Mafiascum.net

Varsoon - during day 1, the only posts you made that weren't fluff was complaining that Klingon was fishing. Multiple times, this happened - yet when it came to a decisive vote, you chose Alchemis, who you'd made about one comment on the entire game. You ended up hammering Klingon, but that wagon was a done deal by the time you made your move anyway.

What gives?

ebwop: you chose Alchemist.

I am willing to bet the game on Elyse and PS being town.

This is the part where my reads could go wrong, but... I think Aneninen is town. I was on the fence about this read, but I think I am willing to call him town with a reasonable degree of certainty. Certain interactions with Klingon rule him out, in my mind.

I have also decided to, and this could potentially be the ruination of me, exclude TWIE from being scum. I do not think TWIE has been town, I do not think TWIE has played well, I do not encourage TWIE's playstyle. TWIE could easily be the SK.

If TWIE is scum, it's not so much that he's played well, because he hasn't. It's more that he's got lucky because there are so many awful players lurking alongside him that he can't help but look good in comparison.

Out of that lurker pool of {PV, MOHIS, TWIE, IAI, inte} I feel PV and TWIE are the most likely to be town among them.

TSO

I am basing my inte read on warcraft 3 reigns of mafia if you wanna check it.

I am still baffled on your PV thoughts though

In Masquerade he was active as fuck.

Masquerade, fun as it was, happened a year ago. Since then, I have seen Peregrine have absolutely dreadful activity as town (see: Inorganic Chemistry). Activity no longer plays a part in how I can read him - it is dreadful as town, it is likely dreadful as scum also.

What's your inte read, and do you support a modkill on the slot? I may have asked you this already, but I'm asking it again.

VOTE: I Am Innocent

I'm trusting everyone else who says random is town for now. I might be confbiasing because I don't understand town reads on him but don't feel like pushing him cause I saw something that dissuades me from having a scumread on him. I really think something weird went down with the hider and IAI was odd with Alch so I'm starting here.

↑ T S O wrote:What's your inte read, and do you support a modkill on the slot? I may have asked you this already, but I'm asking it again.

He is a black hole alright but I am willing to lean town from the lurkers because I have seen the same behaviour as town here

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=23&t=63530

Now he was more active there but the same useless lurker vibe applies.

Force replace would be the preferable method but I wouldnt be sad if he got mod killed

Extrapolated Eagle - I am in three minds on whether to lynch inte, IAI or MOHIS today. If the person I select flips town, then I will have no choice but to let the others lurk to LyLo, since there will be no more spare lynches available to town.

With that in mind - who do you think is the best lynch out of the three today?

↑ T S O wrote:Extrapolated Eagle - I am in three minds on whether to lynch inte, IAI or MOHIS today. If the person I select flips town, then I will have no choice but to let the others lurk to LyLo, since there will be no more spare lynches available to town.

With that in mind - who do you think is the best lynch out of the three today?

Honestly I'd love to lynch EP. But ... If we lynch a lurker...

I've had bad vibes from inte for a while.
I am innocent said something about dapper I remember not liking.
But Head pulled that quicklynch yesterday. And I feel like he's trying to get away with it by staying shut up. So. Policy lynch on two accounts and lynch for being scummy by lack of participation. I guess I would push head.

Fire and vedith, get your shit together. You are both good players who should be doing more than this.

↑ T S O wrote:I have also decided to, and this could potentially be the ruination of me, exclude TWIE from being scum. I do not think TWIE has been town, I do not think TWIE has played well, I do not encourage TWIE's playstyle. TWIE could easily be the SK.

If TWIE is scum, it's not so much that he's played well, because he hasn't. It's more that he's got lucky because there are so many awful players lurking alongside him that he can't help but look good in comparison.

Rude.

↑ T S O wrote:Extrapolated Eagle - I am in three minds on whether to lynch inte, IAI or MOHIS today. If the person I select flips town, then I will have no choice but to let the others lurk to LyLo, since there will be no more spare lynches available to town.

With that in mind - who do you think is the best lynch out of the three today?

MOHIS is still town

Why

I would also love to hear why. MOHIS's play can be summarised neatly - attempted to defuse Klingon wagon, fluff, voted Dapper, fluff, hammered Alchemist, fluff. Intermixed with a nice pinch of hardcore lurking.

I really hate having to sort TWIE as town, but I can't get anywhere if I keep being stubborn about it.

Hey TWIE - support a modkill on inte?

↑ T S O wrote:Hey TWIE - support a modkill on inte?

Tso will you vote eagle

I have been thinking about doing so, but I still have sorting of players to do.

I would like to state right now that I am withdrawing support for modkill on inte.

I also do not support a lynch on a lurker today.

I very strongly advocate a lynch on errant parabola, someone who has been rather dodgy, did not directly answer my question about his thoughts at the time of directing his attention towards Elyse at the time of the Klingon wagon.

TSO also strangely enough seems to be dodging pressure towards EP. I asked him how he felt about aneninen and ep yesterday and he spoke about how he didn't want to end day before he took a closer look at aneninen. In fact, every time I have brought up EP the discussion has strangely been changed.

I think EP is the lynch today and if he flips scum we flip TSO next.