Posted: Sat Apr 18, 2015 1:47 pm
it would be dumb for me to not go fir this.
Unvote, Vote: AD
Titus wrote:Given how townsided most of the open setups can be, I bet practically no one preferred scum.
TSO wrote:So, you don't know if this set-up is townsided yet, but you don't think people would have picked scum in fear of it being townsided?
Titus wrote:@TSO, Use context please. The opens are townsided so I would be surprised if anyone picked scum in those games. It is too early to tell if this setup is townsided.
TSO wrote:But how is this fully open? It's semi-open at best.
Titus wrote: Read my posts in their entirety again.
Titus wrote:You think I lie for no reason???
I think the fact that he's saying that she's lying about Bulba's meta is wayyyyyyyy too strong for someone who's only just started reading the game. The level of confidence that she's lying vs asking her why she has a different perception of Bulba's meta strikes me as distancing rather than someone trying to sort someone. There's also the use of the word 'lying' seems like more of a sheep of TSO saying there's a discrepancy in Titus's posting. It's even worse because there's no vote and he later starts nakedly townreading her with almost no significant interactions in between:Espeonage wrote:Ok well I don't get an easy bane vote then.
But you're lies about bulba stand.
Espeonage wrote:Also Titus is probs town.
Titus wrote:Let's see here, since you're being an ass to me. The claws come out here.
Quote this god gamn case if you want me to read it. There have been multiple references to cases and evidence that people want me to rely on. Getting all hostile when I ask is antitown as best.
It also puts me in the state where I want to lynch you regardless of your alignment and rip your case to shreads.
Espeonage wrote:Calling paragraphs of case that I believe in and am copping flack for that I didn't even wright "evidence" is insulting. You got the claws out first honey.
Nothing about this back and forth reads as genuine to me. The "I'm getting the claws out" comment from Titus especially strikes me as being fake.Titus wrote:TTH's case is basically that he couldn't follow Marquis's train of thought. We looked at Marquis following that. Marquis frankly obvtowned himself during that discussion. TTH's case was worth investigating at the time, but Marquis wasn't actually scum. You seemingly have ignoredeverything that goes against your point Espy and are relying on one player misunderstanding one read.
Yeah, this vote is not moving.
Espeonage wrote:You self voting is a really bad sign though.
And this is all within sixteen posts of each other and Marquis didn't even post once in between :/Espeonage wrote:Current List of people ok with being Booned: Marquis
Oh, anyone can analyze them.
Gonna need to tell me what that was.
this feels like you're calling a personality thing scummy.
You agreed with espe's point that titus' reasons for townreading bulba were weak, but you turned it into an "espe is likelier scum" point.
The lesson was bad. So?
No problem bb.AD wrote:THANKS GUY WHO'S VOTING FOR ME!
↑ ActionDan wrote:Ffery....
I don't understand, how could you even think to type something like this:
this feels like you're calling a personality thing scummy.
I have maybe said one thing relating to Espe's personality including both his tone of posting and his personal relations with other players... and that was calling his reachout to tammy patronizing.
As for your other criticisms I really don't appreciate them frankly.
Like this 1 out of the 2:
You agreed with espe's point that titus' reasons for townreading bulba were weak, but you turned it into an "espe is likelier scum" point.
The lesson was bad. So?
Actually I didn't agree with him. I stated as an aside that in general titus' stated reasons for townreading bulba would be weak for me: Replace Titus and Bulba with 2 people of your choice and the result would hold. But the finer point here is what he made of those reasons coming from titus' unique POV. They were used as an attack on Titus much more so than anything else, which is what I found scummy.
↑ fferyllt wrote:↑ ActionDan wrote:Ffery....
I don't understand, how could you even think to type something like this:
this feels like you're calling a personality thing scummy.
I have maybe said one thing relating to Espe's personality including both his tone of posting and his personal relations with other players... and that was calling his reachout to tammy patronizing.
As for your other criticisms I really don't appreciate them frankly.
Like this 1 out of the 2:
You agreed with espe's point that titus' reasons for townreading bulba were weak, but you turned it into an "espe is likelier scum" point.
The lesson was bad. So?
Actually I didn't agree with him. I stated as an aside that in general titus' stated reasons for townreading bulba would be weak for me: Replace Titus and Bulba with 2 people of your choice and the result would hold. But the finer point here is what he made of those reasons coming from titus' unique POV. They were used as an attack on Titus much more so than anything else, which is what I found scummy.
Oh the horror! and I was paraphrasing Nacho, how could it be?
I think even a deep and enlightening post about espe would ring a little hollow at this point. one case, on the player with the largest wagon, and then a fade with promises still on the table.
(This post is horrible, btw.)↑ singersigner wrote:It's probably because all of my scum buddies are hardcore ignoring my wagon in hopes that'll disappear. Well, there's maybe one white-knighting me, but she can't vote anyway so I'm not worried about it coming back to bite me in the butt.
I also didn't realize we were voting based on "bareableness"...I might have to change my strategy! Can you comment on my case on Shadoweh?
↑ Cheetory6 wrote:Do you think I care?
You've made one significant post about one person. I have no idea what you think about anyone right now other than Esp. I'm down to sheep ffery on this vote for pressure alone if it means for you to start playing the game and start taking more actual stances.
Pitch three people you think might be scum and name two people you're townreading and why.
Nacho's feelings are mine!