Mafiascum.net

In post 2749, Mistyx wrote:for my intents and purposes that's the same thing

so what is so weird about that? are reads not allowed to change?

In post 2750, Something_Smart wrote:

In post 2749, Mistyx wrote:for my intents and purposes that's the same thing

so what is so weird about that? are reads not allowed to change?

no but if your reads change in a way that aligns with a fairly plausible scum agenda without explanation i am going to put pressure on it

In fact I feel like a distinct feature of my scumgame is to have extremely static reads and to cling to early townreads on LHF slots so I can cash in on towncred when they start getting pushed.

If I were really just looking to take the path of least resistance, I could be pushing T3 here. (Even if he's scum-- honestly even more so in that case.)

wdym without explanation, I explained it in 2416

In post 2751, Mistyx wrote:no but if your reads change in a way that aligns with a fairly plausible scum agenda without explanation i am going to put pressure on it

so you were lying about think I'm likely scum? or what?

In post 2754, Something_Smart wrote:

In post 2751, Mistyx wrote:no but if your reads change in a way that aligns with a fairly plausible scum agenda without explanation i am going to put pressure on it

so you were lying about think I'm likely scum? or what?

no but likely scum is not guaranteed scum i'm not going to deathtunnel you over this

In post 2753, Something_Smart wrote:wdym without explanation, I explained it in 2416

i don't want to shut you down with "this doesn't sound convincing" but that was my first thought

why did you initially list him as town then?

headed to class now

idk where this is going

i just don’t think I’ve seen anyone talk about ss this hame

also like, I think I pretty demonstrably was not townreading Kitty at any point, I defended him a lot without actually giving any reason why I thought he was towny, because I didn't. I'm sure you understand the context of that list, which is just to pick one or the other on every person, which is of course going to be completely arbitrary if I don't have much of a read on them.

I believe I wrote town primarily because I didn't like the push on him. My read on him went from null to scum, which I mean, sure you can call it potentially a scum agenda, but you can equally say that about anyone else pushing him.

In post 2756, Mistyx wrote:i don't want to shut you down with "this doesn't sound convincing" but that was my first thought

oh for sure, I would not expect it to be convincing. but the question is, do you believe that I could believe it? not necessarily as a deathtunnel or anything, just as something that feels worth pushing.

S_S is very hard to talk about.

also, I have 117 posts in the hood. so even if I'm flying a bit under the radar here (I'm trying not to, but I was out of town for a while around the end of D1 and the beginning of D2), I'm certainly not doing it there.

and I am on record as being terrified of hoods with strong solvers as scum, I can go find the game that comes to mind. Ali modded it.

In post 2758, Something_Smart wrote:

In post 2756, Mistyx wrote:i don't want to shut you down with "this doesn't sound convincing" but that was my first thought

oh for sure, I would not expect it to be convincing. but the question is, do you believe that I could believe it? not necessarily as a deathtunnel or anything, just as something that feels worth pushing.

I do

I still think it’s more likely that you would fake believing it as scum than believe it as town in the context of this game

But that’s not a very confident read

In post 2732, Val89 wrote:The thing I realised that wasn't clear is why Norwee is interested in hashing out my read on Alisae, and not Alisae's read on me; which unless I missed something, was still a scumread and would preclude us being a TRing happy clan together anyway. I also want to go over the games I've been given in case I am mistaken and the similarities are NAI for Alisae, so I'll flesh this out properly once I have answers there.

I GUESS NORWEE COULD BE MORE RELUCTANT TO CHALLENGE ALISAE BECAUSE OF THEIR ANGST, SO THEY ARE FOCUSING ON YOU? I'M NOT SURE.

In post 2762, SCRRRDBEAR wrote:

In post 2732, Val89 wrote:The thing I realised that wasn't clear is why Norwee is interested in hashing out my read on Alisae, and not Alisae's read on me; which unless I missed something, was still a scumread and would preclude us being a TRing happy clan together anyway. I also want to go over the games I've been given in case I am mistaken and the similarities are NAI for Alisae, so I'll flesh this out properly once I have answers there.

I GUESS NORWEE COULD BE MORE RELUCTANT TO CHALLENGE ALISAE BECAUSE OF THEIR ANGST, SO THEY ARE FOCUSING ON YOU? I'M NOT SURE.

IT DOES SOUND IMBALANCED AFAIK.

In post 2763, SCRRRDBEAR wrote:

In post 2762, SCRRRDBEAR wrote:

In post 2732, Val89 wrote:The thing I realised that wasn't clear is why Norwee is interested in hashing out my read on Alisae, and not Alisae's read on me; which unless I missed something, was still a scumread and would preclude us being a TRing happy clan together anyway. I also want to go over the games I've been given in case I am mistaken and the similarities are NAI for Alisae, so I'll flesh this out properly once I have answers there.

I GUESS NORWEE COULD BE MORE RELUCTANT TO CHALLENGE ALISAE BECAUSE OF THEIR ANGST, SO THEY ARE FOCUSING ON YOU? I'M NOT SURE.

IT DOES SOUND IMBALANCED AFAIK.

WHAT ABOUT NORWEE'S CLAIM THAT THEY ARE THE ONLY ONE SORTING TITUS?

I wouldn’t say i was the only one sorting Titus like all other players in our hood had given it no thought. But i tried to ask questions and exactly the same theories as was said earlier about them potentially being a scum that could select hood to spy in and etc.

Titus didn’t want to share why exactly they selected our hood though so they are honest about still not sharing their true motivations.

VOTE: fireisredsir

I no longer think mistyx is scum

In post 2765, NorwegianboyEE wrote:I wouldn’t say i was the only one sorting Titus like all other players in our hood had given it no thought. But i tried to ask questions and exactly the same theories as was said earlier about them potentially being a scum that could select hood to spy in and etc.

WHY DON'T YOU CONSOLIDATE ONTO KT TO MAKE SCUM FAKE MORE REACTIONS? I DON'T KNOW WHAT T3 IS FLIPPING BUT I WOULD BE STUNNED IF KT FLIPS STARCLAN.

In post 2698, Mistyx wrote:hey T3 what do you hope to accomplish by playing this way

Yeah where are the read explanations. Cmon even I am putting in more effort than this.

Like imo this complete lack of engagement with the game is scummy af even for T3 who is something of a lurker.

In post 2767, Dannflor wrote:VOTE: fireisredsir

I no longer think mistyx is scum

hi whats up

I think town!T3 would be less... deflated when under this kind of pressure.

In post 2717, Titus wrote:Ngl KittyTacky is curious on a VCA level but I don't think they're scum.

Flavor is not Rusty or Scourge.

Using curious immediately after it was (dubiously) said to be a scummy word is +town imo, scum would be more careful with wording.

In post 2768, SCRRRDBEAR wrote:

In post 2765, NorwegianboyEE wrote:I wouldn’t say i was the only one sorting Titus like all other players in our hood had given it no thought. But i tried to ask questions and exactly the same theories as was said earlier about them potentially being a scum that could select hood to spy in and etc.

WHY DON'T YOU CONSOLIDATE ONTO KT TO MAKE SCUM FAKE MORE REACTIONS? I DON'T KNOW WHAT T3 IS FLIPPING BUT I WOULD BE STUNNED IF KT FLIPS STARCLAN.

You will be stunned then if the wagon on me goes through.