Page 113 of 155
Posted: Sun Jan 17, 2021 5:44 am
by Flea The Magician
In fact, I'm going to timestream yeet anyway, I can fullclaim if wanted
Posted: Sun Jan 17, 2021 5:45 am
by superbowl9
Yeah the more I think about it the less conclusive I think this will be
pedit: I thought it took out both people? So your ability is just literal suicide?
pedit2: Yes just claim
Posted: Sun Jan 17, 2021 5:47 am
by Flea The Magician
There's always more to it than I let on
There's a reason I've not fullclaimed yet. I have some maths to do.
Posted: Sun Jan 17, 2021 5:52 am
by Flea The Magician
Do we think 2 or 3 scum btw?
Posted: Sun Jan 17, 2021 5:55 am
by Bell
2 if oil is 3p. Is my guess.
Also, flea, if you're negative I see no reason for you to time stream yeet yourself at all really.
Posted: Sun Jan 17, 2021 5:56 am
by Flea The Magician
I mean, I'm going to have to at this point anyway.
Either that or I try and WIFOM Scum...
Hey, hey bell... how confident are your reads in this game?
Posted: Sun Jan 17, 2021 5:56 am
by Bell
Not very.
Posted: Sun Jan 17, 2021 5:57 am
by Flea The Magician
awww
Posted: Sun Jan 17, 2021 6:18 am
by superbowl9
In post 2804, Bell wrote:2 if oil is 3p. Is my guess.
Also, flea, if you're negative I see no reason for you to time stream yeet yourself at all really.
I think Oil + Flea 3P with 2 scum
Posted: Sun Jan 17, 2021 8:00 am
by Firebringer
this game is really weird if what flea is telling us aboaut their role is true.
Posted: Sun Jan 17, 2021 8:05 am
by Finral
Yeah, this game went over my head
Posted: Sun Jan 17, 2021 8:34 am
by Flea The Magician
Awww it's almost like you're losing confidence in yourselves. It's cute <3
Posted: Sun Jan 17, 2021 8:58 am
by Battle Mage
my confidence remains intact
Posted: Sun Jan 17, 2021 9:00 am
by Firebringer
mine has shaken but im ready to roll the dice and find out.
Posted: Sun Jan 17, 2021 9:03 am
by Battle Mage
In post 2688, Oil Tycoons wrote:We're Jimmy Cracker, human reporter = survivor.
Our ability is Reporting to you Live! and we have to use all three shots of it and survive to the end in order to win - a positive report, a negative report, a neutral report.
Negative report is what we used last night - roleblocks everything but scum kill.
Positive report soups up all active abilities.
Neutral does nothing.
So you're taking credit for Mastina being dead?
eh, i struggle to believe a SURVIVOR takes the approach you have in this game - not scumhunt and be as antagonistic and conspicuous as possible. Like if you're a survivor, are you really getting into drunk arguments?
I'm 100% fine elimming this at first glance. still reading
Posted: Sun Jan 17, 2021 9:10 am
by Battle Mage
In post 2692, Finral wrote:Cell
Cell Jrs.
Challengers
Caroni
Pirozhki
Mr. Satan
Goku
Gohan
Vegeta
Future Trunks
Piccolo
Krillin
Yamcha
Tien Shinhan
Android 16
12 challengers, plus announcer does make 13. this is a 13p game, right? I'm sure Cell/Cell Jr's have a fake flavor claim for each of them within that or else it could seem broken with a flavor claim.
Should we all just flavor claim?
No. Given the roles are linked to flavour, a flavour mass-claim just gives scum all the role info without telling town as much.
good question
In post 2695, Finral wrote:Alternatively, if 16, 17, and 18 are all in this game, Oil is confirmed scum here, because I can't see the announcer being in over the 3 of them if they are in it, which means those top 2 challengers would be out too.
Despite the above, given I've already roleclaimed - I am Android 18. So Oil confirmed scum for you I guess.
In post 2712, Oil Tycoons wrote: In post 2689, Finral wrote:why wouldn't you claim that before you got nominated?
Seems suspish
Firebring?
1) Claiming torpedos my chances of winning.
2) Thought there would be more discussion before I got nommed. Shoulda known better, but didn't.
Given 1...why claim now? Don't get me wrong, it's possible, but I'm fine with the risk that, AT WORST you're a 3rd party who deliberately fked town last night.
Posted: Sun Jan 17, 2021 9:16 am
by Battle Mage
In post 2721, superbowl9 wrote: In post 2688, Oil Tycoons wrote:We're Jimmy Cracker, human reporter = survivor.
Our ability is Reporting to you Live! and we have to use all three shots of it and survive to the end in order to win - a positive report, a negative report, a neutral report.
Negative report is what we used last night - roleblocks everything but scum kill.
Positive report soups up all active abilities.
Neutral does nothing.
This is just a scumclaim
yes agree
In post 2725, Guillotina wrote:
And me.
So they didn't throw our game but they scum sided, they decided to block Mastina's chances of survival, rendering titus sacrifice to clear her useless as well. It's the same as claiming scum in my opinion.
yes agree
In post 2737, Bell wrote:Are we going to ask flea to blow themselves up to kill Oil?
If Oil isn't scum, I'm looking at Bell again tomorrow. The incredible good-faithing through all obstacles is too much. Trying to make a weak case for saving Oil, when it's a lot more natural and easier to see the reasons for elimming them.
If Oil is scum, no way Bell jumps under the train here, so Oil-scum implies Bell-conftown for me.
My opinion doesn't matter to you? pfft
Posted: Sun Jan 17, 2021 9:19 am
by Battle Mage
In post 2746, Bell wrote:Pretty much they're not getting out of this phase without cooperating with the town.
But the second they survive, they have no obligation to help us.
Except by telling them if they don't send the ability enhanceer to a pool of the towniest players, we would eliminate them next day phase.
But if we followed through with that we might as well have eliminated them early.
Likewise, there is no benefit for a protective role to help them.
So they are both constrained by us and the scum team's mercy.
Unless they have a bullet proof jacket, which, honestly they might I can't remember if they did in the anime.
what on earth are you trying to pull here??
How convenient.
Posted: Sun Jan 17, 2021 9:25 am
by Battle Mage
In post 2768, kookiemonster wrote:So monopoly man is 3p and has conveniently only got good things left for town.
Flea can just bounce. No utility to town at all as far as I can tell.
Bell watchu wanna know?
-j
solid take Johnny
In post 2770, Finral wrote:Anyone else think Bell's playing the "i don't know better than anyone, don't trust me" card too much?
ooh me me!
In post 2773, Guillotina wrote:The more i think about it, the less a like Bell and Flea's willingness to keep Oil alive, or anyone advocating for giving them a second chance for that matter! They are a 3rd party that have acted anti-town.
The whole strat about letting them use their powers to prove themselves is flawed.
1)We don't know what “enhancing” entails (does it duplicate the targets, does it give more shots etc) and we don't know what powers do scum have, being ok with enhancing everyone's powers when the wolves could have extra killing powers besides the factional is a bad idea.
2) They can say they used it when they didnt, hinting a possible roleblock or jailkeep that we can't prove.
3) There is no way to prove that's all the abilities they got that could affect town.
Other reasons to not keep them alive
1) They roleblocked the entire player list after Mastina got confirmed town.
2) They tried to a frame player for it which is scummy as hell.
Finral makes a good point about Flea backing down on using their power when it's Oil on the line.
VOTE: Flea what if Oil are not 3p but scum? Which in opinion are essentially the same thing.
Guillotina doing the Lord's work.
In post 2781, Bell wrote:I have a one shot ability that can detect a mafia indicator when players are in the arena.
I will heal them if they're negative for the indicator, and hurt them if they do.
If both don't have the indicator we fade Oil.
If Flea has the indicator we fade flea.
If oil and flea have the indicator we fade oil.
If oil has the indicator we fade oil.
and spare flea.
Got it?
Got it.
So you're claiming battle-cop? you can investigate the people in the final 2?
If so, isn't the above fairly self-explanatory? we elim the guilty one, if neither are guilty we elim the 3p-claim first. if both are guilty, I'd elim Flea first, but it clearly doesn't matter game-wise.
Posted: Sun Jan 17, 2021 9:27 am
by Battle Mage
In post 2782, Bell wrote:It's worth keeping the 3p alive if they are a 3p because, I don't have any other abilities and it's likely based on the current abilities that there are more town abilities out there that would benefit fi the 3p claim is true.
If oil is negative for the indicator they are 100% 3rd party.
this seems like a bit of a waste of your ability though isn't it? I mean, if you get a negative on both, we're still elimming Oil.
I don't understand why you even triggered this here? Surely better to keep quiet for another day?
Posted: Sun Jan 17, 2021 9:32 am
by Battle Mage
In post 2786, superbowl9 wrote: In post 2778, Flea The Magician wrote: In post 2767, Flea The Magician wrote:We vote scum into the arena, oil lives and activates the positive ability tonight, if all abilities are enhanced, we'll know about it.
Then frankly Oil becomes arena bait if we can't decide who is scum to send into the arena.
Anyone else amused by Finrals ignorance of this?
In theory if we have a protective and oil activates the power tonight nobody dies.
Also in theory an investigative will get MULTIPLE RESULTS... or at least, something traceable.
Yes because we should believe the team that gave scum a free IC kill
additionally, scum took a punt at killing Mastina, the IC.
Clearly it's more likely that they KNEW Mastina wouldn't be protected, which suggests Oil-scum. If they didn't know Mastina would be protected, frankly, they are dense and got very lucky.
In post 2793, superbowl9 wrote: In post 2791, Bell wrote:Both people in the arena.
It has individual indications for both players given to me.
so I will hurt both of them if they're both positive and will heal both of them if they're negative.
Or hurt one and heal the other. if one's positive and one isn't.
Gotcha. Your plan works then but I don't think it will give us as much utility now that we know there's 3Ps, since a negative isn't a town result
we "know" there's 3Ps? Little slip there hombre?
Posted: Sun Jan 17, 2021 9:37 am
by Battle Mage
In post 2786, superbowl9 wrote: In post 2778, Flea The Magician wrote: In post 2767, Flea The Magician wrote:We vote scum into the arena, oil lives and activates the positive ability tonight, if all abilities are enhanced, we'll know about it.
Then frankly Oil becomes arena bait if we can't decide who is scum to send into the arena.
Anyone else amused by Finrals ignorance of this?
In theory if we have a protective and oil activates the power tonight nobody dies.
Also in theory an investigative will get MULTIPLE RESULTS... or at least, something traceable.
Yes because we should believe the team that gave scum a free IC kill
additionally, scum took a punt at killing Mastina, the IC.
Clearly it's more likely that they KNEW Mastina wouldn't be protected, which suggests Oil-scum. If they didn't know Mastina would be protected, frankly, they are dense and got very lucky.
Eww no. Jury's out but in simple terms:
Oil-scum means Bell-town. Oil-town means Bell is worth a good look. I don't think the claim is worth much - it's an easy scum fakeclaim right? Bell feels out on a limb. But they'll be sorted in due time, so I wouldn't sweat it for today.
In post 2808, superbowl9 wrote: In post 2804, Bell wrote:2 if oil is 3p. Is my guess.
Also, flea, if you're negative I see no reason for you to time stream yeet yourself at all really.
I think Oil + Flea 3P with 2 scum
where did you get Flea as 3p from? and how did you jump from Oil is confscum based on the claim to Oil is 3p?
Posted: Sun Jan 17, 2021 9:41 am
by Flea The Magician
Given i jump out of the timeline... I have "no town use".
My only option now is to timeline jump.
Posted: Sun Jan 17, 2021 9:44 am
by superbowl9
In post 2820, Battle Mage wrote: In post 2786, superbowl9 wrote: In post 2778, Flea The Magician wrote: In post 2767, Flea The Magician wrote:We vote scum into the arena, oil lives and activates the positive ability tonight, if all abilities are enhanced, we'll know about it.
Then frankly Oil becomes arena bait if we can't decide who is scum to send into the arena.
Anyone else amused by Finrals ignorance of this?
In theory if we have a protective and oil activates the power tonight nobody dies.
Also in theory an investigative will get MULTIPLE RESULTS... or at least, something traceable.
Yes because we should believe the team that gave scum a free IC kill
additionally, scum took a punt at killing Mastina, the IC.
Clearly it's more likely that they KNEW Mastina wouldn't be protected, which suggests Oil-scum. If they didn't know Mastina would be protected, frankly, they are dense and got very lucky.
In post 2793, superbowl9 wrote: In post 2791, Bell wrote:Both people in the arena.
It has individual indications for both players given to me.
so I will hurt both of them if they're both positive and will heal both of them if they're negative.
Or hurt one and heal the other. if one's positive and one isn't.
Gotcha. Your plan works then but I don't think it will give us as much utility now that we know there's 3Ps, since a negative isn't a town result
we "know" there's 3Ps? Little slip there hombre?
Oil's ability got announced, also I don't start a game (esp. 13p) assuming it will be multiball, so know that we know there's 3P stuff involved we need to take that into account with Bell's investigative. If they come up red it doesn't matter anyways though yes
Posted: Sun Jan 17, 2021 9:46 am
by superbowl9
In post 2821, Battle Mage wrote:where did you get Flea as 3p from? and how did you jump from Oil is confscum based on the claim to Oil is 3p?
"I suicide" is a 3P ability in my book. Oil is clearly at minimum scumsiding so they are scum, whether that be scum 3P or true scum. Combine that with Oil's 3P claim and I think Flea/Oil are a 3P team that's scumsiding