NY 167: COMPLETELY NORMAL Mafia (GAME OVER)

[Angry Frat BROs]

AP's still on break. I haven't been able to flag him down.

I'm getting close to a break myself. This game was fun, though. Playing on my back foot the entire time was good practice.

[MC Maraca]

No shame in raising the white flag in an unwinnable gamestate. I highly doubt town wants to suffer through two more days of lynching us while we post trolling pix.

[Cephrir]

By the way, I meant what I said about claiming vig. I would never claim vig as SK, literally ever, even if I was tracked to a kill and found to have a killing ability.

[MC Maraca]

For the record, if RC is legit a cop.

Goon
Goon
Encryptor
Scumdoc

Gunsmith
Cop
Unlimited or multishot Vig
Vanillas

is pretty broken.

[MC Maraca]

Like how the fuck does scum win that with no blocks or even a rolecop to find them?

[Cephrir]

THe lack of a godfather there is so absurd that I have to believe RC is fake.

[BROseidon]

Posting from my main b/c the game's functionally over anyways.

RC's claim was obviously fake the entire time. He couldn't get me lynched on his own, so he needed to come up with a fake claim to go for it.

[BROseidon]

If it's not fake then the setup is pretty wtf. Double PR should be heavily gated in ways other than a godfather against one of them and a vig (vig is an anti-town role, interestingly enough)

[MC Maraca]

Even if he is, one role as the single counter to both town roles is pretty lame. Like is AFB dies, we're entire at mercy of both vig AND gunsmith.

[Cephrir]

I mean that was certainly my automatic reaction. And there was the whole thing with his earlier posting basically claiming "not cop". It was only the scumteam becoming obvious that changed my mind.

[Cephrir]

If it's not fake then the setup is pretty wtf. Double PR should be heavily gated in ways other than a godfather against one of them and a vig (vig is an anti-town role, interestingly enough)

It can be, but I'm not overconfident in my own reads! Woooo!

[BROseidon]

setup with a gunsmith is going to very often include a vig/scumdoc to serve as a miller/godfather, effectively.

It's technically a better setup for scum than cop/miller/godfather.

pedit: yeah, but vig also went into the hands of the strongest townie by a significant margin. There are a lot of players where giving them vig costs town the game from the onset.

[Cephrir]

I guess I don't see what this can possibly hurt.

http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/8CBZy3FrUuvn

[MC Maraca]

CephPerson was signed in when posted

11-24-2013

10:12 PM ET (US)
I honestly mildly suspect bauss and Rank of cheating, possibly to the point of giving bauss the whole scumteam...



I think they just talked about WHY rank replaced out (GM knows but we the scumteam don't) and that was alignment indicative. But it's possible. Cephrir was moving in lockstep with the entire scumteam on day one and two; and yet bauss didn't even mildly suspect him.

[yessiree]

yeah, Cephrir would be my back-up scumread

[Cephrir]

He started to suspect me after I basically pointed out "you should really suspect me", but that doesn't count.

[MC Maraca]

yeah, Cephrir would be my back-up scumread

He's not scum. The scumteam is Me, AFB, sangres, orcnius. If there's a SK that's your problem; but scum is scooping.

[MC Maraca]

He started to suspect me after I basically pointed out "you should really suspect me", but that doesn't count.

That was after he made his big "here's entire scumteam but let me only FOS sangres instead of calling all four so it doesn't look as bad" post.

[Cephrir]

yeah, Cephrir would be my back-up scumread

You didn't click on the qt I posted did you

[yessiree]

yeah I know, I'm just saying I would lynch Cephrir if we somehow end up in a LyLo situation and all my other scumreads are dead

[MC Maraca]

yeah I know, I'm just saying I would lynch Cephrir if we somehow end up in a LyLo situation and all my other scumreads are dead

You won't. If cephrir is town, game is over, as we've asked GM to let us all just end the game here and not drag it out. If game doesn't end when all three of us are dead; then you've got like a ton of mislynches to play with.

[Cephrir]

[Hint: I'm town]

[RadiantCowbells]

yeah I know, I'm just saying I would lynch Cephrir if we somehow end up in a LyLo situation and all my other scumreads are dead

No, you won't.

[yessiree]

maybe I was unclear on this. I know the game is over and you're town. But I'm saying that

{IF}

this game was still going on I would lynch you in case the ceiling falls down

[yessiree]

yeah I know, I'm just saying I would lynch Cephrir if we somehow end up in a LyLo situation and all my other scumreads are dead

No, you won't.

are you COP?