Mafiascum.net

Yay that simplifies some things

Check wilky please

In post 2798, BrightEyedFish wrote: While we wait on sheldon's response to DDL's PT guilty, I would love to hear what Flippynips has to say about it.

Well he slipped out of the kill yesterday by being active. My main goal yesterday was to get a lynch cos we were pressed for time. Sheldon had pinged my scumdar so that’s that. I do want to hear from him tho

In post 2756, Akarin wrote:

No one died last night!

Also haven’t seen that before. At least not on N1

Let's not end the day before everyone says something.

UNVOTE:

Well with my vote that was L-2.
I’m not trying to end the day either, like I said I wanted to hear from him but with pressure

With a PT check, he's going to have to talk about it regardless.

In post 2806, insomnia wrote:Let's not end the day before everyone says something.

UNVOTE:

See insomnia, we can agree on this.

Here are the players who haven't checked in today:

Creature
Pretentious
Shiidaji
wilky

Add these players to that list because they haven't commented since DDL dropped his guilty:

Sheldon
Macabre
Vedith

VOTE: DDL

Can only be a fake claim imo

DDL - can you say exactly what your role is - day 1 you said cop and now you say I have a PT (I don’t for the record)

Here's what I think. If DDL's not bussing and actually checked a scum with a 1/11 chance he got a PT result, then my PoE would be Shidaji / Pretentious , Sheldon , wilky / flippy. I don't know if it's a traitor setup as I'm not good with roles. DDL can check wilky and in the off-chance doc didn't save him last night, he should be on him tonight. If wilky turns out to not have a PT, next targets I'd look into would be either shidaji or pretentious. Shidaji vs RC feels SvT and RC might be the town, I liked his reluctance to get sash off the lynch yesterday. Shidaji followed RC on his votes, including you BEF. She hopped on all wagons.

If you want me to pick in between those options, scums would be Shidaji , Sheldon and wilky. If any of shidaji / wilky flips town, then the next person I'd look into would be Pretentious, respectively flippy.

This resulted off some iso checks and votes without any proper VCA, ank is good on that part from what I've seen, I can even say that her scum hunting tool that she relies on the most is VCA.

And this is mainly PoE.

Thoughts?

In post 2557, DrDolittle wrote:PT cop

@Sheldon

That's not too far from my PoE actually

I'll go through a quick analysis on DDL's claim legitimacy.

I'll go from the premise it's true and I'll attempt to disprove it. If I were DDL and my scum buds didn't manage to get a kill, I would've personally checked someone that is a relatively low poster in terms of activity and when I flip red, suspicion would be thrown onto that person for attempting to clear someone that the town suspect a lot. Instead, DDL went for what the "crowd" suggested. Which was that Sheldon was a somewhat common scum read. There's no reason for DDL to check someone that's already suspicious and point to him being scum, that's wasting a mislynch in order to stall his (DDL's) lynch, when scum already "wasted" a night kill. That's not optimal for scum.

Either way, that scum team that I just put out seems too easy to be true, so I expect some plot twist with today's flip. If not, then the game is that simple.

I would've personally checked someone that is a relatively low poster in terms of activity and when I flip red, suspicion would be thrown onto that person for attempting to clear someone that the town suspect a lot

Just to be clear with this, I meant as in check someone that is a relatively low poster and clear him as town. So not getting a PT result on them.

Down w a Sheldon lynch since he confirmed it's either him or DDL, i expected a neighbor claim in response so that makes things way easier for us I feel DDL scum would have chosen a player to drag down that would be harder for scum to push. Not really concerned with them being both scum since there was no kill last night but if that is the case his nightly results will just help figure it out.

i expected a neighbor claim in response so that makes things way easier for us

Precisely what I was thinking, but the thing is if Sheldon = Lycan I expect him to pull off something like this. The only way he’d have an equal chance at escaping a lynch in a 1v1 is if he claimed something that doesn’t have a PT.

Shidaji, what do you think about my scum read on you? Who do you think are Sheldon’s team mates?

Vedith, do you believe DDL’s claim?

I'm tied up, so I'll post here later.
I'm going with yes though. I was actually expecting DDL to claim roleblocked.

In post 2820, Vedith wrote:I'm tied up, so I'll post here later.
I'm going with yes though. I was actually expecting DDL to claim roleblocked.

Fake claim roleblocked btw

I could see him claim Cop as a PT cop.

Looks like you’re scum, Sheldon. I don’t think DDL plays that way to fake a guilty rather than fake an inno.

In post 2821, Vedith wrote:

In post 2820, Vedith wrote:I'm tied up, so I'll post here later.
I'm going with yes though. I was actually expecting DDL to claim roleblocked.

Fake claim roleblocked btw

Why so?

:thonk: