I mean maybe he is just the most excellent scum player of all time but it seems unlikely. I'm unwilling to vote there for the reasons stated above. I'm more willing to vote there than other people. Would still prefer to lynch Cheery Dog or InflatablePie or Magua.
And actually thinking about it now we probably need Iece dead before LYLO since he decreases lynch threshhold by L-1 and I'm surprised nobody has considered that yet.
p.edi: No, we're not killing mollie. She's skimming and barely reading. You yourself even said she's reading every other post. That does not a scumbag make.
In post 2795, Axxle wrote:Reck, your biggest issue with Jordan/fate is fate's farewell posts, right? Did you actually parse what he said?
Not the farewell posts. The first weird string of posting from him where he was like, "I see all now. Reck, it is okay to be scum. Don't cry. You must be scum so we can be town" or some shit.
Not to get into it but Fate was legitimately high and off his rocker and
actually
thought he knew the absolute truth of the world because he smoked something, idk
Seems like a reach for him to fake it when having his first trippy drug experience. Like it's hard enough for me to play as scum when I'm DRUNK in a game, but I manage. If I was high or tripping balls? There's no fucking way I could fake that
EBWOP: It should also be noted Fate said in thread, "You don't have to be scared Reck, you can come to the other side" and that was referencing some deeply personal issues I have and it'd be really really out of character for him to use something so horrifying in an attempt to manipulate me when he's scum. Even Fate has his limits.
Posted: Wed Apr 09, 2014 3:49 pm
by Ythan
Thanks for the input but you're not on my scumteam.
seriously, just fuck you. if this is what you do with your confirmed town status on day fucking three then fuck you
Posted: Wed Apr 09, 2014 4:03 pm
by A Simple Math Problem
I don't think anybody reads the shit I say here.
Deadline: April 24th @ 1PM Commune Time
V/LA:
mollie on weekends, Axxle through Sunday, Iecerint through Friday
Posted: Wed Apr 09, 2014 4:09 pm
by Untrod Tripod
In post 2800, Your New Gay Overlords wrote:And actually thinking about it now we probably need Iece dead before LYLO since he decreases lynch threshhold by L-1 and I'm surprised nobody has considered that yet
I have, but eh I'm not gonna get bent out of shape that you forgot
and I really don't get why you're busting out the emotional appeals. does it really OFFEND you that I'd scumread you, or are you so unconfident in your scum game that you're flipping out like this?
to be doing this on purpose for some reason because you're not usually this... daft
In post 2762, Your New Gay Overlords wrote:I don't recall you ever saying why Anti's slot is scum. In fact, I don't recall anyone saying why Nuwen/Anti are scum.
see above except now I want to throw something at you
In post 1288, Nuwen wrote:ACTIONDAN was shrugs. I already said I'm tired of lynching Action Dan every single Day 1.
Because I didn't defend OR bus scum, I'm scum? THAT'S the way you think that played out.
I am telling you 100% that ActionDan's wagon contained his own cannibalistic scum team because I know I wasn't interested in voting Dan, as town. Only his buddies would be so sensitive and swing onto that shit, and ActionDan obviously had no intention of living. I don't think anyone on his team threw him a lifeline, which is why he gave up.
ANTIHERO is this "100% confidence" role related or is just Nuwen's bluster
In post 1288, Nuwen wrote:ACTIONDAN was shrugs. I already said I'm tired of lynching Action Dan every single Day 1.
Because I didn't defend OR bus scum, I'm scum? THAT'S the way you think that played out.
I am telling you 100% that ActionDan's wagon contained his own cannibalistic scum team because I know I wasn't interested in voting Dan, as town. Only his buddies would be so sensitive and swing onto that shit, and ActionDan obviously had no intention of living. I don't think anyone on his team threw him a lifeline, which is why he gave up.
ANTIHERO is this "100% confidence" role related or is just Nuwen's bluster
In post 2800, Your New Gay Overlords wrote:And actually thinking about it now we probably need Iece dead before LYLO since he decreases lynch threshhold by L-1 and I'm surprised nobody has considered that yet
I have, but eh I'm not gonna get bent out of shape that you forgot
and I really don't get why you're busting out the emotional appeals. does it really OFFEND you that I'd scumread you, or are you so unconfident in your scum game that you're flipping out like this?
Yes, your reads and play are fucking offensive.
It is really fucking offensive that you have
yet
to actually engage in a dialogue about why I'm scum instead of just saying "can we lynch YNGO yet" ad nauseum.
It is really fucking offensive that Waffles gave you the gift of having people listen to any rational points made by you by having an innocent result claimed on you and instead you just coast along.
It is really fucking offensive that I've continued to play and done countless things that I think are incredibly town and your read is completely static and has not even shown signs of budging since you got lucked in this dumb fucking tunnel since D1.
Trust me, if I was scum, I'd be relishing the fact that town appears to be eating itself alive.
to be doing this on purpose for some reason because you're not usually this... daft
In post 2762, Your New Gay Overlords wrote:I don't recall you ever saying why Anti's slot is scum. In fact, I don't recall anyone saying why Nuwen/Anti are scum.
see above except now I want to throw something at you
"kind of arbitrarily" implies not entirely arbitrary. You put some flowery adjectives behind other people's names and PoE'd from my gathering but I meant it like... anyone can come in and invent reasons for thinking it's so-and-so or not thinking it's so-and-so.
And since you've provided a big list of times you said
why
Anti's slot is scum, I now have something to digest! One second.
Nuwen says "ActionDan was bussed by his team" after saying "Pie & EagleKit are scum" when you two weren't on the wagon.
You assumedly take issue with this but I cannot fathom why. Never did she say that Dan's ENTIRE TEAM bussed him. She even LITERALLY IN THE SAME POST WHERE SHE CALLS YOU/EAGLEKIT SCUM gives her THREE PICKS for DAN'S TEAMMATES WHO BUSSED HIM.
You're cherry picking things here and ignoring everything that doesn't fit into your narrative.
You spin a narrative that continues harping on the false dichotomy of "EITHER HE WAS BUSSED OR HE WASN'T" when you know damn well she never said DAN'S ENTIRE SCUMTEAM BUSSED HIM. You also call her out for being reactionary with a scumread on you but
you literally quoted her from many moons before calling you scum before you called her out the first time
. It's like fucking magical adventure storytime where everything's made up and the points don't matter.
You hypothesize a Nuwen/Mollie scumteam. You do not give reasons. In fact, you say you're "not feeling Eagle" BECAUSE Nuwen was voting Eagle... well, Eagle's flipped scum now, wanna reevaluate or is this like a museum where we don't touch the poop?
Please help me here. "Nuwen is scum see below" then I look below and you literally just copy paste the EagleKit wagon and say "Nuwen is scum here based on this, 'nuff said". No, I'm sorry, not 'nuff said, Nuwen voted Eagle second therefore she's scum? What kind of FUCKING MOONBEAMS METHAMPHETAMINES ARE YOU ON to think that's "nuff said"?
Posted: Wed Apr 09, 2014 7:53 pm
by Your New Gay Overlords
SO TO SUMMARIZE PIE'S CASE ON NUWEN
Nuwen says Dan was bussed and also calls Eagle/Pie (non-bussers) scum.
Pie calls Nuwen out because he lives in a fantasy world where these two things are mutually exclusive.
Pie then tries to play Nuwen calling him scum as reactionary to him calling her scum (but Nuwen called Pie scum first).
Then he just repeats empty adjectives like "terribad" to describe Nuwen's posts "in general" and says that qualifies as explaining why.
So...
@Pie
, you literally had one reason for voting Nuwen (she said Dan was bussed & also had reads off-wagon) and have just tunneled on said one-off shitty (and misinformed/misrepresented) read the rest of the game. Sound accurate?
Posted: Wed Apr 09, 2014 7:56 pm
by Your New Gay Overlords
I do very much appreciate you pointing out those Nuwen posts though, because it reminded me that Nuwen actually WAS scumreading you and eaglekit (as well as Fate/Jordan) which gives way more credence to that slot than I first thought so now Anti's on the untouchable list for me.
Nuwen, as scum, would not have called the D1 lynch bus-heavy only to turn around and call out behavioral scumreads on non-bussers. Nuwen, as scum, would call the D1 wagon bus heavy and SCREAM AT PEOPLE OVER AND OVER until they agreed to lynch from the potential bus pool, securing herself and eaglekit as non-lynch-candidates.
Posted: Wed Apr 09, 2014 8:07 pm
by Antihero
...
...
yeah, why is anyone talking about lynching reck?
Posted: Wed Apr 09, 2014 8:12 pm
by Antihero
UNVOTE: VOTE: pie
Posted: Wed Apr 09, 2014 8:14 pm
by Your New Gay Overlords
I'm waiting to see how Pie backs out of his town read on us.