Mafiascum.net

Their scumgame is really lackluster, i don’t think they would put in as much effort as they have in this game if they weren’t town.

norwee, the issue is i see nothing but mindless tunnels that didn't make any sense, were refused to see any reason, and kept hitting town. i need a bit more than "lol effort"

I’ve seen Mastina be wrong about reads before, i just don’t equate that with: "omg BoP! They scum!".
Also i’ve correctly read them in almost every single game i’ve had with them so i trust myself to be able to see it if they were of the mafia allignment. And so far i don’t believe it is so.

Also the supposed "mindless tunnels" you refer to were really convincing cases and i feel like Mastina truly believed in them.
If their heart was truly in it, why should they be scum?

that's the issue, i don't believe her heart was truly in it

because the scumcase on bingle was absolutely godawful, imho someone having the thought is one thing, but someone repeatedly putting it out despite it making zero sense, refusing to reevaluate despite the whole game screaming how the case is utter nonsense, and then bingle flipping town is like, willful ignorance

but i am aware that i can be wrong and rn we can't afford that so i am asking you, can you make a more solid case than a one-liner?

In post 2779, Datisi wrote:that's the issue, i don't believe her heart was truly in it

Why?

because the case on bingle was godawful nonsense and she kept refusing to think about it despite most of the game telling her it makes no sense? like idk how much clearer i can say that i find it unbelieveable that someone would *actually* believe the garbage she was pushing and would actively refuse to listen for a second to what the majority of the game is saying about it? like there are bad cases and there is mastina's bingle case

i am aware that i've been wrong on reads like this before and i'm aware that my experience with mastina is basically nonexistent so i am asking you to put some effort in and try to change my mind

If Mastina’s case was so garbage why would she push it with conviction? Mastina is an player that can only fully push when they believe what they are saying. You’re not looking at the deeper subconcious level but only assuming surface level= case bad which means Mastina scum.

RCE meanwhile is saying all of the right things but their intentions are hostile.

The way she could push a shit case even though it's shit is by being scum

Scum comes out of this looking good because they let Mastina make the wrong pushes for them, and then afterwards the fingers can be pointed at the players that were doing things. Even though they themselves haven’t done anything because they don’t care to solve the game.

In post 2784, Dwlee99 wrote:The way she could push a shit case even though it's shit is by being scum

No.
Also i disagree with the premise that it’s shit in the first place.

This has been pointed out but RCE isn't doing that despite you saying he should be doing that as scum

Because RCE doesn’t need to do anything. Whoever of you/GCB is town are doing it for them.

The case was "scumslip" and "meta." Ffs it was completely atrocious. I pointed out that the scum slip was actually a townslip and mastina just didn't engage me on it or reeval ever. She would come back every other day pushing the same awful case

Ok so, i’m still not really buying any of this.
But in the case that Mastina is scum.
Who is she with?
Because from my perspective i’m town so who the heck would she even be with? It’s not convincing me if the team has me and T3 as their only exact possible team.

Ari or RCE could be scum with Mastina if you're not.

Then that’s just another reason to flip RCE.

Actually barring you get quickhammered here it would have to be RCE if you're town.

In post 2782, NorwegianboyEE wrote:If Mastina’s case was so garbage why would she push it with conviction? Mastina is an player that can only fully push when they believe what they are saying. You’re not looking at the deeper subconcious level but only assuming surface level= case bad which means Mastina scum.

that's the point, i don't believe her conviction was real - scum!her could be pushing it because being tunnelled on a single town player is a great way to look busy as scum, and everyone will go "haha that's mastina"

that's what i need you to explain to me - how can you tell between town and scum her there? what about that push is her town meta and couldn't be coming from her as scum?

In post 2783, NorwegianboyEE wrote:RCE meanwhile is saying all of the right things but their intentions are hostile.

what does this even mean - how are his intentions hostile if he's saying the right things?

not saying you must be wrong on rce, but that post makes like, no sense without elaboration

Here's another thing though. I don't think Ari is scum with RCE.

In post 2795, Datisi wrote:not saying you must be wrong on rce, but that post makes like, no sense without elaboration

Me?

In post 2796, Dwlee99 wrote:Here's another thing though. I don't think Ari is scum with RCE.

why and who is

also that previous post was @norwee

In post 2794, Datisi wrote:what does this even mean - how are his intentions hostile if he's saying the right things?

I’m saying that he is mafia but he comes out looking better than me because he hasn’t done anything worthy to talk about this game. Mostly coasting.