Just replaced in for unwnd, read over some of the day 1 stuff with the Execution Chair+associated shenanigans before I asked to be put on the replacement list before but very little else so far
can you take a look at the opposite team/glance at them to see who you do or dont like?
Posted: Sun Oct 17, 2021 9:40 am
by Ydrasse
In post 275, SirCakez wrote:god this mechanic has totally killed my WIM for this game
Just replaced in for unwnd, read over some of the day 1 stuff with the Execution Chair+associated shenanigans before I asked to be put on the replacement list before but very little else so far
can you take a look at the opposite team/glance at them to see who you do or dont like?
yeah, prob won't be reading over exclusively other team but since we're nomming one of them I won't exactly do deep dives onto people in here until I'm fully caught up or this phase/event/etc is over
Posted: Sun Oct 17, 2021 9:43 am
by Morning Tweet
Posted: Sun Oct 17, 2021 10:40 am
by Gammagooey
i have decided after reading the first 23ish pages that I like Prism (who is Gypyx now) and Dwlee for town so far and that skitter gets my mmmmMMmmm of the day award
ulyana looks fine so far and that seems worth mentioning since it seems like the vague consensus of Team Blue is that she's scummy but also looking ahead she doesn't place her first vote until like page 40 something so eh
VOTE: skitter for now, if anyone has an opinion on Taly they'd like to share since they were my predecessor's vote I'd like to hear it though
Posted: Sun Oct 17, 2021 10:45 am
by Gamma Emerald
yissss
idr if I've had a completed game with gammagooey, I'm real hype ngl
also, my fetters are finally undone, so I can finally talk about this. I feel like the way unwnd's replace in kinda got treated was somewhat similar to what happened when Titus replaced in for Toogeloo in Isekai UPick. In both scenarios it seemed like there was a certain refusal to re-consider the slot's position, and the player themselves wasn't really helping either. As such I'm probably adding Gammagooey to the [True Townblock]
Her conviction on what she believes like the Toog-unwnd-Gamma-Infinity hammer theory feels contestanty, that's about it.
Posted: Sun Oct 17, 2021 1:22 pm
by Saber
In post 280, Gammagooey wrote:i have decided after reading the first 23ish pages that I like Prism (who is Gypyx now) and Dwlee for town so far and that skitter gets my mmmmMMmmm of the day award
ulyana looks fine so far and that seems worth mentioning since it seems like the vague consensus of Team Blue is that she's scummy but also looking ahead she doesn't place her first vote until like page 40 something so eh
VOTE: skitter for now, if anyone has an opinion on Taly they'd like to share since they were my predecessor's vote I'd like to hear it though
Hiya, very interested to hear your thoughts on myself, do you agree with your predecessor's opinion?
skitter's felt like a contestant to me, seemed like she's been pushing out unfiltered thoughts and whatever's on her mind. She also apparently had decent interactions with Dunnstral though I haven't verified this myself.
Her conviction on what she believes like the Toog-unwnd-Gamma-Infinity hammer theory feels contestanty, that's about it.
Actually, this is probably not very valid if no one actually agrees with or sees the theory though, she could just be finding something useful looking to do as a stagehand.
Infinity>ulyana>Toogeloo is where I'm at now.
Posted: Sun Oct 17, 2021 1:45 pm
by Gammagooey
In post 281, Gamma Emerald wrote:yissss
idr if I've had a completed game with gammagooey, I'm real hype ngl
also, my fetters are finally undone, so I can finally talk about this. I feel like the way unwnd's replace in kinda got treated was somewhat similar to what happened when Titus replaced in for Toogeloo in Isekai UPick. In both scenarios it seemed like there was a certain refusal to re-consider the slot's position, and the player themselves wasn't really helping either. As such I'm probably adding Gammagooey to the [True Townblock]
We've played together but it's been a while - I was scum in TAZ mafia and made myself obvscum day 2 to daykill Varsoon and prevent a guilty on NSG, and we were in Team Mafia 2020 together but I think we were in different games
In post 280, Gammagooey wrote:i have decided after reading the first 23ish pages that I like Prism (who is Gypyx now) and Dwlee for town so far and that skitter gets my mmmmMMmmm of the day award
ulyana looks fine so far and that seems worth mentioning since it seems like the vague consensus of Team Blue is that she's scummy but also looking ahead she doesn't place her first vote until like page 40 something so eh
VOTE: skitter for now, if anyone has an opinion on Taly they'd like to share since they were my predecessor's vote I'd like to hear it though
Hiya, very interested to hear your thoughts on myself, do you agree with your predecessor's opinion?
skitter's felt like a contestant to me, seemed like she's been pushing out unfiltered thoughts and whatever's on her mind. She also apparently had decent interactions with Dunnstral though I haven't verified this myself.
I commented on Taly earlier if you ISO me.
I don't even know what my predecessor's opinion of you is yet. I'll check your iso in a bit for taly-opinion
I didn't particularly like your posts up to page 25 but the things that bugged me so far seemed more 'I feel like this playstyle might annoy me a bit' than 'this is more likely to come from scum' (no offense meant and don't feel the need to change if you don't feel like it, I'm just the mafia equivalent of an old man whose leg hurts when it rains except its for when people act certain ways in earlygame)
My dinner's almost ready so I'll read a bit while I eat, then walk dog and then come back and read a bit more
Posted: Sun Oct 17, 2021 3:02 pm
by Gammagooey
also what is wim I keep seeing people say it and I don't know what it means (energy??)
Posted: Sun Oct 17, 2021 3:03 pm
by Gamma Emerald
Want it more
It’s like a measure of how much you care about the game
Posted: Sun Oct 17, 2021 3:34 pm
by Gammagooey
I'm at page 50, kinda confused by the switching at this point from Gamma Emerald to my predecessor - there was a mini-wagon on Dunn that seemed like it got completely derailed by skitter posting like 15 times in a row about Galrond? I wish I could ask her what she thought of Dunn at the time, she asked Gamma Emerald why he was voting Dunn over Ceph but like Dunn doesn't feel like he did anything town-worthy at that point in the game yet
ulyana has some weird posts with 'Gamma Emerald is doing this to have a reason to kill me if it's kingmaker'. her iso looks like she ramps up a bit in posting soon though so hopefully that'll be readable
Posted: Sun Oct 17, 2021 3:50 pm
by Gamma Emerald
In post 288, Gammagooey wrote:I'm at page 50, kinda confused by the switching at this point from Gamma Emerald to my predecessor - there was a mini-wagon on Dunn that seemed like it got completely derailed by skitter posting like 15 times in a row about Galrond? I wish I could ask her what she thought of Dunn at the time, she asked Gamma Emerald why he was voting Dunn over Ceph but like Dunn doesn't feel like he did anything town-worthy at that point in the game yet
this is something I wasn't entirely conscious of, can you post some quotes?
also, wrt Infinity, I'm kinda pulling the same card I used to pull when reading MariaR. That is, we are so familiar with each other that we can read each other based on how the other reads us, or at least I can read infinity based on how she reads me. Her progression on me makes perfect sense as town, and the best-fit agenda I can see for if she were scum is trying to pocket me, in which case her concern about TRing me for things scum!me can do feels out of place, and the Prism/Gypyx progression seems a bit wacky for that too. It took her quite some time after shifting back to TRing me to go after Gypyx. While I don't think the Gypyx push is entirely well-founded I think it's probably a towntell how she came to it. Town are generally more likely to have that sort of natural "I let this go and still think there's something here, I'm gonna pick it up again" attitude.
In post 288, Gammagooey wrote:I'm at page 50, kinda confused by the switching at this point from Gamma Emerald to my predecessor - there was a mini-wagon on Dunn that seemed like it got completely derailed by skitter posting like 15 times in a row about Galrond? I wish I could ask her what she thought of Dunn at the time, she asked Gamma Emerald why he was voting Dunn over Ceph but like Dunn doesn't feel like he did anything town-worthy at that point in the game yet
this is something I wasn't entirely conscious of, can you post some quotes?
just reread page 49 & 50
context is Dwlee wanted to vote someone on his list (I think instead of voting you since you were the main wagon), you chose Dunn, and then skitter takes up the majority of page 50
Gamma Emerald wrote:Also I feel like Dunnstral being like this tends to be a scumtell
He also scumtold by reacting to my Ulyana push way too fast
it took forever and a week for the game to finish but a big point to my dunn read was his play here felt like how he played D2 in isekai upick, basically textbook frozen scum
Posted: Sun Oct 17, 2021 4:39 pm
by petapan
referencing that was part of why i changed my mind but not as simple as quiet/not quiet
turns out i was lazy today and didn't want to reread
Posted: Sun Oct 17, 2021 4:51 pm
by Gammagooey
In post 294, Gamma Emerald wrote:p sure that's a joke from taly jsyk
also D1 ends at page 70 so that's prolly a solid stopping point
yeah duh its a good joke Taly's avatar is a very large nosed bird and I appreciate it
at page 70 but I'm gonna skip over your thoughts on before choosing an execution for the most part since my opinion on you largely doesn't matter until this part of the event ends
also for some reason I had it in my head that you shot Toog first before the sabotage and not Galron from my skim before replacing in? huh
I still don't feel like I have any particularly strong scum reads - skitter's still my strongest choice but I'm probably biasing myself against her at least a little because I know she's a strong scum player? aside from that my gut says Ydrasse feels a little scummy and I at least wouldn't be surprised if one of Ulyana/Toog were scum? meh
more tomorrowwww
Posted: Sun Oct 17, 2021 5:00 pm
by Gammagooey
oh uh also deadline for choosing is 3 days and 2 hours or so from this post
so I guess I'll see if I can read the entire other half of the game tomorrow so I can know what I want to fight for in the last 48 hours. but also in exchange I would like other people to rekindle some PASSION for who they want dead so like at least find someone to vote by tomorrow so we have a couple wagons with more than one vote on them plz friends
Posted: Sun Oct 17, 2021 5:40 pm
by Gamma Emerald
I feel more passionate about who I DON'T want dead which is kinda a double-edged sword for me
