him above suspicion. Being endowed with the special knowledge that Fire is capable of such gambits, I saw it as my towny obligation to be vigilant about Fire's possible fakeclaim to ensure that town wasn't duped in this game.In post 290, BlackStar wrote:It's more likely that Vulcan is his partner though because they never really made any efforts to sort each other and their interactions don't feel right. Plus Vulcan really wanted Firebringer dead and voted with 123 on the SS wagon
I stopped town reading him over a day before he blew up. How is that "right before"? And I don't understand how that post is awkward. It feels like you're just desperate to cast shade because there's a lot of heat on you right nowIn post 295, vulcan logician wrote:But you townread him all day. Awfully convenient that you change your tune right before boom-boom time. Plus, this post raises an eyebrow. For real. It's awkward. Whether it's awkward town or awkward scum, I can't really say right now.In post 275, BlackStar wrote:It feels good to know that I was right about 123 being scum lol